NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTNENT BOARD
THIRD DIVISION Docket Number SG-21242
James C. McBrearty, Referee
(Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(Southern Railway Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Claim of the General Committee of the Brotherhood of
Railroad Signalmen on the Southern Railway Company
et al."
On behalf of Signal Maintainer F. Watts, headquarters Decatur,
Alas, for 11 hours 40 minutes overtime account Signal Maintainer Whitten,
Sheffield, Ala., working on claimant's territory on April 7, 1974. (Carrier's
file: SG-457
OPINION OF BOARD: As of April 1, 1974, the home stations and assigned
territories of Signal Maintainers in the northern
Alabama area of Carrier's Memphis District (Lines East), with work
weeks 7:00 AM - 4:00 PM Monday through Friday, rest days Satprday
Sunday, were as follows:
Home Station Maintainer Territory
Huntsville, Ala. (33$.9) J. F. McClintock MP 311.9-343.0
*Decatur, Ala. (363.3) F. Watts (claimant) MP 343.1-366.0
**Town Creek, Ala. (389.0) T. A. Clark MP 366.1-399.0
*Sheffield, Ala. ( .4MF) D. A. Whitten MP 399.1-4MF
407
* (Subject to call under Rule 37 - Sunday April 7, 1974)
** (Marked off-call and not available - Sunday April 7, 1974)
During the first week of April 1974, signal Gang No. 4 (Lines
East) and the
IBEW
Line Gang were engaged in repairing and restoring
to service communications and signal transmission lines on Memphis
District which were damaged by heavy storms in the northern Alabama
area.
Maintainer D. A. Whitten (Sheffield), during the first work
week in April, 1974, worked with and assisted Signal Gang No. 4
employes who were headquartered at Sheffield and worked out of that
point in repairing the damaged pole line and signal installations
in that area.
Award Number 21386 Page 2
Docket Number SG-21242
Signal Gang No. 4 worked twelve hours on Saturday, April
6,
and twelve hours on Sunday, April 7, 1974, all on the Sheffield and
Town Creek territories of Maintainers D. A. Whitten and T. A. Clark.
Maintainer Whitten was used to work with and assist the signal gang on
his Saturday-Sunday rest days, working 11 hours and 40 minutes overtime
on April
6,
and 11 hours and
40
minutes overtime on April
7,
1974.
Under date of June 2, 1974, Petitioner initiated a claim
on behalf of Signal Maintainer F. Watts, for 11 hours and 40 minutes
overtime, alleging that Carrier violated the Agreement in using
Maintainer Whitten (Sheffield territory) instead of Claimant (Decatur
territory) to assist Signal Gang No.
4
working near MP-372 (on the
Town Creek territory of Maintainer T. A. Clark) on Sunday, April 7,
1914.
Applicable roles of the Agreement alleged by the parties
to have a direct bearing on this case are as follows:
"Article II
CLASSIFICATIM - RULE 2:
* ~r
t
(d) Signalman, Signal Maintainer: (Effective
June 19, 1921) A man qualified and assigned to
perform work generally recognized as signal work,
together with all mechanics' work connected
therewith, shall be classified as a signalman or signal
maintainer.
Seniority -- Rule 4: (Revised - effective April 1,
1942)
(a) Seniority shall be established and held as
hereinafter provided. Seniority. consists of rights
in the several classes based on respective length
of service as shown on respective lists of employes
covered herein, in each such class.
ar ~r .~
t
* x.
Award Number 21386 Page
3
Docket Number SG-21242
if
Calls- - Rule
36:
(Revised--effective September 1,
1949)
Employes released from duty and notified or
called to perform service outside of and not
continuous with regular working hours will be
paid a minimum allowance of two (2) hours and
forty (40) minutes at the rate of time and onehalf for two (2) hours forty (40) minutes work or
less. If held on duty more than two (2) hours
forty (40) minutes they will be paid at the rate
of time and one-half computed on actual minute
basis. The time of employes, when notified in
advance, will begin at the time required to
report and end when released at designated point
at hone station. The time of employes called to
report at once will begin at the time called and
end at the time they return to designated point
at home station.
Time worked in advance of and continuous with
regularly assigned hours shall be computed on
actual minute basis and paid for at the rate of
time and one-half with a minim,m of one (1) hour.
Subject to Call- - Rule
37:
(Revised--effective January
16, 1948)
(a) Signal maintainers assigned to regular
maintenance duties, recognizing the possibility
of emergencies in railway operation, shall notify
the train dispatcher on their division where they
may be called and will respond promptly when
called.
(b) For the purpose of relieving such employes
from being subject to call every Sunday and
holiday, each Signal Supervisor will prepare a
schedule, on an annual. basis (subject to change
from time to tine as positions are established or
abolished) for the territory over which he has
supervision, designating the Sundays and the
seven holidays named in Rule
31
on which signal
maintainers filling the positions so designated
shall be held subject to call. under this rule.
Award Number 21386 Page 4
Docket Number SG-PIP42
"When one of the seven designated holidays
falls on Saturday or Monday, the schedule will
be arranged, so far as practicable, for the
same employe.to be held subject to call on
such Sunday and holiday.
t
* a-
~t
(d) Employes held subject to call under this
Rule 37 and called for service will not be
confined to work on any particular section or
territory, except they will be confined to their
own seniority district but this shall not prevent
their being used on another seniority district
in an emergency. The scheduling of employes to
be held subject to call will not prohibit the use
of other signal employes on Sundays and holidays
when employes held subject to call need assistance
or because of circumstances beyond their control
cannot respond promptly when called. Other
employes so used will be paid as provided in this
agreement, but the utilization of employes not
scheduled to be held subject to call under this
rule, will not disturb the schedule set up for
employes held subject to call on Sundays and
holidays.
(e) Employes held subject to call on Sundays
and holidays under this rule shall be paid for
a minimum of four (4.) hours at pro rata rate
for the Sunday or holiday on which held subject
_ to call, and, in addition, if called for service
during the hours held subject to call, will be
paid for such service so performed as provided
in Rule 36."
~r
After a thorough review of the record, the Board finds
that the rules cited simply do not support Petitioner's claim, and,
therefore, the claim must be denied.
Award Number 21386 Page 5
Docket Number SG-21242
FIIMINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Hoard, upon the whole
record and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute
are respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as approved June 21,
1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction
over the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was not violated.
A W A R D
Claim denied.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Br
Order of Third Division
ATTEST:
Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 28th day of January 1977.