Prix-'L:i-s 'Lo Di_^,r,Ute:
n
,.1a1Tl1 CO'
NATI0:;~T~"-,L FAIZ:~',O~v~ A?JJU~`P'Ei;.' F>0`.I'D
StCOlv.D DaA'ISI0N
The Second Division consisted of the regular members and in
addition Referee Robert A. h'VaY'lde?i 
when c',?·rr~'C~ laws x'erldeY`ed.
Ay; J.,L'd 
i.vTO 
, 7
.L  ^l
1WcH~, No. `l i ~0'1'
2mCR. ~-,~M_r s `?
~! yJ c
System Fede:."ation P?o. 
G j layl?'aay ?nnnloTTes'
De:partmE-~nt, 
lL. 
F. of L.
 
(Carmen)
_
w 
C'. :i. . 0 .
Rock island a2? 
TeCLf1C 
FORM 
COT:rlYV
h1CrgO2 
ts
(.i.) Tll.w..''G' tJ.YICj_E"nr' the C'U.Y'.'r°C'Tl'i'n 
Ag't'c,a'~' 
the
the use of oth.l:i
,:i1v 
~. carrier 
1:"; )i C 
'a_, 
IW...
the use of 
OT.'t'l`:1` 'ui_<:.;1 C'.,'~':,..=:1 
! T 
~:iI.l·Ta~i1.;eC 
';:.~'~.~.n 
LYua_ 1 'i.0 pf'"t'fi;~'i
Carmen's 
,.`Oi'._ 
of 
,'.~C~i r'1" '1.m.tG.i:', : :a.71'' 
f1).e.1.. 
011 c,Ll:i.l t,.1IW 
017. 
'aC)
diesel 
CW','_T1C'..> 
at 
't::1:rJ11, 
.J..CS;`, 
forty I(40) 2:1.?CS during the j:onth
ofI.T:;r'il, 
a_G.,.~,
f
That ~~.c~:cm°C~;.n;;'s: the C,rziW ' be ordered to comne,..me 
Caz~;..en
Glenn 
!:' 07_~';E::i-W.1'' 
S .. _< 
J_.-.i'li:i.:l u--`id R. Rahn 
:C1;' 
14J^,`' /3 hours ;)ay
Elt 
t1 !c 
'c.:i .,:-, 
· v,:-id or,e: half
~'at r .
Find! n;°s
::d i.L~vc_~
T11C 
Second Division 
O 
f the Cidj`'...:it?i:oYl'b Board, upon the whole 
recap! 
an2-'I
all the evidence, finds thnt:
r;;.=n 
carrier 
oy. 
carriers 
an~ 
the 
an.~ i ~., ",r)!' 
ye_ ~  i'1 
-Ll_.,_, :,~_a ,_.aJ
.,re a: .,.c~C .. w L -il_.,_,:,
d15 
l `:1tC. are Y'Gw:p-:C;t1.4W:ly carrier c..!d r'.,:>lU'TE'. w:!_'-::1iI1 the 
.C'h1?i1.'t,.?, of t.2C
_. . r-
Railway Ybo;t' Mv a_s c?.T)~?`r[r\"C; Ca Junv'- c_'O.; .L;nJo!`-E.
This Division of the Adjustment Board has jurindiction over the dispute
involved herain.
Parties 'CC) said d:LSpK;e i^,.'C.,iVod x:Lgtli. of8.~j1C:~1.'_'C~.L1CG at hC.2'-iZlF t)1CrGOn.
 
This dispute is unlike that covered in Award. To. 7793 only in
that 
it involves the of engines by QJ-i-r,_C,,, sand, fuel and
luo a oil b jr i,~_J ~~, ~t~-ee ~:oe.d. '.!~r ain crows.
 
This Board has historically held 'G1,_':'J the 
L;1C>v'-s npr:m°i;;_T r"ust n~.,et the
burden C1 proving 7`-C claim. ,-;rxd = _ y,r · er^;_
.?>z; ...'~'?1,> c.. d0 not ~~'11~'_.':.~.':~E:L1:1 EJ_C,: ~e tt.
Carrier ~. ' .. r -~ 'S'iC~.^ ~ : ^~: ~ ' : _ .!..between between the parties
was Mlated.
'~L= .l' , the w ~ o.,~;a.`.u.~:"~c'i'1' between the ...1G parties
was MlatCd. ..
A W 1, R- D
A W h ?2 D
Claim Claim 
denied.
I? o nn 1 A;~.,axn. i;o, l r1:37
1'a,r;e 2 DocJ-cv i'·:o. 7 i j0._ L
   
~~.,CR1&'~-Ct.T-''(
 
hiATI-OiN;AL F,,~TGt;0A'D AP~7`uT~iT,r,.;,,,TT 'R OA .i:I)
  
iy 
Oi'u.;°r 
of "Decond  
'i)JivJI-Sloll
Att est : Execuui-ve S<,c.-etIc.)-y
 
~~.'i;:i"canal R~:iltt;~.;i l_dju:~'t~i~ri.'~ Boa.rid
 
.s~°r 
^~"°6 ~ .w  
, s_,w_ -es-^` '". 
,r.,.,~  ~, "' ,
.,F~S.~  .,. ~ ~  ....
~r
 
.~ . __. _ _. _  r . _ _. a
. 
__  _. w»._~ ~._
I;.`',~ 
-:;J.Y if' ~'..e_:;C"_ ~ :.U1i'L11 S'Lx'~ae. 
Vi! 
., ,.-SGa:1'~i.
y 4`V c, ' Yy 
a 
r 1. ~. . ".1.;.~, y~ ~  i. T  ('y7
 
D<.1.'(;Cd i;,'Ei 
1.17.7.0p".jGS .l_~  L.L__ ~ V~11_~, 
~J 
r1~h 
G.c.,y' 
Of
w-._1'L~i,."J 9 
-~-.: .ye