~i lr
~~
t-I
-', --ie
i Bw4 I'D Award -No.
0
577
JCCO1'ID. DIVT·JTMT DOcfat H' o. '41.1
2-H-P -C%i-
' 73
,~.e ~econ4 Di,ris_oconsisted. of
-c
a re~uiar Members and
i:2
r
-.21~.0_1 ~e`~.~..?'°2 L'dta'.111d
~'T. :jC1edl,.'.r :'ra°_'.1 ?war-,.
:v?3
I'eu~2eieG''..
jS'-ue i:
0
. 2, R
a j/' ""~'O~,reSi.
'Je,^: Federation i r:ra,.:.p
r,artmo .,
r...~nt,
r.. F.
o-L
(Carmen)
a?wties to
D is-outl e:
O' Fm`llO iW'.J :
:.1530'.:2"7.. n3Ci i iC
R3iW."3. d Co=- any
- v.
T. O.
1.1:'?'_v the ;·11aSOllr
1. P3C1L'IC Railroad
CO"p;-~LL''y
violated
t-2e
Agreement
Oa
November 2i,
1964 , wep
tlOZr
dei rived Fainter
P.
A. Tarnborel-lo..,
~O'.W~c.`ly i2:t--,y
the
right to work nis assignment on Wednesday,
fl
JT~ 1 ~ cf~ 1071·.
a0F.t~ui:
.'' ~L
r, - ~ ~° i
~iis:~ouri Pacific Railroad Com~an
oe
ordered to
in::.., acco_ 3in~"-y, :,._~ y
CO..'
r'c_lc,°..tO ?-''c:i:1c`'.e_'' `,t'?:alOrc?ll·O 1.:1
the
'rt',:'C?ini. O_ E.'`;i?.''. -IoIJ.:L'3
(v')
av
punitive
2'?.te
i0='
April
14,
1971, apd
lit 2;7Jiii0·-'1 to the money anount,
C n herein., the
Carrier Sh3 ~ ,u^ .~ ~ ~ una :'1
-3 ?_' l.'.1..~ u.l, i _· c._ ~ W,.~.. " 13i% 'd'Z. amount of
tDp`-5~i 8.phiZm CO:IpOili>>:i.Cd. annually on ti-ne -anniversary date of the claim..
one Second Div'_sion of she Adjustment Board, upon t%1? :aloe record
and
all tLe e-r idence, winds that:
~'_'_^_e carrier or carriers and tae e:;2lD_lofe yr em;lvyea involved. '_:z tzis
,1
=n m` r` el r a,·.i r within l;o? meaning ~` - e Rs.1,, Rail-way
~isr ,._ ~..~ _ swectiv __;~ c:~rrie_ ._ e:~rioye wi~__i~. ~, _5 o ;.__.f
:Labor Act as ;proved. June 2iy 19?L.
i'hia ~i-V _aion .._' t'_^.e Adjustment hoard his jurisdiction over
the dispute
invo?ved herein.
_'a-_·-vies to said dispute :,awed right of appearance at- hearing thereon
.
'~:1is disn-eze involves the
question or vir_o is to fill a vacancy, if the
:?va:iC- l:a t0 ~e Ii--e7 when d:1 E'::'_r:l`>;f°2 has contractual ?"i3^t'°. to t==ie a holiday on
ai s birthd^.v. The a :~i :e::ce d.i sc'! .cse:T the Clai,-nant :1a3 a holiday on
'v <''1qt7 d1sC_O_iOd that D--C::.=C'r -i. :'il
l
'J:, V-_S Old bv is
:7
17 .'? P.
or 1.~, ~~7_ t0 r°z3Orv to the =°i?'lv sho-.) and work -witb-
'1._.`. _.__~ '~Ial'..a'?t was O=·r on :115 .rli ..__.. ?.
T',e cited, ~r --cle 11, 3eetli.o-a the -Agreement of
i
l A:rard :e, 6577
'z age 2 Docket °:o.
5411.
2-MP-C=,r-' 73
rt~
._'''_i^fin~ rules :an'a pract-ices there';:'1Qer governin- whot1?er
8n
en
° worIz.-z
O:I
a
i2G`li C3'~
and the =a .^.°=lt' for
;·f'~I'::
_.ari r.3Y.med' on
_ ,r:.
h_l
iCa:; shall
a-Pply
on his bir
thday.
and -the _-Tote to Rule
5 :
1 -. i l ' TTS
-,receding a holiday
ay y
Note: Notice ~.
-Will 1' 7r
:.e
~n 5t~2_~.
°lJe ~ days 5 ~ ~re)cedi~.~ ~_ ·, listing
the names of
t'1°
employes assigned to work on the
12:3?
iday. Eea will
be assijned. fro- the
men an eaC_a Shift `riilo ·wculd have the day on ?which
-'he
U
11
holiday falls as a day of their assig=ent if the holiday _:ad not
occurred. and. ~ ;.·r?-_
ay the wor'Ai.
L;:.Ca1
_0?'~'.^.its.ttee w'll be adVZsed of'
,_... r..o-t_ecs ,,
h__
the number of men reQ,_uired and- .will furniin names of the men
i.0
be assigned
bat in even:. of =ai lur°
t0
furnish suf?cient
em.I
o;y~a to con.-Olete the
require-eats! the
j7Inior men
on
each shift will be
a331gned
beginiing wittan
the Junior Clan.
The Carrier conten^ed. ti':e claim eras procedurally incorrect because the claim
:_.-
i?O:.
-cesse
In
the ~stsa ...,.inner
On
the ;ir0_°rt~h° Carriers
SC:.SS17n
~iSCl03ed-
t~zat a siTDlificd procedure had been aar°ed
t3
for handling numerous birthday
C-ai-3.
~Tio-wever, --·ie Carrier distin~:_Llshed beti·Teen t2° .ins.t--ant clai".1 :,.,here a labor°1."
.nea
ha
t'
er n
r·
re-"
'-.
This
_ -e-placed
a
w..C..,..n1C
and
Oti!?
_.
claims
-where
a
~t<eC.
dnl
.~
reiaced
a
::~echa
is
s t t.
difference
GOF.`
n0~
a-=^e2 that ..:ere .1S a. "?8
.te'..^?".7
dlmGi2nC° in the types of disputes
.
_ ar^v awen of the insta r t , d i sputa, a s it T-ras in the raechani c r
eplaciq3 a°chunic
::.ij~)I_~tes! has Who s~JS the
"-roper em^_rofC'e to r2-:,_·'.:.Ce the i:?2C'I8:?_C a-Lid not., as the
r`cri=°_:." C01t,ei2ded! Ti-hat 2'.!1i:ir3%·2a replaced
. Tn'!e i:eC^.aniC.
her tainly this Beard '.dill ;,igr°e that' facts may be dis-4r-guishable in vacancy
_-%riel:?ncasj however in the instant
grievance Vie y:Tc-S:io_`L .tzt .._1C.er the proTTi3iaus of
.2e _ ~re^e"Ient! Iri?o "r:c2.:: t:1e tU=er e''."'l "'rF?e 't0 'ill ;'ie holiday vacancy O!7 April f!
'-il..` Tae Carrie-'s clai:' that the instant z-rielraace iiT3s prOCed:Lr211y incorrect is
,enied .
On the ^nerits of this di s-ute the Carrier ccntended Laborer Wilsoa did not
aerior- any painting 'sdllic='1 is incl -ded i'1 the classification of work stale, Mae
evience
disclosed Wilson sand blasted an enjine. Rule 118 relating to the classificationl
cf work for car-nen helpers says, inter alia:
rr Rule 111 ',4. ET!1pID.r,^s reE'iI??'' j^ assigned t 'J heeiiJ Cai.^ °_'. and apT~'L'Lit3CeS! I
emr,loyes engaged. i-D washing and. scrubbiu? tiie inside and outside o_'
^<aasen72r COaC'=e3
:rerarattory ':O pa=_^. t; t'_^.a! O_era"tors of sand C~.-S.s'.LTIo
-. 7 _. _ f caint on. _ · · ,er i ·,, a n ar car_ preparatory
^:a=~s__`'_,! ...-:13 `_,ll ..~?°_:=' :1'.'.... -;C'::?-?yJ - ieeo~7-n_=e.' a: car-en
he~ye?:'~s o:ork! Sh^11 Cc C_2.saed c3.: :i°lU°ra'.T·
i
i
i
~.ra.Td -o.
6
~2 DJC~Wt
i:0.
64i1
2 '!I''-CM-
' 7 J
i!1
the opinion
GL'
this 'Car!. -the work cf
za:2,-'
blasting
flowed to the
mech3IliC3
_a.uqer .,.-n laborers
bec".;32
mechanics can d0 all Vie work ::el~)2rs do but laborers
can not. `_'_^°_ Carrier ::eaeT, in their subiiission, overcame or refuted T,aborer Wilson's
-' a' ama
t,,±
nn a.:
never worked
i='1
the paint
Si: ' lei--re
or after t^e date in question
'!rice
i-hP1e
are
:2o
laborers ?eor;Cins in the ya.i nt shJO.
The Orsrani ?at ion has made a claim - for interest at the rate of
6' p°r annual:
COM00,1ndnd h=u21
~1.y.
1i_
terej t. is not earned on a
cl.3.~--
until after a -21--termination
bas
been
-.'.de
o° the
ciaL- j
therefore interest
i 3
denied.
A W A R D
C_aL"2
i s sustained., but interest i s denied. .
'_`ATIO_AL ?AI-RC?.D AD.~":~^:-`.` -^A~D.
By Order o° Second Division
:",t-est.
EX2cxt1T.·'a
Secretary
1;:L
t i onal -a i Lroad. Adjustment Board.
I
( Gc i
aosc-t.-aa=ie Brasc_,- - h-~iaist-ative
Assistant
I
Dated at C";icago, Illinois, this 10 h day o?
OctO:ber?
1~7~.
I.
i