Award No. 5315
Docket No. 5027
2-SOU-CM-'67
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
SECOND DIVISION
The Second Division consisted of the regular members and in
addition Referee Howard A. Johnson when award was rendered.
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
SYSTEM FEDERATION NO. 21, RAILWAY EMPLOYES'
DEPARTMENT, A. F. of L. - C. I. O. (Carmen)
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY
DISPUTE: CLAIM OF EMPLOYES:
1. That the Carrier violated the controlling Agreement by furloughing Carman H. A. Henegar, et. al., Hayne Car Shop, Spartanburg, South Carolina, at the close of work on November 30, 1964,
without a five working days notice.
2. That the Carrier be ordered to discontinue said violation and
pay -Carmen H. A. Henegar, M. N. Gowens, R.W. Cannon, F.L. Tillotson, M.C. McCall, E. E. Pollard, E W. Lindsey, R. X. Smith, J. R.
Brown, C. J. Sellars, J. C. Stuart, R. L. Godwin, E. M. Smith, W. L.
Ashcraft, R. P. Jones, J. B. Brown, H. M. Frazier, B. C. Mattison, J.
C. Lee, Jr., E. R. Jennings, H. E. Gause, A. L. Lee, R. L. Westbrook,
Frank McElrath, C. R. Quinton, J. T. Earnhart, J. J. Gregory, H. A.
Frazier, R. J. Clayton, J. B. Lane, N. D. Sheehan, J. W. Blume, R. L.
McCoy, C. E. Wilson, J. F. Petty, C. B. High, Jr., R. M. Johnson,
L. G. Gilleland, W. R. Weathers, Jr., E. W. Lewis, Jr., H. W. Henderson, S. E. Pollard, J. A. Grubb, M. L. Wessinger, H. A. Vickers,
M. V. Brown, J. B. Mayes, C. A. Braziel, W. A. Black, R. H. Taylor,
W. E. Shirah, Jr., C. W. Wall, A. H. Campsen, J. D. Cannon, J. F.
Pressley, S. L. Schrimsher, H. E. Vann, J. W. Mattison, S. G. Shell,
W. A. Hinson, J. H. Jones, G. E. Ford, W. P. Allen, L. R. Lovett,
A. C. Still, J. A. Lewis, P. E. Wessinger, E. C. McCraw, R. L. McKee,
R. L. Speer, Floyd Loflin, W. H. Sanders, P. F. Lister, J. B. Van
Patton, E. L. Metze, 0. A. Smith, W. C. Davis, S. R. West, T. W.
Shields, Talmage Stevens, H. R. Hutchins, D. W. McElveen, H. J.
Crawford, B. H. Lamb, J. B. Pinson, B. C. Fink, C. Honneycutt, H. A.
Allen, S. F. Metze,
C.
R. Heatherly, M. Edwards, J. L. Lamb, B. T.
Raines, L. B. McDougle, V. E. Beaver, J. H. Ballinger, J. W. Burnett,
W. E. Moody, J. R. Thornton, George Lewis, C. L. Robinson, W. C.
Eubanks, C. C. Cantrell, P. E. Lawson, W. W. Garrett, G. D. West,
W. H. Orr, D. 0. Davis, 0. A. Quinn, T. E. Vinyard. J. H. Peeler,
S. P. Price, R. E. Cason, Jack Senn, R. H. Sellers, A. W. Gunter,
W. D. Sowers, A. J. Gone, M. P. Duggar, G. W. Stephens, W. R. Sanders, E. P. Tidwell, R. L. Miller, P. L. Giles, J. A. Friday, W. B.
Taylor, C. W. Bishop, T. F. Puckett, C. E. Cassady, R. L. Cooper,
G. W. Bagwell, A. Walton, R. J. Bailey, F. A. Wilson, R. A. Cannon,
W. S. Ellisor, L. M. Quinn, C. J. Honeycutt, P. Bright, F. M. Crow,
S. W. Rose, J. B. McDougle, A. C. McAbee, J. E. McAbee, C. C.
Taylor, J W. Peeler, R. E. McBride, J. W. Cooley, R. E. Youngblood,
L. W. Graham, W. S. Sheehan, E. M. Green, J. E. McDowell, L. 0.
Blalock, H. A. Devine, N. J. Brady, J. H. Holden, J. A. Poteat, C. E.
Cox, H. L. Jones, J. C. Snow, H. O. Daniels, H. C. Satterfield, W. J.
Rimer, I. L. Proffitt, Jr., J. F. Thompson, R. E. Hammond, H. R.
Christopher, C. B. Humphries, T. J. Rollina, Carman Helper, I. W.
Owens, Painters J. A. Rogers, G. E. Kerr, C. L. Hines, C. T. Bishop,
P. H. Foster, Painter Helper R. D. Giles and Upholsters P. L. Lanford,
J. R. Pack and L. C. Patterson, Hayne Car Shop, Spartanbuurg, South
Carolina, eight (8) hours each at the pro rata rate of pay for failure to
give said employees a five working days' notice before furloughing.
EMPLOYES' STATEMENT OF FACTS: Carman H. A. Henegar, et. al.,
hereinafter referred to as Claimants, were eanployed by the Southern Railway
System, hereinafter referred to as Carrier, at Hayne Car Shop, Spartanburg,
South Carolina.
On November 23, 1964 Bulletin No. 642 of same date was posted at
approximately 5:00 P.M., after quitting time of the aforesaid employes,
furloughing them at the close of business November 30, 1964, copy attached
and marked Exhibit A. Prior to posting of Bulletin No. 642, Bulletin No.
2051, dated November 19, 1964, was posted stating that Thursday, November
26, 1964, is a legal holiday, therefore, no work will be done at Hayne Car
Shop and Hayne Wash and Condition Track on that date, copy attached and
marked Exhibit B.
Accordingly, Claimants did not receive a five working days' notice as is
required and/or provided by the controlling Agreement.
This dispute has been handled with all of the officers of the Carrier
designated to handle such disputes, including the highest designated officer
of the Carrier, all of whom have declined to make satisfactory adjustment.
The Agreement effective March 1, 1926, as subsequently amended is controlling.
POSITION OF EMPLOYES: It is submitted that under the terms of the
controlling Agreement, and more particularly, Article III of the June 5,
1962 Agreement reading:
ADVANCE NOTICE REQUIREMENTS
"Effective July 16, 1962, existing rules providing that advance
notice of less than five (5) working days be given before abolishment of a position or reduction in force are hereby revised so as
to require not less than five (5) working days' advance notice. With
respect to employes working on regularly established positions where
existing rules do not require advance notice before such position is
abolished, not less than five (5) working days' advance notice shall
be given before such, positions are abolished. The provisions of
Article VI of the August 21, 1954 Agreement shall constitute an
exception to the foregoing requirements of this Article. (Emphasis
ours.)
5315 2
Oral hearing is requested.
(Exhibits not reproduced.)
FINDINGS: The Second Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the
whole record and all the evidence, finds that:
The carrier or carriers and the employe or employes involved in this dispute are respectively carrier and employe within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act as approved June 21, 1934.
This Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the dispute
involved herein.
Parties to said dispute were given due notice of hearing thereon.
This claim is the companion case referred to in Award No. 5314, and
necessitates .the same disposition.
AWARD
Caim denied.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of SECOND DIVISION
ATTEST: Charles C. McCarthy
Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 26th day of October 1967.
Keenan Printing Co., Chicago, 111. Printed in U.S.A.
5315 14