NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
THIN DIVISION Docket Number NS-23079
(Darrell Claiborne
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(National Railroad Passenger Corporation
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: This office represents Darrell Claiborne, a former Amtrak
employee. This letter is to serve notice, as required by
the Rules of the National Railroad Adjustment Board, of my client's intention
to file a submission within thirty days from date of this notice, covering an
unadjusted dispute between Mr. Claiborne and his former employer, Amtrak.
The specific question involved is whether or not Mr. Claiborne was
terminated from his employment with or without just cause and, whether or not
the hearing leading to his termination was fair and impartial.
The facts involving Mr. Claiborne's termination involved alleged charges
of immoral conduct for a passenger on an Amtrak train.
OPINION OF BOARD: This claim is faulted with a procedural defect.
The Claimant was alleged to have made sexual advances to a young female
passenger on board Amtrak Train 11 on April 24, 1977. Charges were filed and an
investigation held on the charges on May 5 and 9, 1977. The Carrier found Claimant
guilty as charged and dismissed him from its service effective May 18, 1977. The
Organization appealed through the agreed-upon appeal procedures to the highest
officer designated to handle such matters on August 29, 1977, when Mr. C. L.
Dellums, Vice Chairman of the Amtrak Service Workers Council, met with Mr. G. F.
Daniels of the Carrier and pleaded for Claimant's reinstatement. The appeal
was denied by the highest officer in conference and confirmed by letter on
September 20, 1977. This decision was not appealed to this Board until May 25,
1979, when Claimant's attorney so notified the Board, twenty (20) months after
the final decision was made on the property.
Rule T (d) of the Agreement between the parties reads in part as follows:
"Any appeal from the decision of the Director of
Labor Relations must be made to a proper tribunal, as
established under the provisions of this agreement,
within ninety (90) days of the date of such decision."
Award Number 2_;;095
Docket Number MS-23079 Page 2
Claimant's attorney in his brief pleads ignorance of the rule which cannot be
accepted by this Board.
He also
contends Claimant was not notified by Carrier
of the final decision of September 20, 1977. Rule T (d) clearly provides that
the Claimant "or his duly accredited representative" may make appeals to the
Director of Labor Relations who was, at the time the Agreement was signed, the
highest officer designated to handle such matters. Mr. Dellums was Claimant's
"duly accredited representative" who had the right under the Agreement to make
the appeal in behalf of the Claimant. In accordance with existing procedures
Mr. Daniels confirmed the decision made in conference on August 29, 1977, by
letter on September 20, 1977 to the Chairman of the Amtrak Workers Service
Council with copy to the Vice Chairman, Mr. Dellums. There is no requirement
in the rule to give the Claimant a copy of the decision letter when he did not
make the appeal himself.
A hearing was held by the Board on October 14, 1980 with this Referee
present but neither party was represented.
It is clear to this Board that Claimant failed to notify the Carrier
of his intention to appeal the decision of September 20, 1977 within the agreedupon time limit of ni
time limit rule and should be dismissed.
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, after giving the parties
to this dispute due notice of hearing thereon, and upon the whole
record and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act,
as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the
dispute involved herein; and
That the claim is barred under the time Limit rule.
A W A R D
Claim dismissed.
f.9TIOtYAh RAILROAD ADJ'U$y~;ri EOAFD
By Order of ThL^d Division
ATTEST: __4~Execut ve Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 15th day of December 1980.