NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSIVIE" BOARD
THUD DIVISION Docket Number W-22738
(Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employer
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(The Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company
(Southern Region)
STATEMENT OF C1.AIE4: "Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood
that:
(1) The dismissal of Trackman Carl Winston, Jr. was without
Just or sufficient cause and was exceedingly disproportionate to the
offense with which charged (System File C(So)-D-533/mG-2047).
(2) Trackman Carl Winston,
Jr.
shall be reinstated to service
and all other benefits and remedies prescribed in Agreement Rule 21(e)
shall be extended and applied to the claimant."
OPINION OF HOARD: On April 28, 1976, claimant, in applying for
employment with the Carrier as trackman, completed
an Application for Employment and Placement Health Questionnaire, as is
required of all applicants seeking employment with the Carrier. The
application for Employment contains the following statement:
"I hereby certify that the answers in this
application are true and complete. I understand that any falsification, misrepresentation,
or significant omission may constitute just
cause for dismissal, regardless of when
discovered."
The Placement Health Questionnaire contains a similar statement
which reads:
"Any untrue statements made or any concealment
of material facts shall be considered and
accepted by me as just cause for the Company to
dismiss me from its service, regardless of time
when such facts may be discovered."
Award Number 22562 Page 2
Docket Number M'v1-22738
While working for the Carrier, claimant received several onduty injuries. In investigation of th
claimant had sustained several injuries while employed with the Morison
Cue,
Elgin, Illinois, and that neither his prior injuries nor his
employment with the Morison Company had been disclosed on his Application
for Employment or the Placement Health Questionnaire.
0n October 26, 1977, Carrier's Manager-Engineering addressed a
letter to claimant reading:
"Attend investigation to be held in Manager of
Engineering Office, 2600 Parsons Avenue, Columbus,
Ohio, at 10:00 AM, Wednesday, November 9, 1977.
"You are charged with falsification of Application
for Employment and Placement Health Questionnaire
completed by you on April 28, 1976, by concealing
facts concerning previous injuries sustained by you
covered by health portion of the forms, which information was made known on October 25, 1977.
"Arrange for representation and/or witnesses if
desired."
The investigation was conducted as scheduled, and on November 23,
1977, the Manager-Engineering notified claimant that it had been found
that he was at fault for falsification of Application for Employment and
Health Placement Questionnaire by concealing facts concerning previous
injuries, and that he was dismissed from the service of the Carrier.
The Board has carefully reviewed the transcript of the investigation, including claimant's state
misrepresent facts on his Application for Employment concerning his
employment with the Morison Company, and his injuries while employed by
that Company. A letter from the Morison Company was read into the
investigation, which showed that claimant had had three injuries while
employed by that Company.
This Board has consistently held that employes who falsity
employment applications are subject to discharge, despite the lapse of
time between the date of application and the date of discovery. Awards
11328, 14274, 18103, 18475, 20507 and 21562.
The claim will be denied.
As we have decided the case on its merits, it is not necessary
to pass upon the procedural issues raised.
Award Humber 22562 Page 3
Docket Humber W-227385
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole
record and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Employes inqolved in this dispute
are respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction
over the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was not violated.
A W A R D
Claim denied.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJDSTMERT HOARD
By Order of Third Division
ATTEST:
Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 16th day of October 1979.