(Advance copy. The usual printed copies will be sent later.)
Form 1 NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMkOT BOARD Award No. 6505
SECOND DIVISION Docket No. 6369
2-EL-CM-'73
The Second Division consisted of the regular members and in
addition Referee Irwin M. Lieberman when award was rendered.
i
( System Federation No. 100, Railway Employes'
( Department, A. F. of L. - C. I. O.
Parties to Dispute: ( (Carmen)
( Erie Lackawanna Railway Company
Dispute: Claim
of
paployes:
That the Carrier compensate Carman J. Ziembicki one (1) day's
pay for May
19, 1971,
his birthday holiday, and Carman H. McCarey
one (1) day's pay for May
17, 1971,
his birthday holiday.
Findings:
i
The Second Division of the Adjustment Hoard, upon the whole
record and all the evidence, finds that:
The carrier or carriers and the employe or employes involved
in this dispute are respectively carrier and employe within the meaning of the
Railway Labor Act as approved June 21,
1934.
This Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the i
dispute involved herein.
Parties to said dispute waived right of appearance at hearing
thereon.
i
Claimants were both Carmen employed at the Jersey City Car
Department of Carrier and were regularly assigned first shift employees with
a 7:30 AM starting time. One Claimant's birthday was May
17, 1971
and the other's
was May
19, 1971.
The Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen called a national strike
effective 6:00 AM on May
17, 1971.
which lasted throu& May 18, 1971. On the
morning of May
17
Carrier posted a bulletin discontinuing all positions as of !-
the start of the first shift that morning because of the strike. Carrier contends
that this bulletin was posted at about 10:30 AM that morning, and since there is
no evidence to the contrary we shall assume that this is correct. Claimants were
denied holiday pay for their birthdays since they did not work respectively on the
day before or the day after their birthdays; both employees were eligible in -
every otter i e::-pect
for this holiday pay.
i
i
Article II, Section 6 (d) of the figreeriert dated November 21,
1964 reads:
I
i
i
i
Form 1 Award No.
6505
I
Page 2 Docket No.
6360
2-EL-CM-'73 ~'
"(d) other than regularly assigned employees shall
qualify for the additional day off or pay in lieu thereof,
provided (1) compensation for service paid him by the carrier
is credited to 11 or more of the 30 calendar days immediately
preceding his birthday, and (2) he has had a seniority date
for at least 60 calendar days or has 60 calendar days of
continuous active service preceding his birthday beginning
with the first day of compensated service provided employ
ment was not terminated prior to his birthday by resignation,
for cause, retirement, death, non-compliance with a union
shop agreement, or disapproval of application for employ
ment, and
(3)
if on the workday preceding the workday
following the employee's birthday he satisfies one or
the other of the following conditions;
(i) Compensation for service paid by the
carrier is credited; or
I
(ii) Such employee is available for service.
Note; 'Available'as used in subsection (ii) above is
interpreted by the parties to mean that an
employee is available unless he lays off of
his own accord
or does not respond to a call,
pursuant to the rules of the applicable
agreement, for service.
The workweek for other than regularly assigned employes
shall be Monday to Friday, both days inclusive, except
h
that
any such
employee who is relieving a regularly
assigned employee on the same assignment on both the
workday preceding and the workday following his birthday I
will have the workweek of the incumbent of the assigned
position and will be subject to the same qualifying re
quirements respecting service and availability on the
workdays preceding and following his birthday as apply
to the employee whom he is relieving.
For other than regularly assigned employees, whose,
hypothetical workweek is Monday to Friday, both days
inclusive, if his birthday falls on Friday, Monday of
the succeeding
week shall. be
considered
the
workday immediately following. If his birthday falls on Monday,.
Friday of the preceding week shall be considered the
workday immediately preceding his birthday.
i
Compensation paid under sick-leave
rules or
practices
will not
be considered as
compensation for purposes of
this rule."
Form 1
Page
3
Award No. 650'5
Docket No.
6369
2-EL-CM-X73
The issue before us is whether or not the Claimants were available
for service, as provided above, one on the day preceding his birthday
and
the
other on the day following his birthday.
Petitioner urges that Claimants were in a furlough status on the
days in question and were available for service. The Organization argues farther
that the test in determining availability is whether an employee was called for
service by Carrier and did or did not respond. in support of these arguments
a series of awards are cited largely dependent on Award 5061. That case must
be distinguished from this one in that it dealt with a partial reduction in
force due to decreased traffic and no work stoppage was involved.
In this dispute, regardless of the notice requirements of the
April
24, 1970
Agreement, and without regard to the exact time of the posting
of the notice, it is clear that Claimants did not see the notice posted on
May 17,
1971
since they did not work that day. Thus it becomes essential, to
support
Claimants'.position, that
there be some evidence that they attempted
to work on May 17, 1971 or otherwise made themselves available. Such evidence
does not appear in the record. We have said before (Awards
4494, 6435
and others)
that union members, particularly in
this industry,
will not usually cross picket
lines. Employees have the burden of affirmatively indicating their availability
in order to establish their right to benefits accruing during a work stoppage
when such benefits are based on availability. In this dispute Claimants have
not presented such evidence, hence the claim will be denied.
AW A R D
Claim denied.
Attest:
c..'~·
Le.
NATIONAL RA31ROAD ADJUSTMENT HOARD
By Order of Second Division
Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this. 30th day of
Mar, 1973.