Form 1 NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJTJSTPfEiv'T BOARD Award T.?o.
7+66
SECOND DIVISION Docket No.
739
2-KC S-MP -'
78
The Second Division consisted of the regular members and in
addition Referee '.Robert A. Franden when award was rendered.
( International Association of Machinists and
( Aerospace Workers
Parties to Disxnzte:
(
( Kansas City Southern Railway Company
Dispute: Claim of F~nployes:
1. That the Kansas City Southern Railway Company violated the controlling
Agreement, particularly Rule 6-B and the Overtime Board Rules when
they arbitrarily assigned Machinist T. J. Welters to work overtime
despite the fact that Machinist K. L. Kabonic was the first to
be called out in accordance with the Overtime Board.
2. That accordingly, the Kansas City Southern Railway Company be
ordered to compensate Machinist K. L. Kabonic in the amount of
ten (10) hours at the punitive rate of pay for a Machinist for
being denied the right to work overtime on Wednesday, June 11,
1875
and Thursday, June 12,
1975.
Findings:
The Second Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole record and
all the evidence, finds that:
The carrier or carriers and the employe or employes involved in this
dispute are respectively carrier and employe within the meaning of the
Railway Labor Act as approved June 21,
193+.
This Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the dispute
involved herein.
Parties to said dispute waived right of appearance at hearing thereon.
On Tuesday, January 10,
1975,
machinist T. J. Welters was instructed
to report for work at
6:30
the following morning rather than at his regular
8:00 a.m. starting time. The purpose of this request toes to give him the
additional time necessary to prepare for a road trip to the site of a
derailment at Amsterdam, Missouri where he was to assist in a rerailing
operation. Once at the wreck site an emergency developed late in the day
when carrier's wrecker became disabled. Due to this emergency machinist
Welters was held on duty to make the necessary repairs on the wrecker. This
work was completed early in the morning on the 12th of January,
1975.
s~
a~
a~
%"O
",o
4-) ·N
.\,°~- m
m
~ ~ c0
a
I ~ ~
a) m
0
0 ~~ ~ ~ ·~ a)
Ca
.z N vN 0 rl 0 ~ ~ N
S-t N :, ~t O 4-I
U S-i 01 ',tea N ·.G' ~ to
vl ,5, O U 4i .s ''
cd
x ~
eD m at 40
r-I N
·r-1 -1a O
Tao uo
i-~ rd -N Cd 4-I N
,'3 U 1
cd -h
~4 ~:
co
.. 'L,'
r-1 0 N r-I tr' lU S'~., N ·r-I
N
N O
.u
Sr`
O N ~ -N -N
Cd
N
~.'' ~H r-1 rl rl
U
rl ri
·Nr-I ~N
U
~-,r
S"''
~O.,
U
·1~
'~d'.'
,!?
`~
·rI
U
0i
r-I rd
a)
S~4
-P
O , F:
1-3
O
~~
r-4
0
°~
U·Ci
SL.
ll S,' iN Id
q) Tao t- O rd -dO rtl rd) r1 0td4-3 0 +x
N ~ ~ U
.S~'
cd ·rI ~~ S'.' ·t-~
N
r~-I ~ ~ QTSA
N S4 r-I ·ri O .S~ U N ,Cd
4-i
4) rA ;4 a)
0 SL-t
'`~ -N -N -Ncd -i~ N·
cd .. ^· O 'rl
·a .vl £14-') W rd i Ea
cn
c$ t" N f~" O S-W" U -i~ N ·r-~ O O
r ca
H O ·d
Cd ~Li ·sa ¢~ ·ri O ·r-I
~r ~4 f~ O Cd Cd t0 Cd .~ N ~ ·rO
l
8 U ·N `~ S~-~ ·~ ~ cn ° Ea to N pq 0 ~ H Q ~ ,.~ U .'~ cd ~, (1) M k0
O rd N a3 O ri N ,Q O W N O ~ ~ O - .~.' ,'3 N cd i'· Id i Sj d +:' .Q 0
St
.C Sr-1 rd
bD 'B .LO A .91, -:t I ·r-I N ~I Cdh
~ ·+-3 O rl O O ·r-I v) ,5,
·r-1 ·H .-, N I O ·r-I
·r-I 4
-I O W ,Q . ILI cd ·rl r--I U ,Q ~ ·rI a
i
N
$4 -1~ ·a' 4-1 ~ ~o -f1 x -N O rd +D Cd 4a to O ·~ N U -P ad U
U ccd.7 4-I v1 S,"3r ',N~ ~U x
~ r~-I ~ . ~ ~ U c3 5r v1 O VA it 4I -C4 O O ~z-I~-~ 4·y+4-3
~ S'` r-I ^ N 13 N Cd 14-) d cd t10
CO a z ~ r-4 N r-i ~ 'a s~ a) a~ rd t +) +~
·s~ ~·· ro-I ~ ~ . ~ ~-~> a~ ~ r-q
° SL4 v °'·r-I S:: a) x goo vc ca~ ~ ~ N
-N U ·rl
·r-I U ·n O 0 rd i 1,~
cd
~ ~ O ~ U ·4-)
rI ° ~d f~ N ~ N cud, Cd ,_r-I ..~ Cd co ~·'' .s~ S4 Id
'~ ~ ~ V ~~ cued ·',~3
H · ~, ·rl `U ~ ~ 4O-i O ca ·~ NN U va ~r Sr Cd O 0 Cd PA ~ ~
1 U ~ ~ 0 H S4 4-I x O N ~ 4
D O U -N
N x ~.' N O N si O +~ En O ·ra -h
~~·~ _~ v N0 a) ti'.U~ ~ca
~c~d ~biD -P ~ OOO ~V) ~r-i~O
a) -P cl sI cd .Q t4 m N
N~4-3 5p Cc ,d ~-Q, 0-P 4a
N'd u rq .d o u a a) +~ -P ca
r-A
a) o ca o a) ·d w r-I
~4 Id
4--l CO
~a
~a a~ a ., a~ -N ~~ o ~ ~ a~ ~ ~ :'~ ~ 3
rl rl -P fir ·ri rd a3 O Ea r
i · ..~,' rl O 'd U ,Sa
m
N O ~' ~ O · ',~ 4-I ai ·h
Cc 4-pi
m S.U~ ~ .E.W U., ~ N N -ice a3 \1O ~ $. 4 ~ 0 -13 U ~4 A ~ v~ N 4-I r-I ~ ra O
cr ca ·r-I ·rA U vl ~ o x W o a) .~ rd
p v o 0
0 4-a s., Cd N s~ O U ,Q .U ti' rl O O A a a) Cd a)
.,-I .. t4 U N
Id F., vQ ca r ~ u tz0
O N O .N ~N .UU ~H >N;.' O U U -h tiU ^ 1~-1 ,Q N ir' Cdi ·fOa' 0 ~4 cd ·~cd zO ~ .c! 0 (D O
~y'NM U c
',~d
!L4 ~ cd
ca ~ ~ ' ·~ ~ s~ ~ ·i si ro S~ 34 x· -h A() 4-,
St .i.~
N .o QrI
·ra -P Pi U h 3 -P O ·5
·rl --~' N ·rl L -hcd f-) U Cd U Gd O r-I
N o Pf -Iw-~ ·
z a) ,"3 ~..~ u) ·N a) ,·~9 ,~(a o a)
~-, lizi 9 vo `,~Ca o o rA
0 Ca r-I r-I ca ca~f-3 r4 Sr Pi 2 'd I-) c3 'Q !~ v1 m N rl FLcL H -t-:1 pi ·ri u N rd d, O U2 ·~
·SJ'~' ~ 'd · rA ·r~ i El Cd -:t H O ~ +3 rU-I t ·rr-Al O ~ N
Cd ;i St 2i N \O Ca U Cc N ^ r-A
N O0 Cd x r
l 4O"N H ,N5
~ ·S- W -Z.~,~ d ~>
st
ti O O U E O rl P1 L) U O dSf~
-, H Oy~ rl N c~ ~- Lf~ `o N
(L) ,Q ~~
~ ~ N va ~t N
rd N
rl
N H co · ·~ ti H a3 N
SU.i -h O ·Hrl
40 N a) a)
~ z4
~w i o
Cd
F o rm 1 Award No
. 7+66
Page
3
Docket No.
7396
2-KC S -fiA-
t
78
"8.
Man does not lose his turn on board, if overtime
is worked on his regular shift and regular day.
9.
Holiday work will not be taken off overtime
board.
10.
Arms
man working in a foreman's capacity wilt not
be considered working overtime, and will not lose
a turn on the board.
Approved for Local
579
Approved for K.C,S. Loco.
I.A, of M. Dept. at Pittsburg, Kansas
Local Comm.
signed signed
Edward L. Tims - Ch. B. L. Uttley
J. 0. Lavery
A. D. Burton"
April
27, 196.
Amendments to the understanding of the operation of the
Machinists' overtime board in the Diesel Shop, Pittsburg,
dated April
27, 1961.
(1) The existing practice of operating overtime
board is to continue as is except the c arnmittee or the
man appointed by the committeeman is to furnish the
names of the men entitled to irk overtime, if the
selection is to be made during regular work hours.
If necessary to call man between shifts, the foreman
will call them from the overtime board.
When emergencies arise, such as road trips,
foreman may use man most readily available.
(2) If men are needed on special jobs, foreman
will consult with the committeeman and judgement will
be used in selecting men needed.
(3)
Men-going to depot to service passenger trains
will continue as in the past.
(4)
Men held over for overtime continuous with
regular work hours will not be selected from overtime
board unless it is necessary to work more than two and
one-half hours. Holdover overtime to be divided as
evenly as possible.
Form 1
Page
4
Award No.
7.66
Docket No.
7396
2-KCS-MA-'78
"(5)
Holidays not to be worked from board but
according to seniority as in the past.
(6)
When a man is called and he does not respond
to call he will not be turned unless call is continued
until position is filled.
This is a memorandum of understanding as to the
operation of the overtime board and not an agreement,
however, the contents herein will be observed as fax
as possible, consistent with the requirements of the
service needed.
Approved for Local
579
I . A, of
M.
Local Committee
signed - Arthur Burton
Approved for K.C.S.
Loco. Dept. at
Pittsburg, Kansas
signed - E. L. Hornbuckle
Shop Supt."
Paragraph 2 of the
1961
Agreement stating that "not necessary fox a
call off the Board, fox less than a regular call (2 hrs 40 min)" is controlling
in this case. Paragraph 1 of the
196+
Agreement states "The existing
practice of operating overtime board is to continue as is except ....
The instance which is the subject matter of this claim is not the excepted.
Nothing in the
196+
Agreement modifies paragraph 2 of the
1961
Agreement.
We will deny the claim.
Claim denied.
A W A R D
Attest: Executive Secretary
National Railroad Adjustment Board
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of Second Division
By -4
o emarie Brasch - Administrative Assistant
Dat ed a Chicago, Illinois, this 10th day of February,
1978
low