fox7n 1 IATIOiAI:, PAILii:.`t^;D PLW7US7'?'-fl-~.']T T501'iRD Award No. 7`(191
 SECOTIT) Dh`fISIOTv Docket Pda. 77-i
 2-c;R-Bm-' 79




f1:,1:"tJ.^,S t0 i)1.5L;'tAte ( (13 ailex':"_,3,v:Gx`S>



DO ,3ute : C 1a~ m of iy::plo,~ e:: ;




                                              "entry"

        fro:;l t3c.nsin2. That s,c:cord=?1g1~,,r the Carry el` be ordered to xe:__ot%'e ' .lei s _c. o

        ~tvd n~t the Cv~iier

            t.~r. ~;_°o:cps selwsce _ a _ f.~.,

        compensate him faaZ_1 last time.


Fi nc7.inaa

 The Second Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the w1liole record and all the evidence, finds that:

 The cwrx:i.nx' or carriers and the employe ox` Employes involved in 'cOs:i., d1Sp11'tG' are wS'WC·1.Ve1_y carrier and employe within the ::1F'2:'!'.'_11;; Of the Rai.lmay Labor Act as ap_pra'red June 2:i., .--r c;34.

 Ths.s Division of the Adjustment Board has jnx:isdict~_oll over the c3.j.E;~nte involved herein.

    Parties to said dispute waived right of appearance at hearing thereon.


Cl.aS.zn ant was given a 5-day suspension and a notation on his service record for insubordination to Lis forenon and violation of designated Carrier's General To.a_ce a?ad Safety :.Zulcs.

 11s gl.ca..riod from the ):w^orc'i, at aoov.'t 6:10 ay:i., Claimant's fo-reri'an
 _.s_ ~ '-'wl'· -ef~ to dispose Of c1 piece Of scrap steel 1' 7.T?~,
 a_rl:~ ~ ~-'uct ef a.no ~: a.. e:iy~lo;~ ~ _ ~: ... a
 on the floor of the Foyer T!ant boiler room. Although tile instruction was
 not directed nor issued to Claimant, ire ::~_ver`'cne7_ess too: yr~sse5svan of
 the piece of scrap steel and Ore n it ;^ibcut 25 feet across the shop into
 a, hole in the floor at the rear of .',o. 2 ba:i le.r. Td~mn directed by the
 foreman to pick ut) the pieec> of ;:cra__~, Claimant f;_rst proceeded to put Oil
 hi. .. c lfine :E- Ite, r,;.,r f,r , n:: ; ;1.<.n't
 _ a.r1`:i zed at the
 . clo.wx 1. -t.~:~ ;~ a~ uc.p m.r1,~ t_ . c _ i .._e ~.
 fO'C'irit3.n' S 0:1.'f7.CL'. and placed the piece 0f S'LCv on the fa1'C:"...,n' S dOax:.
 Form 1 Award l.a. ((91
 Yale 2 Docket -No. 7 i ~_`!
 -CR-3M-' 79

 At the W vesti~,a~tion, Cla.~.I~arlt, who refused ren,.-:se:ntation arid w9_.t n-;s~f= s, claimed that he "a,ttel:)-?:)to d to 't:h'r.~ovr the --aid piece of steel in 't;ha.t x'f;CE.'ptaCl'.: '4i)1J_Ch 7_S no ~`i:;Ox`E.' t1:.:i.?1 j 'f'^et 8,s:c.y from ~f0. 2 boiler". !V.`_'v the record s;lrovrs that tnc carltI-~al2ex to which CTla-I.maI.It refers is a s,!:-all square box with a trap CtOi),L' as ttWe top, and thc,v the scrap bo.~> is out>; ~lc~e- the Foi~rer Ilouse.

 Cl.aIz::ant elected to x.e,pxe;>'~?at hs.nrse].=' at the her r'1th, lie a_chnowled-eii
 receipt of the Iloticc; too" no cv.ccpt:ion ~eo ;,he cha.Y°;E: rlot~ce at 1-6;,
 r
 17ec`3x'1n;; 'cl.C'Cn0'svl:.'(.i;e.C: u.°!Cr_yj"s"t~:,;'irU?y of tLc :ai'Y'-Lral u:>tj.C::S and I-,v_lE:s,

 l:lent lOnCC3. 1n t11e 13s:r'.Y".i t 1L; 110t10E's L7.ar;d. a CJ':.rlc`*T.~.CI:L~E:'C~..' 2_'t 'Gr!i' I1-C'ar 1rl.t; tt)e';"-

 t} p -- '- n a ';,' v ~ ^m o ' t f
 .C rOC::C:d:ingh'zd I'll~·`1 _ held :in accordance T,rv'! x'11 the
                                      <. t_'t~E_._,.11V e


    T ho n):'T!"~.~,Yli_7a';,1f)YItF.` Local (.'.]'!w61'tlac`3.n, T'::?<._) attended 'Gl!.° hE'a,rillz; as a


x'e- .w_ .., h- i r ! J . i n
    e.~e o_-' t.c_~:-,_v~ l._,-> '3~ ._ocal union; also ~:.-~:-:ac:;;led.r~c:d t:::a.t the hea,_rl-n.` and

1..nVLsti~3;'.t7C?r~ 1'.'''.hS t!e]_d 2n a f8,v o^ and -!l'^.i.~:...i:`'i,-ltx.~.. i7:a:1?1::Y` and in 2.OCC:L'u_:1nCe
 Zw t t h the
 t`1 £; t' E C~'1 ~ n 'G .
The evidence _prociia.ced at the hearinn by Cwzr~ex' ;rr.,_ not contY'c7-'f.rted_ ;,~
 Cla1I?1aY1"e. C7d11:=·clflVt:3 'behavior 'f1=:S iuiiZ:2,~:'Y",?.r11-e:~i_a lI2 IT>z~c:C't:,c:~. ~1.:~:i~E:.L:I' be't:Tf;,3il
 the 1UT":::.:~t'1 and the ~'Or'~:;.a11t S ~ Y?C;'iul: ~;.C'~.101:5 `UC: E,.r!U`GtleY' C='.: _;~.1.0j C:O. X1''1;: ?Ct~ a:-1
 1.1i ti1r0,:'.t.I1:~ the r1_eC:_= of scra:~ '!'i:::7i'.'1 :>O_-C' 2' -feet was ui.Il 6.L, recU Vo
 of Saf-Ei1' D1lE:s and n-::1y have rGs17ItE:~'~ 'in _t1;J"_zY',`' to Ot:'-I.'-'Y' ei1'..'~710~Tees.

 The DO%j.Y'd, cons E?~;jii:'.:1'vly, does not f.-Inl t:e ]r-CIE-Y sL1S~DE'-nS1UY1 L1Yt)."E:B,SOL1~a~.E_' and Sees no ,LeaSOil to CIUbStitUI.C a.t; ~'.7_U.t':,1Cnt for- ti;~'i::3.' the CC3.?.'?'1.E:Y'.

                      A T~; A Tl D


    Claim denied.


                          I.ATJ;OT~Tr'~I~ "~ILFG.LI) ;~o.ilJSTt;L°=vi' ~O~ra:':,lO

                          By Order of Second Division


Attest: Execut-ive Secretary
 National Railroad Adjustment beard

 !g .,s .-r`~

    ~'iCv.C:~i;:LY`:Lf'.Y.i.'?"2).SC'ti h~U:::Li1:i-C'_'~3.~,:iVE. h',.._:L.S'G.i2t


Dated at Chicago, I11~ noi.s, this~'th day of January, lQi 9.