NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
THIRD DIVISION Docket Number CL-22913
George S. Roukis, Referee
(Brotherhood of Railway, Airline and
( Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers,
( Express and Station Employes
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(Pacific Fruit Express Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood (GIr8842)
that:
(a) The Pacific Fruit Express Company violated the current clerks'
Agreement when it instructed the Agent-Clerk at Eugene, Oregon, Mr. K. C. Wilson
to work the Agent-Clerk position at Medford, Oregon, effective March 1, 1978,
notwithstanding the availability at Medford of a qualified unassigned employe,
Mr. James A. B*_mmott·
(b) The Pacific Fruit Express Company sball now be required to
allow James A. Brummett eight (8) hours compensation at the pro rata rate of
Position K-1, Agent-Clerk, Medford, Oregon, for March 1, 1978, and each and
every calendar day thereafter until the violation is corrected;
(c) In addition, James A. Brummett shall be accorded protected
status as provided by Section 8, paragraph (e), of the Agreement of
January 17, 1978.
OPINION OF BOARD: In our review of this case, we find that Carrier violated
Agreement Rules 6, 7, 9(i) and 13 (c) respectively when
it reestablished the Agent-Clerk position at Medford, Oregon on March 1, 1978
and required Mr. K. G. Wilson to travel from Eugene, Oregon to Medford, a
distance of approximately 187 miles to perform the duties of the new position.
Claimant had been the occupant of the position K-1 Agent-Clerk at Medford
until it was abolished on January 9, 1978 and, as an unassigned employe,
was subject to call for that position, consistent with the terms of the
aforementioned Rules. When Carrier established this position again at this
location, it was obligated to call Claimant. We understand Carrier's
argument that the degree of economic activity at Medford didn't warrant
the establishment of the Agent-Clerk position, particularly during the
March 1 - March 16, 1978 period, when only eleven (11) carloads of pears
and thirteen (13) carloads of rosebushes were loaded, but Mr. Wilson's
actual work schedule didn't show that it was a limited time assignment.
Award Number 22919 Page 2
Docket Number CL-22913
Rule 6 required Carrier lo call Claimant to fill the position and asserting
that it was only a redeployment of existing personnel because of short
term economic exigencies doesn't change the realistic effect. It was a
de facto reestablishment of the former K-1 Agent-Clerk's position and as
such violative of the intended letter and spirit of the cited Agreement
Rules.
On the other hand, while we agree with Claimant that the amended
claim relative to protective status first advanced in the General Chairman's
Nay 24, 1978 letter was technically validated when Carrier didn't challenge
its presumptive impropriety when responding on June 27, 1978, we find that
we cannot ascertain the interpretative significance and application of
Section 8(e) of the January 17, 1978 split off agreement since a copy of
this agreement was not submitted to the Board. The record, however,
substantially demonstrates that the collective bargaining agreement was
violated when Carrier directed Mr. K. G. Wilson to perform Agent-Clerk
duties at Medford from March 1 through April 3, 1978 and we are compelled
to sustain parts (a) and (b) of the instant claim for this period.
We will dismiss part (c) of the claim for the reason stated herein.
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole record
and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway labor
Act, as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over
the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was violated to the extent expressed in the
Opinion.
ATTEST:
al/,~(~V~
Executive Secretary
Tlatpd at Chicago. Illinois- this 22nd
Claim sustained to the extent expressed herein.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of Third Division
day of July 1980.