Form 1 TTATIONAL h.r'M,ROAD ADJ-USTNrl3T BOARD Award No.
7540
SECOND DIVISION Docket No.
7488
2-EJO-CM-'78
The Second Division consisted of the regul ar members and in
addition Referee Arthur T. Van Wart when award was rendered.
( Syster: Federation T,'To.
6,
Railway Employes'
( Departriient, A . r'
.
of L. - C . I . 0.
Parties to Di s-Dute: ( (Cax_men)
(
( Elgin, Joliet and. Eastern Railway Company
Dispute: Claim of Erin love s
1. That the E1f,in, Joliet F Eastern Railway Company refuses to
compensate Carmen R. Rel1, LT. West and F.
aT
for egizt
hours sere=ice per!'ormed on "januaf~y 26,
1976
and Carmcn R.
Bell. and 1·7. West for tlj ree
(3)
!-,ours on January 27,
19176.
2. That the El,;in, Jol~.et & Eastern Railway Company be advised to
compensate Carmen 1;. Bell and
W.
West for eleven (11) hours and
Carman
1P.
.7annura for
einht (8)
ho~zrs at the 1)ro rata rate for
service performed oil ~~°,?.u ark,- 2
6
anal
27, 19`r'6.
Findings:
The Second Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole record and
all the evidence, fin(7s that:
The carrier or c%rriers and the employe or emnloyes involved in
tr:is
dispute are respectively carrier and er^j-)l oye witha_n the meani n of the
Railway Labor Act as approved ._'Iune
21, 1_934.
This Division of the Adjustrient Board has jurisdiction over t!-=a disp»i.te
involved herein.
Parties to said dispute waived right of appearance at hearin, thereon.
Claim-:.nt Carmen, on the dates of claim, mere also the Chairman,
Secretary, arid Vice lin,:al C1~a3_::a.n, respectively,, of the Local Cor:dttee
of Adjustment of hocal '.:o.
88,'-'_
o" the ~~Lo-tllernood of Rail,--a.y Cannen of
the United States and Canada. C''_,'..7.r,ant.s here seek coi::n:nsat'ion i'Or service
which they a.lle ged th^y perforrt,,e::. for Carrier on January
20"
and
27, 19'(6.
The record reflects that on January
26_ 1.976, some 120
erployes in
Carrier's East Joliet Steel Car Slop, actin; in a uniform manner, ~_trstfutcci
L
and 1Jart-i.C'-
%3, t.
::d 1n ...!)
'_Zt1~_~'t'.. _ll.~.. ,:OY'h_ S':.0:7"!~,:"~'.
S
1iC11 e:_"`?1?.l.U''c.S
-,-('used or
failed to .perform an,y work, whatsoever. evon alter they had received
instructions from thel.t, suPe-"'t':._"Ur- to <o so.
:laid
emiploy'2S adv'1sed :?at
they ~vrould. riot return to -.aorl> iin%1 assured that, Carr-_cr ,To,).Id irrmediately
pay them ttYbac'~ wa<,;~diac their as the result, of -the <<^~t:~.ona1 Wa_;e
Agreement, ratified oil d',:.niJ`:1''T,r 12
1976.
Form 1
Page 2
Award No.
7540
Docket No.
7;88
2-EJ&_H-C:·i-'
78
After all efforts, including those made by the Employes' General
Chairman, failed to -ersuade the employes to return to work, Carrier entered
the Federal District Court and sought a Temporary Restraining Order. Such
Court Order was issued at
2:30
J'.M., Janlzary
26, 1676.
Said Order, ·~hich
directed all em ployes to cease and desist their illegal activities, was
posted. on the bullet-',n board aY)out 4:00 f. ivI. It was served on the Local
representatives of the Union about 9:00 A.i,i., January
27, 1976.
Claimants
returned to and commenced working at 1_l : 00 A.M. , January
27.
Claimants and other emr_loyes were ,riven an investigation to determine
their individual rest,onsibility for instip-:-ating, encouraging, and/or
part:icpati ng in the illegal work stoppage . As a result thereof Claimants
and forty-one (";1) empinyes were dismissed effective 11-:arch 2F.,
19'T6.
The Board finds that Cl ai.narits were directed by the General R or=an
of the Shop early in the morn-n~r of jc.nuary
26, 19`-('6,
to Po to ;cork. They
failed to com_ply~ with his instr,zctions. Tine General Foreman also as"r:ed
Claimants to sell, an ex~.rr~le to tl,e other cr,.ployes by -,oinL- to worn. Such
a request v.as, in thc
Clalmant' s rei'asal 'i,o <!cmply
~~Ti-r~
tr_at rewsc>nable request was indicitive
as to how and why their time was being sent.
The Board is unable to find su:p.r~ort i n this record for concl-di_n;
that the time spent b;;r Claimants Faith tLe :ari_:.i n~empluyes was se;vice
performed for, or on behalf of, or at the direct-_on of Carrier.
In the ci rcumstances this claim -,fast fall .for lack of .nerit and rule
support. It
STill
be denied.
Claim denied.
A W A R I>
Attest: Executive Secretary
National Frail road 11,djus-'Urrent Bo<%rd
TVATICiAL RTJLROAD ADJTJSTi,F=1T BO ARD
By Order of Second Division
By
R°bF.ra.rie 5Y'crc'n. - l"~i.::r!.n i r~ t,ratiT,-e
,9 1. r l C ' 1
,°la I
Dated rat Chicago, Illinois, V11~.w1~'th day °f y'
~7