"1. That in violation of the controlling agreement at San Antonio, Texas the Southern Pacific Transportation Company (Eastern Lines), without just cause, arbitrarily removed the name and seniority date from the seniority list, adversely affecting, failed to provide or allow proper recall from furlough and withheld Claimant Senior Maintenance of Way Electrician J. S. Crawford, from service which is in violation of Rule 24 and 28.

2. That accordingly, the southern Pacific Transportation Company (Eastern Lines) be ordered to return name and seniority date of Electrician J. S. Crawford of San Antonio, Texas to the appropriate seniority list, with all seniority rights unimpaired."

In Second Division Award 12772, involving the same parties and the identical Claimant, the Statement of Claim was that the Carrier be ordered to make the Claimant whole for, among other things, "all service and seniority rights.11

This Board, in disposition of the prior claim held in Second Division Award 12772 that the Carrier had failed to properly recall the Claimant from furlough for a vacant assignment for which he was qualified and entitled to hold "by virtue of his seniority standing.,,

Nothing of record shows that the Carrier had failed to fully comply with Award 12772, or, in particular, that the Claimant was not returned to his prior and rightful place on the seniority roster. The Board therefore finds no purpose to be served here by revisiting the facts and circumstances which led to the adoption of Award 12772, except to note that there is merit to the instant claim if in fact there remains some hidden dispute.

AWARD