(

P,o-'G-Jr's to (Carmen)
 union Pacific Ra1ltuali. Ccqwny-

      (1) That W Carrier Kos unjust2y dealt

                                  i~.Lil C

        ;,C`._!cL~:~, ~. ~1. ~TE:r:':?'~.~.''1 PGNIPM C)%'"?;oni:i.'?° Shops, when to v_._ disw'O·'ad from s er-ri= on Most A 19'6 for all'-:A,.; ;'',_o~,j;.:~_.. !=,'ules 7';0 not 702- _ the t.:'7,.,. , ., and. ` n E>t'nact,Lon, _ C? .:. the 10 1', S1 r... De tat= O:n".


      (<) That accordingly ..:c: Union Oc:i?.'1C Rull_o`,d. be G:. :!ei _.'.'i. v0

      x'ei t. t. .'G t. K . 7. · r7 _ ._ f 'i :i i't . Oated 0a

      Rule ,)) (__. the _;o:"..rGlil'" A _'eemcnv dum se'.iten'sc. 1, 1949'

      YAW ons changed to . -L7 _le 37 .:~? ttLL_ )'AFC' %;. ,_ . _`''i°ct~": ."; C:S.C1, E~_

      a c>

        ~;O'G~E:'~)_.. 1, 1(~7U, i;ith all 1' ... u'i·ion vnd · .nl'·. _ty Y':' .:-;'l:. WJ,.

        j;('J:.l`vC1 .V~L-l~i:~.`~ insi'._au'-'.%'. E.AcO Ls:;,, all c1:diT J.Kt'o . a_lrowd

        Ret·1re'12!?% '111:'! LIne.. , ..::"tlt Ansui"nee ,._, FOV~Qts, pay for all tine

        lost at the pro rata f'a:-o of , - C)&, C;; YL.an Orin`, the r'ery a,_

        T J' would have earnad

        Wile Cu_sm,._s w C:d. from .: °?`. ice.


F'' "1'x.'1 1't .I c

 J'he C:_cond lV;; i,_ion O:(· the AQj'I'SW't·t> Board, upon the whole recnnd. t',-, all th;~ evidenci,, ::i.tl~s that-

 The carrier C1,' carriers and the t'.":~"J_l.'C1;'('. O!' C_n:p2C,les, 7..n-.7Clv:d in this dispute are respectively carrier and E.:'Dloye within We meaning of th-, RaJ lway h~:~)or Act us np,)roved :une 21, 393141.

 This Division of the ~1C1.~.",':i13Tll~ Board has juris :.icli10n over the dispu''v` involved herein.

    Parties to .,.._.<:~. d:LSC)u'Ge- waived right. of appearance at hearing tbercon.


ClaLaa`,1t, irz5, rcmo`v'ed foam service of the Carrier On August PS, 1976,
 :1: o11 0w'1t g x.21 3nve W J ',at Vs hearing for 01E).. -iJ 0'..7 of '100 uvvI 7W
 which _,,~2ad as

        Z~I.L~._t' < < v


        rrRnpluyc·3 will ?7r%'(', bc_ L'e`GaL.nad in the fier,'Ve who arc careless ().` ths safety of 'Gja'mn'et.ves or othe=5

Form I A-~Tard 1'7~o.'(G%:;3
 Pz::gt: 2 I)-'cl-;et T.io. '(~-L'~'
                                          2 -h P--C M-' rl6


        rrin-ll)o2diY1'ate Ashone.Tt , i_?CLnora1, Cjl C0:-.'0 I,20?Lld- Off' o':ILet7TI-D vicious, o1." ,.'ho do not cal CJ-;i. thensel`.es 1n such n manner


          1_

        thc;.a, the x'a-__rowi will n;at -be su_aject:A ,:o c1':ita.c-<izi and

        los:~ of good will, or who do not meet their perv=:A

        ~i ..P t.

        .i.).l a g'ia:_ol.l,ri .


        Rule: (`U'P


        "I'mt~i_r;~e.~ x~;?;-i M.and io their duties Outing thy hs_r~s presct`uf)Gd, r'es_ae T,TherC' required lqr ,-.ho nnnv, -_.-:nt, and CC. _ ;1Jt.'f~2-i.. _J stXUCiin" _Jr0`tCi. r< 'vI0aL" _ They .`_ 't,~7'i.)`1 or .J?J-b;;tt,utu others in their plac.' nor eaig3ge 7._11

        other r --,uthority."


    The rccO'd poovides ,.. -....e: cvNence to the Board that, as claNea Q,,;

the Carrier, the CSC'...?:-..,~, ,r.,:" absent without ppoper authority for !'(
 ninutes on M r . 3, 1976, and PO .'!7 `,!Vte-S on ·Iul- W, 1976, and also
 r`<. i ,i . ire .. - .n , h=_ ...n. dKc _ to di-.:i :e his absc=Cs,
 Clra,1T''-.nt had 2n excess of ._' 7 years' Stl_ . ; ce with the carrier a) tree 't._ ..._
 of his renov u:l_ .

    1:1: the.' cK es i-Thick '~...Y::l the bL.&L for We removal action stood

ent·i1'°2y by th,_.-,MvC's,Q'K_'o would ht= r'c<_;on `LCD ;T,'· iC' C'.o?'_id2'ration ..,_ t__ whether or r no-t the penalt of pC? ag?'a!T. r.__Ytova7 _. P:"'i service .ould r 2,~`·,~)? !,1.':~.~'E' . This :.6 , how - . ,.._°, not the situation 7 tT. :.his cw:_u.

    Clairiu,lt -as twice pic'v io"sly Y 'eriL)ved from s,_,. ,,'1 ce -- in 1972 ant 1973

and later reinstated on a l enjency M_s. Tide 10te'r renov,..l bias W
 violation .. :>: ' e . "' . s ,' ( > _
 as to 1-}-o o e·v gIc- , .7` ?° m0co' %uci, -_i
                                TLe Cal"'1C_ T' :t'1'`T E:iIC:_ ._aN;.'_~

i'ts right to conc;do_ the ,:ox°k zeco'd of the untl; ,rc, and offered the Claimamt; the oRp_rtunty to confirm. this record L-12 the
 'i.Yl:!C;,`ii~_.,ju.%1'... hearing.

    Tine discL'et,1nnaiy exercise of lenicncy by the erpinyer ^_21 !)re'v1CYL:Li

instances can poop?rly be utilized as a guide to 1-ad of
                                              J''JL"~:.-tE;Y'


disciplinary vjaction, i:!- r..X11d ~_e~ 13.v' I-^i· proven i nr'y_eTl'ias G1 ~ rule r'. ''u: i_. t__ v' 1. ~._..E? violation
 occur, The Beard has no basis on which '!o G'L?E:,`;'i;:is.ri the COTI; eyJEalce'i:~
 the C1:"v:1.Tiif',:i,: G1' h1_° t,t.C~.:L.J?;>3 0'1 J`L5-.i.J~' ~:j c.7'tC~. «i.
                                  17


                      A I4' A E; D


    Claim denied.


                          i~ r'..P.f~. C?~.!,Ti 11rvi'LPI\~.~'.~%~ir~ li~.'L....T r~,;~' 1 On 1?u')

                          BY ol.°(ll ? o1.` JccoTJd D.._v_*,_1Oa


        HAKIM ;-._.:i:iz°o~.-1 ~1~4,i;-~__=~i ;;` '.°d

2-iTh-C;L'- r