Third Division

Paul Samuell, Referee


PARTIES TO DISPUTE:



THE CHICAGO, MILWAUKEE, ST. PAUL & PACIFIC RAILROAD C0.

DISPUTE-'Telegrapher E. T. Putnam claim payment for eight hours pay each day October 31 to November 9 inclusive, 1929, account being improperly displaced at Kittredge."


FINDINGS.-The Third Division of the Adjustueut Board, upon the whole record and all the evidence finds that

The carrier and the employee involved in this dispute are respectively carrier and employee within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act as approved June 21, 1934.

The Third Division of the Adjustment Board lucs jurisdiction over dirpute involved herein.

The parties to said disiuute were given due notice of hearing thereon.

Said cause being deadlocked, Paul Samuell was called in as Referee to sit with this Division.

An agreement bearing effective date of Deoember 1, 1927, governing wages and working conditions of employees therein designated is shown to exist between the parties to the dispute.

Three telegraph positions at Ashdale were abolished 12:01 P. M., October 25, 1929. The three employees holding the positions and their seniority dates were as follows:




The three youngest assigned employees in the district holding positions of the same class on October 25, 1929, were as follows




Telegrapher Bowman did not exercise displacement rights but went oil the extra list. Margileth took a leave of absence for a period of ninety days and did not exercise his right to displace a regular assigned employee. Telegrapher Williams was permitted to displace E. T. Putnam, October 31, 1929.

The payment claimed is based upon current Telegraphers' Schedule Rule 3 (n), reading, in part, as follows:

"(n) In event a position is abolished, the incumbent may displace the youngest regularly assigned employe in the district or the youngest regularly assigned employs holding a position of the same class, who, in turn, may displace the youngest regularly assigned employe in the district, provided seniority and ability are sufficient, and claim being made within ten days.

In case the youngest employe holding a position of the same class is also the youngest regularly assigned employe in the district, and the employe whose position was abolished is not qualified to displace him, tie may displace the next youngest regularly assigned employs in the district, who, in turn, may displace the youngest regularly assigned employe in the district.

The term 'class' in this rule will be defined as: Agents, Agent-Operators, Ticket Agents; All Operators except Agent-Operators; Non-Telegraph Tower and Levermen.

"In event of two or more positions being closed at the same time, the incumbents may displace a similar number of employes as above, preference being given to seniority."





That in accord with provisions of Rule 3 (n) Williams should have displaced the youngest regularly assigned employee holding a position of the same class, and it was agreed by Management that Pntnam had been improperly displaced arm he was accordingly- returned to his regular position at Kittredge.



Claim of the employee sustained. By Order of Third Division:
NATIONAL RAILROAD An.IUNTMR;N'r BaARa. Attest:

Secretary. Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 29th day of June 1935.