The Second' i)LElISl_t'x.·.^. CCa.F.`,i:ii?G U:: e~El`'. Y1:~1L1.' .s:£iT.'Crf'.'$"S and 7.I1 addition 12:LteY-° l?1'LJ ' . Qa':^.:?LYo fst, t2 h l:i_H3S I^F%:..ctLd.


                        ( StJ~'~tti ~~4~;.if°: `c: k T.fft1 No. ? g ~ ?:.'x ·.JI·;w3y ~~p1T,ri.fxrv:::Sf


                                  A . F. of L.

                                  .1 C 1. 0.


        Parties to TO~°?Is":P: ( (('

                                  ~.t:Y2:2 f'!


                      ( Missouri Pacific Failread Co;;,pany


        FiS~t3 ¢'C : cl^ !'.s't of ST."·alI.G"!ns1. That the Missouri Pacific u ai'Lrod C;;'rpri ny ir:gxopar3.y a'bolisII,-d

                the wrecking ere-?? lOb of CaI'ii.;:Il r . Ae F'.;.c`'.Chr`.S'·.:1; N`_:'th

                ~? ir:~.·?

                Roi'? LtY'iu:u:i:._; [,';-.;-'^.::tii~." i~.~J.:'t.a:..'~i a'.2 . .._:! ;' . - t-

                                          1`) 7 2 , C1 au':,:i p t C: ' : i >:i:i .i3

                been advertised s`Faratc frc.~ his carcnn's position in the, ail

                room arid readverti:.=ed it aLIaCI:;'ad to sge·Ciri.C car.~:~anf s job, ta:US

                ~CSU:."^.i37Cj i:.L:'t w..:i Ui.:i Z.ia y::S`~:....:ai Ci? r:r:Li".'~' :i.:11, u::.i


            2. That accordin<rly,, Cie Missouri Pacific Railroad- be


r ordered to k'E.""iat3bLie>h the WYt`'.Ck:ing Crt_'".9 ;.ISSI ~(":.;Iii. ep-Yi,W''.
 _ fz lia51 ': pe f.:J17.F.L t. a tI2~.A 1k 'if Y0 :°.~j.·i L l:~j· a :3 .i4 t".:.i4J tj.(7ui r 3:f) icor_al-y
                                                          s.l>s

3 .i~ i <t~., ar-'A it!' c3:r_i.,.~`il ~.·~,`-'v:_.::ii _'i.F:v;i.v:~v.i. T(: tii:~ Eix':.W;r i:;j;;_,.z: ~d
 i~ cl fG'?CtCd by Bulletins'ls and ;U7, and Cf; i~£?I?F:d ~~` H-1:1 `i.t L i.~iC
 punitive rate for ea ch date h-- has bc~!n rorcaad to work, f'rc:a
                o:OJ P.M. to 3:3D P.H.,be!girning February 23, 1972.


        Findings:


        The Second Division of ta:e t°udjustr.°.-=nt LoE?rd, upon the w;olc reCad and all the evidence, finds teat:


        The carrier car carriers and the o.*'Ta?lGyw^ or employes in-,.7olved in this

        dispute are rCSpeCt1Ve1y carrier- and E.':Lgl;;ye within the meaning of 'f:hP.ailw-ay Labor Act aJ app -roved June 21, 1934.


        This Division of the Adjustment ward has jurisdiction ovn r the disg!Ite involved herein.


            Parties to said dispute were given due notice of hearing t1hereon.


        Clairiant is employed by Carrier as a Camzn. Prior to February 23, 172 he bid for and was assigned to won?-I in the systor,~ air brr,k.~ s',-:c;j i.zl North Little Rock, Arkansas. Ve ',,:ad al;:o bid for anti was a~-^rdcrl Lei>I'Leti:;na pvSitiOn as i3 regularly assigned !iwia<'x of ta`It' i`ior'CIt L3.Ltl:. E(i:L:i: k.!.'L'CC'.,.xl!`,.~ crew. On February 28, 1072 Carrier uLlietilL:_d t-I-:z :ILoIitimn of a",~.v~.:':;,r' wrecking crew assignment and posted another bulletin 10r tf.'.e f11i'.`'','t~ Ic a vacancy for a position Of- ftCUs'%.°xIl'."''a°'l&:r: F5`: P_r C'iT'r!,sn C:1 i~f's..°'i.'.L'Y'f. Clc.'.1'.:-'.-?Iity an; ~'21':''_I:7:i`y' t.'i_r41i ;rZE?;~ rzXl ·`-~I:C.`! bid f7:1 t.' ., ~!;'1 ` .f: , ^.~.:'·.

                              Z I9:.v i :7`" F~. i:'? ·:":3.=r:~ t:'S

        his c3SS 3.e;f1' ~?.1t i11 tI2e a33.' b:'1kt'. z'oE:a7i in order to retain his II:''.313EYS:'1:5.:5 1:3

      .:,1, fl j


._.'e f:>`)1.~I

 ~fi-'' 34

 ~, 1.. - ..,., e°' _?.,. -nos i mt:a, "~ : ) ^ a . .i .7
 .:i<wCmlii`7 Ci':.3. f:., _:, '.3 wj ~'_.xy %.d~F Cti:~.~'~a TsJlivc°:a iriC~%.:~ :-, ' ,
 . ~:i"; t % S ".`ax 11

 .i 1 -a d -a , ~ - 't i. r 7 a t r f' ~ ,l';~y f ~C
 q.C'iIL e. t t 1'£.: ~.x c:CU:C~s ~lis ._<ai1L 'c.J:.G.:ia. f ;53'C's. i'S to ~:i?2.':.:)x":i7 C::~s e'~':Ez

 brake 6:3.1:`6: ~1~7~ 3'.,~d r.p '-i hip rr ,'t t . . ~° ` f7 o --' th,
                vs:_~: ~~. :o a;:~ ; ,y .~.~<I out a w.,_- ~'a~.:.rt tr


.~ i v . __ . . u t ' ;:~ .ili~y tr:z" :3 <.::u a `':` ',i~' ~~ -y _y t .- i~7 tup ~ a 5'~ . F
 .1.:r'i?. .t·~CxL3_C:: .. :'s:te.Cl:.:^',
 C, 7, l.._Wra.C.. vi~.:~`~.·_. t..~. £v~ ., _.~2e1i:. J1 14·~'.h f- ~ .-f' .·C~` ~.Vi~3c1 tUCfi ~ CtT~d G·r'C.~ ~ L _....i1
 Of th^ CiW.:1'eu.ii::.., ... . .J ._..''s"ld .te:·.L"_ £?atA171Cs;: for ~."·mI_E:i: t;j7 1''.'-,`t.`'...a Pte=.:'t'_~I:`r
 thirQtJ Cl'3.i."srxe"1t ^'. ._ ''_';:.~.~ G^_ ?'<~'~ t3:!'=-Ck3.1`·W'.j·`u.;-1p 'e3S.~''~1',~r:`.'~:.'~rl~ l_13 i.'~°z~'<_~;'.Ci;~'s_~i1 with ti!C: a 3_i" e_'.rait:i~i .~`~'oSi''.`vTlp t",'-_ic.: p in :'WS".=^. ._ ..a",.17'L"i`3 t'3? iii l_7I:~j i? s t·aG~=.4.sW-A

 practice a3 s: -. Vt.. _ ._7 .` b, _ ·, . ~~.:.'yl ~~,.' i i.
        t ~~:? s~i~,;i-.Y. e' :~ .,~u~ .~(i,~c.j .~.·.''.~tii~.2.;7:ax.1'2 Z~i_ isa~. ~ '~ascsL

separate jobs. reti`lac:nr rt_s;3aL::3,s ·Z~·` :,~, <,.Ly j .:riv.a..t,o-n ~: 'w ;_;.-n5::-ftrT ,··vrrl
                                                · ~ ,_,:t

Cti' C 1 it~:.._:.ilt C'f,',slah.-, I r'-s f =_:m Ca Y'k'i i.'.'x^t S ~=?:a.'.-...r:) 2 3 3 1:'72 .':6.'t aC1i.`i !>ia r<R'.Si `_;~_t-i
 and h:.£: status p''_;.'S? to that 6,at::2 to

 2.S afi:v~fiaitia it `Le:z.' right: to pursue t:':e C,-,-.,z"n,1 it folic- CO, on VC1

 ~L _ ·'9
 ~i'c-:~s ._.,_r ? ··`3 ^`\7 _ y^ n 7 ? ,.a. .A_ _ _ .,~.2 _ y
      .,. ~W:s.u <_ ~._ .a._ ~ 1 ~._ _-~._,_. , _, _, _ m_._ _ _ _~ _ ,.,. ;,._.: __._._ 6~


            N 4'' C.v 3N'i'f.2i3· ~:`i ~L·~i~ ~~',,..L_. ' t ,~. ";~'~ ~ t ~ i~ vio ~:a~'s .~n 6 Ih12

or reasons 6. , r il ~ t':,., ~..,.. i:3.3i. p a.:.s av i i..` . s.~. c V C_tvc.F. 3.= J_c_:.: ~.
                    I


hClp:'_rS regardless Off" their Ci:h°Y regularly a:.~_.Le`.:~ ~:'_~.~C~it`W'y _ ·~ ~b%:"ao
 Eftf:ur£i:a 2 u ir`~p 4:'ei,)g v) S 0 7 n E3'vi ) an (i via). . _~ii::S it did not Uf`t°,~i·::'a~.~.:,J
                    w_T _ s _ _ , s n r? .


u_m:. , _ ~ .- _ . _. , - .:~ u _. ... - ._,.

 Of C:`' ?:;f?C-ELaI:~ E'~t: 4ii2:Le:1 Cn t>~:S7t;7::;c~T11; =1; 11--be air t)=~.:~ iGe;s C·?or1J7.th the G=3·~,'c3l 1i:3 LCC£il rd'%i:.~"t:'3L? £5r P?'i.7.e`.1.nT?~r by Ls:£? Cm:_..".'c::3.. Z'^°''='F:..:af'1 at the-, !·ee`~.:'ei1 Little s`'·'.t~.fi.:: _i23taiit tirWt. An ·?g,iCCt:rC:':t~. ~:'us 3."e:!Ci~;J
                                              T:'3_e=:~

enabled .J',a?iri2a L'` '`.''.,J:C the r':.':-?2:'~?[t`spt:~'3I';:`;; l:aaa;:t ;'>`a.,S :'·tSwS,`-f2a(1a1v9T~ii~?r' S^?'.-.s S;f,~f.:i.
          _ 1

          f n _ · . t f t r,t t . T l n. L : .

In r-etltsvt::!r S G_:i?f_a:.'`..t t ;.°.:duCi7.r'.EI ^tO it.,; ia3iu:2l.:iu1_.>I1 .:e :.it:`1 Lill:i .^vi.,i;~"'.;~:'
 of theCan oral Ch,ir;::~rt:

                          Wnx-n2

"In 13 t:;,c?~i:3.t:~ with General Car Foreman, x'.'T'. is. 1'J. CeQri`=,
 ut L~t~ ii~:;i:s Local Ch£ii.m`,i13 I_'-°31'1s.E3lS :rd 1 _d~:7 ','-T'^~? ~.
 u~L";~L":.wS~`_' OF `·.':~.'°;C?':''r Jc}Js ~r: _:',:i C::"it ; n·.: --:-i~7a
    a~.~ · ~ w . .i r:.~c. i l rail

                                        . .

tCmp1T:13iS supplied)

 lill2S Carrier acted pursuant to d duly I:'°C;o~.`1aWd understanding roac:-ed, with dull authorized cnpl.o37~--e representatives.

    Pintitxorzer antes ti:at fol-"-o;,?inf-5 s pr«r:mt by C1air7,:::`c it V`~s C:d4'isrd

bar its IntAraat3ozFal Union that the understandinfr-ac1h=d was no- -,n
 ttkeQpiitg with the PfsgT'c;,-^ens.'T and f`.).tCd A;?.`'_x'dF of this Division r,!Iative
 thereto. TtteraW.reS th=? PetitFG·?`~r Ceta7:W' to fiiSi'"°1sf3Ta t-a 1':.;'LJrU°=:ry Lc" ..
 1972 arrangement, and processed the clal~.:z iW-rEjinv

              9. ._ y · ~ t i9 ()tiL'3 0f t.<'~' pY'1.:a2`y pu."'. sir se'.a. £.'<f i afay ~~l :13.4~'e'~' Labor Act- and `t:..'w

Ae:aUBt:...?Ilt BGl.:.`tI e:i'f:::;i'i?iiE3:eCi t'EI''...'i~:_°lia;~:f` t:2 <rt:C:ax".:' :'? ~:i=.: Y"'Sfjiaa-if;il f1~-
 d3.tf°Y'CLtCes CCt=W:"-li f:m'?.Cn31e1^S T:1 tii~j P ~1.lsi·:1d end Air __"<°.~:c~1G1't3e.~G.:fz
 fields and OY~":Ti:.:at.3aI'ff3~..".:<s'saf:'3.:'3;~ ~::1C li f-.'.`2":.~f:,'_.'C..^.· E?IZ Iiae p3:`c: _,..'t:u."s
 WbLY`Y rj L;>.°.5i1tcS h7`~' c`ii'.>_,_2:W 'It: .:o c: i!O _...._.; __...~'-C:::e=L. s:E'J ~:;-'_? _~.~J ,...r.. ~ x t:
 ,oijJ`arl v tie canc'~,rpt o f i.' r~.G.i-tVV·ai S .A '~1t; '. _1 L~ a_.o. ~.'_.~alia ~:.~t
                                              VIJ'~ Ga...G.Y


A i ,a-~ij C'C:'.:'f t'·a- i-~r rte` a ., ~ is .":' z::$~" ·j,w ~ i i y·r,'ya r- ;~: _.=`"it'! for
 f~ ^~1~E~;. 4::. i ~. ~~ t,.t 2'~ ..:.ta. S~'G~ ~ c. . r'. . ,p.L ~ ua.(., .,i . y ..
 ~ 1 R ~ ^7
 ~~Gi~-.v .L t>IJo:I"u ,:7s t?f1.7

 ~.'c:y.] 1 P, 3E »0 f_. I_'t~ L})~fl
                                            p" _ .`i:

                                                ~. "i ~,, h° cm-, r


r%t'l~t~ -j r. 6-V . Y s '.> <_ - . E ,.~.~.>_a_~! _,y s ~ <,. ,c . .'E -e.' ." S
 C>._jJ i~wi_v> a 4L-'.-;e I: _ mx.£:ep.3tD~I 4= .';J .s.:tt. .e. ~7ii. ~'a (,.',°]~i~.i'i::..E.:J ~`i=3.Gt1.'·.''~ ~e%> ..:ice

 an.] Cl3iJ,Ltiv.^i2ii 0f ..£· n~-t.Ei"y'_'`":2~. T `~' ,^ ~ '~':;a a^..,.~,y.. ,a ' L l.. ._.. ''~-
                  'L 1 ~ O~ ~ m. :C f:7C 1;!vQ ~~ . f:Cf' L:';_.'C %itE:

dl:jY Eie=s.·1'_~`.z -, te d C.3if i C ~.-r ~. a7L :i~l.o Ff.t .'".:_ i e L~_ii~ C,:. Ja t:.'a.s·i.~L.c i:S D L'.` ' yv"%i^S t'LiL'
                                            Yi i:


F'.''~vJi, :1?:t.!( t Cy .J,,: _..._.~ ..'Li_,.J:=°~^.,,...,:Ei i_ i..i ~d._:1S] S:_'c):F~.S1~ .::~ :J_ J~:~?"...'...'i;.ez.a.~ ~ea, ..iv.lv:ii

 h'Cl.t-.:...,=',1 i_?:...r'i l:t:.. 1s. <i-.`i~r _u.~pac] .r_.]f:. a "\ :3 .. ·rr,;a :·>C^`.i '.5~,.,-j~;f~ _
                >. " .~ i' __ " :_._a ~e. iii. ~~.~_ E.i :._, t': , _-.`ia


ta'.iiet.a.ifv~. tit? .. r~`L''<t·,'1F...~:;<C l;!..i=~1~ l`If'f'_, c.~c~=C ~i::i.~i!~cs~.~'nLS ay ,, : . nd
                                              z a., ~. .


Rule 31 of the ,~ '^ ° p . -'`_. F .~^; .._ r·\,e.ri. a_T^ ,
        t:~ ~a=,I'·.6:. ~iy~.l`~:,.'t, '':?i;n.91t ~<c:_ 'C~: Carrier i°Fi,`j m,..^_fri:;:rjF.a e.'tE.


matter ClC'c'I,,`.'W.x Ef'i:hGi~, C?S ti:E',-^_._?`C;.''1E:f'i5-t::ne

            be n f3 tY 1 ~'. ~ 1i ,^ ~ t7 \ t

    r~':^Z'Ea can ba Y20 (:i... ,rvtili)1; CE3=JJ.C rC'i :~. tF`fr-' w If~:'` tai c:in31.ETvc°. I',r".'.LrF'Ci:'.'_'r° t:,'`C.L ( i


to enter into c;~1"S!,-'i^r~.s~l.~r, k':Li.:1 C:`.~i~.~'^-"v?iS E;·h: f3 local b.·n;F_"l~ a';·:i`~cW`v,'.?:~ic3f J to
                          ~ £ _

tie h;S2C contract, for. tt.rF'~.E.; a;Znro r 'r
 rixte l-u'~'~.ut_r.:T:i1t:i:t":9i. C3i li4[y'~!.T,S-ii:il"-. `Lf;.:~y.,;t;j.' in t3 fuSrilE'FIl I:::;:s. s:ift-"r'u to C!:i=d].tT:3!"TS uY..3 Ck.i 4."t'.T..°i,'·,i.",-;Ci1.''c^w'a232"ev.-`.i~.aa Lt a
-aw'4' v~n y _._` ._1<.. .L- ~ <..·. 1 '_ <' r'_w_. '.` e._.1... r < ~ ' , .....Sr^~ .._._.i..
    t:.·~ :r e.^ t. .;> :c_~. ~ ·~ ~_ ·.._ . -~ ~;.:~v

itself W a nii~b_-r of twYiationu in rec,~Trii`i`aII or t:-O:_?~ !;ctc_^;>. In
 our F1.i'.; 1.::,~,5 in is°v:~":Cd 6'ij will be fC3?:::d' _c'1. r evLCSd C)'4 isCG'_<-_nZ:c=ti i~ `.~.,.,~ `i?~
... r._ ..^ ~s f1_ r. _ .t~ .t. r _ ,<_, `· , R, .f.. _ _, p
 _... _. :.t. ~ . .. ... ' . _ .~ . _..__. . . _. _ _ _, . . - . ._ . . . . . .
 ic..% .. c· .. n. ~: ;~S_ z'~a s~ ..%av ._i. ..
    -3 `· y r , $- ma ·~-' Rule W .`.! i'_ l ~ vi ' s s·. f ~ ' a

rf'. ji?r.. .u e:,^~ V7.Ei~..^ _L`rv. O.. c7 ,L.~,.~ CG::i.~ .L.i.~ in I',.Iet°_~ and i.2tc:... ~;J .W21:?
 1.19(?..' ~ or' eat CC::t].':r:'1liT2'~f, a6-i:_ -;,8r114-
                          w i:'~W~ II 'tsf~' rD3' ~ " t r-

                                    4 ~_ 3 ''~ u

                                    l. i v >~ I", ~L: J. ~.`. E. t.. . 1 t '. v~. L

Award we stated:
                for t·IYE"E:::1:'!~ Crews iW:?;,~)','_~'S e: %. ~ i";-f,C' STICfD point-3 to Le c^;5;, ::c^..C3`

                to the first Sly on L`:a:'_ 7C'f?p-xi:.' track. _U i^._Yc 1'.T_!'!":CS ex, lr. :?


·i has biv.-n ,r~,r -.rn-?i.<~r~ ·ir tr~y.?-_.,.,. .; ~. - j.,_j*~< 4-~.^.-s(`·.3_.;i?!^:1~: ~~s~ ",.',>r_
                        -_Y~._... _,.,....~._s .~__,'.s.~.-_=,..._.a._..~ ....A ___..- .,_.a


                C_arr'Il ~ 9 i=~. .ar4:r 1'~' e C?e 1C.t.s_a"`' .s. :.· .~=rJt tea ;' .>i i.E.J .(;:: ',:: . :. '

                              S.


                .,r',',a.i~lc.`1 ~rv3ac... V'lILCqF.e

                              1Y'~yC~'.i:T.~ 'Yi;_u Fi~·~·:. , _,'.';~: ire .'~t

                                                  tl~;:.....=L,;; ~>A>']~

                Alcivai!'i9 cal large Si30p where a t_E'1CPZl, tR z'r'i!` c!^t *v:18 t"'.Ge

                                                      .~.


            (~.'")e~].tx::vl:i :.=tt'~`~.i,<,y.[~)


            lIl essence, tliE' x t:.`:'IrdS X'e.Yt7l.ed u.--n by Petitioner GGT"aZ,n...c.`t: Cg'r5.::'.3'

        rih~ht to t£' s~' lZ y Cf..^;;Tl~- ,·.,x ttl:? T?reVa ali:'S~: t"": -for -12il~ a te .s i f;

              7 E , ~: ti-Cans ~~.in~ >»~Lt._.:~r,

        CI'e't.'So f:C!'vJ'aVC'r' .^.Oitii ::g in those deC3uli]!'.o Cetx_'k.ii:'ai tii? G_, ~sG `..

        ;rU:·. va'''7 c`3brEe?i1g t0 revisions t:--~:.3ffcfVe.^'Ei to i]e =n i:i7-`? 'bast 1:'Ii:art~8°i,' Vf 'Clf? Oj:·lra`C=E3:1 and for 11s.1tLu l benefits t,~h icl: such would secure.


            The record here i.II discloses that the duly t9Utt C?I""3zfsd P~':C)~Ea~r~? Cf;uiWgl-`:;t,.

        namely the General Chairman :f YZtlti cnar and the Local CTJ_;airw,n di'

        the Organa.':'ii`(:I£!Ll at 14C.-- tI2 %J3_tiae Rook were satisfied that Carrie.-' s

        limitation of Sle:i°.a^rship :in wreCtC1I1cy c.o`.-3S eat that ,pC:It1t t0 CaI"u:,'!: :'11;:1

        rCcTUlr^a$' e.'38S1r:eT2ntS on Vie ~'dlCS Vv rail w?8 aGp1'bprli:~."'., F3diWnt-^;"_fjf.'·t,=· and

        Would expedite tia necessary movement to hitcr requiring t2iay]i , '.1`lC]3:o

        hi? i5 , a S pointed (jut a l)CVV IS not 11:vi3Y:S Wta'.-i!t with :'-tliC 11`i(^ 119(n) and 'CMC

        referred i:,'1 seniority provisions Cf th'_° Ct):trOll:.Ii-1 i:.tta?G?va!1e`. Iii' contrary'

        to filly of our ah?t?rL;.`.


        An Agreet;.--nt Niving been reached nn February 2dy 1972, C3rricr. v.,-as entztsed '`.O eff£it1.:;7t`? It and F3(?t"LtiE37i'.??.' I''3 y ::0t !'lr'~? be E"'.'..:rd ~O L>:d'Cii:4._;i;

        tC:4 1_]tifJii eiCa^.i:)rC:'aF2-lJf t:,'tivell b~T Carrier ~L''i:ai:::2t i.lic'.r't0o

      ~f.3r 7".

        ~ f~' ·;r.'L'~ SL ~5 a

                                                      Lli3',


' Pa wt r
 ~l(it_'.'-:" t ?i(j. ~(,.f_ 0
 w x
 2 -':il.l`.'"' I=z

                          A Et A :z r


        Claim dinied.


                                7. TT( "1 ~~t 7 , W~ i~_ U, S,

                                                nYac:~:rn t, r~r


                                  ray Ord:r o f Secon,.1 Eiv-T.sio-

                                                    a


      Attest: E:;cka-ive

            Sc,~:rwtart~

            NiWl.Ui(;a,1. Rail%"cav ::d"Ja:at:`('.;tt Board


      i' /: _ - ~~ ~ __. _ f~


      E ~ 1 . . ~:. s i ,


      y ,' t-.~_.r , ~-. _ -_ ~ ~ --<" '`-


        Fosemrie. B=as.^_h - aam.jnis`ra 'ci,xe Assistr~rft


      Dated at Uhicago, Illinois, this 25th day of June, 1970