NATIONAL RAIIROAD ADTUS24M BOARD
THIRD DIMION Docket lhmber
CL-23178
(The Cincinnati, New Orleans and Texas Pacific Railway Company
PARTIES TO DISPHIE:
(Brotherhood of Railway, Airline and Steamship Clerks,
( Freight Handlers, Express and Station fployes
STAT04ENT CF CLAIM: Carrier did not violate the agreement with the
Brotherhood
of
Railway, Airline and Steamship Clerks
as alleged, when it dismissed Ms. S. J. Toler, F-5 Extra Board Yard Clerk,
Cincinnati, Ohio, from the service of the Carrier for cause on march
16, 1979.
Since the agreement was n=t violated. Ms. Toler is not entitled to
restoration to service with all rights unimpaired, and compensation for all
time lost, beginning March 2,
1979,
and continuing until such restoration
has been accomplished, as claimed in her behalf by the clerks' Organisation.
OPINION O' BOARD: The claim in this dispute has been submitted to the Board
by the Carrier.
The record shows that Ms. S. J. Toler was an Extra Board Clerk on
Carrier's Kentucky Division and resided in Cincinnati. Ohio. Her seniority
date was March 10,
1977.
On February 25,
1979,
she was instructed to attend
an investigation to be held at 3:00 P.M., on Friday, March 2:
" in which you will be charged with conduct un-
becoming an employ, in that on November 2,
1978,
November
6, 1978,
February 1,
1979,
February
6, l9T9
and February
8, 1979
you
made to
distance UL.
sphone calls from your home to At ta, Georgia Code
404 296-Who
end Area code
1W4-688-0800)
and charged
these calls to the Carrier without authorization
and the Carrier was subsequently billed for such calls.
"You may bring to this investigation any witnesses
and/or representative you so desire."
Claimant did not attend the investigation as scheduled and did
not contact the Carrier to advise
why
she would not be
present.
At the request
of the Organization local Chairman the investigation was rescheduled for
3:00 p.m., March 13,
1979,
by letter addressed to Ms. Toler dated March 2,
1979.
Award Number 23252 Page 2
Docket Number
CL-23178
She was also advised at that time that she was being held out of service
pending the investigation.
Ms. Toler did not appear at the second investigation scheduled
for March
13, 1979.
However, the Division Chairman read a statement which
Ms. Toler had given him. A copy of the transcript of the investigation
conducted on March
13, 1979,
has been made a part of the record.
In the statement read into the investigation by the Local (airman
claimant did not deny that she made the calls from her home and had them
billed to the Carrier. According to the Carrier and confirmed by the
Organization, Area Code
(4o4) 296-4240
is listed in the Atlanta, Georgia
telephone directory as "Brotherhood of Railway Clerks, Southern Board of
Adjustment." Area Code
(4o4) 688-o8oo
was the number for the Southern
Railway
PBX
operator in Atlanta. In the statement read into the investigation by the Local Chairman, Ms. Tol
PBX
operator was because Ms. Toler, according to her statement., had
"lost Mr. Muller's number."
The calls made did not concern railroad business. They were
strictly personal calls, made and charged to the Carrier without authority
of any Carrier official. The allegation of any inter-relationship between
the (terrier and the Organization is not credible. We consider claimant's
actions as attempts to defraud the carrier. Also, we consider claimant's
failure to attend either of the two investigations, where she would be
subject to questioning by officers of the Carrier and representatives of
the Organisation, to be derelict. (Award
15059).
There is no proper basis for the Board to interfere with the
discipline imposed by the Carrier. The claim of the Carrier will be
sustained.
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, after giving the
parties to this dispute due notice of hearing thereon, and upon
the whole record and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway Labor
Acts as approved June 21,
1934;
Met this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction
over the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was not violated.
Award Number 23252 page
3
Docket Number CL-23178
A W A R D
The dismissal of Ms. S. J. Toler is upheld.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSMKENT BOARD
By Order of Third Division
ATTEST.
PAA1.&t
Dated at Chicago,, Illinois, this 15th day of April 1981.