- I





                    rD2rt 1.1. :·:a_"Y, Jr., referee


(3-ot'.^.er :Cod of Rai-117,m-,r, Airline and
 ( Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers,
 ( -press and Station Zn~pley es
 LA ~Z=
        T C 'T~ ( _


                (Chicago, Rock 7sla^.3 and P2c_fic

                ( -'Railroad Company

                ( ('.'lilii°.-._. Gibbons, Trustee)


                S='~·~_'n".i:T CF CT~17, Claim of the System CO=ttee of to Brother OO GJ-S320, that:


        _. lh A=_reement cv^'Jeri_nE the ho,-L-s of service and

COndlt-i.US betweenn. she Parties was 'rlola-tea by the Carrier, es=e0==1'y
 'Rules ,~,9, 4_3y a.-:d 44 at Folk Street DUildinlg, ChiC°az0, I1aln-.is,
 AUzaSt 1-, 197,7 in -~_le t.eat.:°rt accorded C-er:i Artxlr 'I. Tra'TS _-1
 31Smissir him -rC^= service, and
        2. Cl°_r=H nrthur W. Travis was not .-g~ul'y and *-as not proven

guilty cf a_1e:j°3 `liolaticn of .Carrier `,.-,,(G) and (:?? O_ their
 Gi47 _e'v=sed. abOUt O:ZO P.r., -ULrast 7, -975, on the Vermont .Street
 St..a._ion P1a'-° '_ Ts1 Illi^.c'is and
 ~_atfPlatform .^. 3_iei island,

          That lA.r taui :V7. Tra-v=s shall! be restored t0 service '.:7th

all ri= t3,uni_mnair°_d and COr_-ensated for a'- MCn°etary loss SUSta4ned
 .7_~ _i._ _. .5Pin ni^g 3,, 1975, "u-d JUbsecue nt tner°eto uL_Lli restore tO
 .^_~_i5 ~~.11JN.__ L N i
 D. O I
 s_r r_c_.
 GPI_4-I-M; OF 3CAaD,: After b21na withheld -from service on August 111.,
 1975, Claimant was dismissed from service on
 1 c 1 ^^S:
 r_Uy',~s'C _, , _ j
 1n Con: eC.:On '·r=`_h a .=O'_aU10.^. O= Genera

          Rule ,^, a^d Ganera_ll Rule ei:. r o_ p -ro:ma q,_.` .

          i Revised con

          cerning an -nc_.ent occ::rr^_"__;z, P-· -- rc`.~l~_la~n__y cC : ill P

          ....

          i -.,e Vermont _t= c S+,.r:,_., J;

          on : =,is_ 77 _97~ on ,.. ,__ e_i ,,~.,_.,_. __ ,fo^

          -_. Blue Island, I11i-ois.

          .... :.' '.S a'v==:cSS2C w-_ ._...,.a St,i__ .. _ o:;,y = o J0 12 1:'2:y2-'J W 1 vc_.J.oS00 .io ~,:..I2,^ o_= J.c:;; saSSati_· ~N. ,"w^^~ `72T~2 2~nGS p c T: vS T2 S : c.:a~_;,


I .. - T_:iaAa 72L;T Uo:12=s aJ' TOC £ =2 a,j j
          s';; ~~ Gn p^o`. JuC -:: yaq -T1"T' ~-~TU:_CU S.xaq'oi.,~.'a a;; ~.:_a=~2o_.ot.,,, 'S:"~

          C~ir po'~ SL:O3 p:,^3 ,.:a2,xi2,7 a'.:1 .a0T .Ta'CTGG^S 2 q1Ll·i i1J'LLZ-n-

                        ' phi; au i:1:1p-I'v

          U02T@ TQ=O0 UCG11 SU?U.TO= at;7 TO aSSnCJ @L~T SU-[.~np r.T TT2k TO S7a Lq-a1 Ob~nn

      :,00q at;, a~:.^ .^·.ETTy.7qT~ 7S-C71E TE7ZSJt:OZ.^.tt ;TO UO:=:pUOJ 2-0`rua= 2aSa SOI UOT-GTaosaad St20iJOp 2 t?'J 'UoCU.'aa=I2 aZ~7 a07 UCT?,2JCA ::O aq 01 UC75s~t_.:.aG paA2aoaa p'm- paqsan oaa au, a'.:.'~.~, JTU,l-1 1E "~Si:T:;.:,.O~T. aiJ,2 - rn np UO S'aD: a

          :"fLasq7 4uapTz)uT a-'u,1 aa-E .:.o aacsaq pauaCCleU ~~t;-: ,r0= OJOE StnT.i3:."2=aU:; ~2l_ Lug Ui a'.r:1GsTp C:r 2.UO=Sanr s0 aJUa"pJ -':e O'= S2:: a.IaUT

                                                  ,


        q 'aSEJ STta. Y~E I"·.:EC

        -7paC ST >>U,= aT4rTT laa.ah_ou Ism azauz 'aj~OTGU_ DUZ.lya a-an _=·o T25s=__S;p

        St.:o:.T.i2,^. aq:~ uOL-Sano 02 UOSEal Ou pa2CE ST-1; 2a-To p,nov LT ---a- S'.:-Laa

        : '007c T-aSS-7,::S 7p S:":'JT..l:ai .". 2 t7'-21: pa LC^aJ I ::-=a ~t'.c ::J:: SaTnG ~.= .ZJ-.~r -E- `.~.': -C .io-.AJ.-VV 'vL;t Pa. °.;.:~U-~= a_'4 lsao:T2^-s= C.T?:.`. :JEU'.i0 L:_


                            'aa;1paJOa'3 TB^oQG2 pU2 a0u?AaTa' Daq'aJSaz~ ~C,1

                    o - -

        :i.--.~.;C-',7:1 ;:02='c--t2_..iJ a4:, ~C '-JasSaJO.Z.^.. fj.z10.zG S21·', .za1-2= ai1+ put =. '.i.cc'k

      i T 2y'_,i2,^.~.'1~2 p:.2 27 a'Pa=,-LoJO.2 TUEu7L2-L;J G G+ Spu2T v.I20G a


                ·u· it pT:2 t~;j~ S°-..:0 U0 :1E-.7Th .40~= jC T Ij T Er iiC-:a-UG T ^o :,:'J

· pa'.p';Su-Laa put ~,.^O~T ::T pGsS_:s7p uaaq tt.TS:':O:i:a.IG vB'; Tt:E'zi2T,^~
 I
 -_ ~n~DCo`i
 L. -
 To ssCT .70 =S-LOT-Tao O- 7Ja2CT:s aq nnou T-~ZNa p203~E.h SLai"4
 1EJT :.2.'_ E Tens U; SUOTT2.`;=TqO X705-TL
 .1 Z C1 aTaT'1 aTpL2u, put
 .7 aUUEL7 2 uJ.^.S UT SaATasuaZ;= ?r0npU00 ISnu. SaSCTC~ '.ZZa~^ nr0
 UJ2a pt.'2 Saa.2UZp.Toqns .i~au~ l of -qad, aT~q^r =71.1 SSU'CT2ap a?aq,~

          USeaf".O TGua T TE O pa.T. Tnhaa s2 ~~UsL^^LIOdap Snoaiano^,

          t:


                                    ~,'.2a Lt spaaa ttrtt aTTT-


              ·pa_iqptc,zC sz GTrp ao a-C T;l: so;czasu ao S~:.BC^CO~UT To Uo,ssasso3

            pa.;qrucZc s-,_ sZp~cZ~za;z .Tc s~.uEJr:cq.a: To asn aT;y:t


                                  sN_OT TOZ S la SP-d@2 tt E)tt a TTTh


I I
              Lt~.'JGG'~,~. Saqt:'Il_,1a_s00`

              c ?a5TZ1 zacc.-n5, paE~:r


    J


                                                .

                      .ward 7=11-1 21-22 -'.=3

                                  ,.,-.,.__

                      ~vC-:et ..1:.::~_~e_T Z.m2vG'_ j


e -jas seen to urinate on the siaeva-:, fall ever on _.is bac:, and
 resist assistarCe or direction when a_.^.D:02Cned. 7710 ii=tress could
 testi;J t0 aI:;j c-oil of il the C-aimant, -or could any
 ,Titness:w~'ie a ce_ai.^. d..iistin-tiOn as t0 whether t'e ~1ain'^a^t'wcS
 into-lcated or -11. :`:o :olice investigation of, or charges Of, in
 tC:-cat'ion were disclosed.

        Mere is virtually no cen°lict in to evidence. To

determine i= the Cr^a--iizaticnls claimm '.has merit, - e e4=aence .:lust
 ^2 re:;iewed aainst to Rules o- n ?lh=ch v7.0l&..tion is C _ar'ed.

            i _ _ i.

        7L.le iv "e use C_n intoyicazLS .is -orC1iC_teC..


_erCUs _-'e:-CUs ai72rds have placed- s=e general_~r 3Cce_vted i_^..-
 taticns ^' the meaning `:71:1=cn ."..ay be inferred by.T-_-a .'~1:1°_ :,~T".ia
 1?ci-__- ate i,,rizdiction of t_:e Carr=er. A lards 'To. 2':i:7=4 'EEEisch-en)
 - ,
 ard-::.,. 2:3 i=__l='ear tJ; are =ar t=c',:.1arly in ;-'-

        ___ __ Js instan^e, tre ClaL^a=;t ,Ms ___ duty at *I°e ti

    "use" t., officially y

G' Ot _i=tOFiCc'1 S and :vas O:i1C1.°,~1y- C^ vacation, not SUh;;eCt
 ' LC G.Uty titer°2''~ ,.~ . C'.~. -he awards referred to above, as ve' 1
                F0l 71iI= _

                n as ..^.l.'`uerOS1S ~ tiers the ai~:.a.^.t Can: Ct be found in ,iolatio, : Gi vas

        1 ;.

_ortio^' c: L,.:e ~r'..le as ..o_^caliy
            -aa~nl'_ed.


            -1 - ,

i,'_~.i :t, ^7a5 or. t::e Carrier,s ^ro^er;,·r. ito c_a;m .is ::ace
 t.at .'__ .;as ast^P-into-:cants on the C2rr_er's 7prop-Crvj C',.,. .a -':._y
 U._c,: ..^.e :C2s iclLn.. C:, L-2 'DrCce- U;;r. Bu, i..._ ~~-r0.')?r ty~ _..lr~i':ed '.7E.S

                    s_p _ _ _ , n

_L`a55e:':j°_ I___.. _y.t_'C^'~ a_ ._.~..-:24 from Z_IP. C_a._?:a.''+S __ace G-
 4..
 wars. 71^0r- =mcr~snt, _... was .^.°_re as _ °-ssen^er -- ^,ct as` al: a=lC;-re.

 :7125 Claimant "i nt0:'icat?d"'. ~er^ans. There 715, a=aster all,
 C =100= : av -~::° ~._a_-"a :C .(~. .._a;J t^71`^, drir'_:S, since _ _.__12 d.^~e_3
 ^o-. recall °re^L
            s c= tie afternoon. ,.,a °:c _._d=-~c_ eIn a^y X~:i^d _r ?re-


SC - ,.r..-. ~.q at = n ~~ a n , e ) , ,a t'ne
 ___... VO _.._u..= 1.:v0_.__Cc- Gn aS CC..t.- Sv.. with ~:eSS 'J._ V..._
 c0=v=-=- ___ antisocial , t·-. cf mid Jubseaue:t c Vsc v ._t_:e w.
 e- -=.azii_cn __ _cr~i_a~_c:: .,_ _rescr='_tion r`ec_c'e and the two
    _te^ _ _ 1 - _ ·-a o-__ - c .,',.. e s'-cian:


'-.r.:,_, .. _ ___-1 S __.'7.~ actieny.`e

 Jv._':=V__J~J .~:-C;-UC_ = c: Ti_ _ _ ===.-_=a .- _ r_._ _-= .. _ _
 .ly ,1
 A:rarA l:Vber 2i;-2
 Doc::et i;1:.::oEr CL-22C^?

 rt "The rGt^he useo' rc^tics -a gyro=bit
                                    .^.aTCCt1CS

n. _ p 3 oarc _ -i-cs L'= z 'he , ^ V al.
 _ . Vr use r v_ Fa.:-`.Lrl ur___rA__r 6 c,.;,._Jr s _."`_`escr=_umC:.
C.I tn ^` n ' 7~ ~ t 11 11~1_
 -^^^ .^C; .t ;. bD ,. E.nCC.^ =aSSEY D,_ ,, G ._- Prohibition C_'SG , ._,.
 distinction ?.lade here =S a_1 obvious one.

          ),le it_-n rtylC_ieS must CC: C~uC'- .... ""°,.=.SC-'ieS .i' Such a


'i° 'r'-?C' - °-r -^a- =Oa'? '1- - C e SL;b~ 2=i, ~O -.S'1 C_^ loss -
    - ~'t . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _


CJC::Tja
he action C' t-a Claimant -- or similar action any ot"ner
 at ·..._ C=~ the Carrier's vabl1C 'acil _tieS -.resents a cblerr- of _.^..2.._'e
 and CECC-l^12 to the Carrier. 3L± t'-_- -e is no -reason to believe tat
 any member C' tae inub-is who wit.-eSSEd to Cl a'= a:t assCCiatel ^`.m. is
 ~'!' ii2~1 with t..°_ Ca __r °_r -- by a `~:-=C''^0:: _.·. -..a:.S°r.Jr_^_._ -, - 1:_^_-_C:~
 ,. t C' _
 tl°_ ,._., .,earl^^, or by a disclosure by ~:e la'_^aat .__.~Sal'.

 under s t2_.dall e _ ,..:.C t_Ca :Tas as _1y
t=a Cl?i-an-t was i:.tC'::iC2.ted. 1:15 ,.as .~Ct proven. JU~L·1~2 all __c.
 taLen lace as rerc_ted, ece-~)t taat -- instead ,.i^" ·.aa7---; s-eadil.
 ar_C L;.ri?latl^' in :ubi1C -- ,.e Claimant had been standing C_^_ v:E tram
 ' ,.'^d --ni ,.t t k
 '_-ai,='C=^ _ ?lad ~l1C:.-___f cc_'.-, with near a taC... :'fCU_C a=5-
                n

- _^17E :'lave
 The
    ' _ ._

        _;,.c r=yauaVlO:= Cl.'_1.:1 _.aS Ler__,.. As r _,.._eiN'

                                          , __.. eve-,


'G ^-1 7j ytl ? r ' t1 `,.'~~ -- v ^n G n 7` .^ T _
 4'1 ._. r:_a 1. ~Jena ·C, (`_y 1;. 1_1 '~7yu~v__ to all Y._rN_ar`: w=1.
 record __ _le re.!, dismissal 1 enle::C- rnr r
 r l_O:;uS C_..~1 ._ _.SLaW.12.'·.,. .J_
 't..tt ~y
 -T~Clat7.O^ C° Pules 't"r!t r-nd _^'Cr~tnCL..,.=.e., not ta:'.i_n~1e
 two -_'1nIis at D11.':C:1) vTCLd have prevented t^:e -.;hole sorry epiSCd°_.
 The Board, t e°_reore, :Jill .not gz--nt baC. La,',', but :v711 reC't. J :2
 2lai=aatts restoration to Service wit^ a='1 rid: t5 --im-naired.
____:G :lOiS: 'he Third Division C' the Adjustment -Card, tJC'1~e '^_
 record 2'_d all eridence, finds and holds:
m· i
 _:.a_ she _ ,_ss -%ai:·ed oral
            Award _i~..noer 21922

                      7

                        ,

                      ~oc 1_.et ..,...._er CL-22CC7


          That the Carrier and tE :~.1DICJES i::'JCi'SEd i- this dST_mite

are ^~s'oecretiiel~ 'l Ca"rier and aes ,:=_ . ^._ h ; _-ea. "'' ^ o° to Railway
 _ r."r,.~io t_.^._ ..^ _.. the ~...i.~_.:a
 Labor Act, as a=-proved j=e 21, 1_~;
          I

          That this Di',nsion of to adjustment Board d "-as jurisdict-ion

over the dispute involved Crei^; and

          That '

            L ~ ~..e Agreement eras violated.


                      a ~r A a D


          C1ai:. Sustained to the ext°^t indicated is the IJDi-icn.


                          MI

                            M=l_-.!.L al__T.7~_D ADJ-ST-= BzCARD

                            Order of Third Division


          _:.eCUt_ve S?C=^°_' 2r'J i

ATTZST

 Sated a t C_~ice=.C, _=_-:_015, this 2ai.Gay C- ~ ebruarV 1918,.