NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
TRIRI) DIVISION Docket Number CL-23986
Brotherhood of Railway, Airline and Steamship Clerks,
Freight Handlers, Express and Station Employes
PARTIES TD DISPUTE-
Elgin, Joliet and Eastern Railway Company
STATEMENT OF
GLAIHI: Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood
(GL-9437) that:
1. Carrier violated the effective Clerks' Agreement when it failed
to allow Clerk G. Lepper fifteen (15) days' pay as sick leave allowance at the
rate of her former position AC-923, Senior Timekeeper, for the period of
January 2 through January 22, 1980.
2. Carrier shall now be required to pay Clerk G. Lepper (her estate)
fifteen
(15)
days' pay as sick leave allowance for the period of January 2
through January 22, 1980.
OPINION OF BOARD: On September 18 1979,9 claimant began an extended leave
due to illness. She was never able to return to her posi
tion as a Senior Timekeeper and she passed away on February 11, 1980. Claimant
had been employed by the Carrier four more than ten years. The Organization
brings this claim, on her behalf and on behalf of her estate, for fifteen days
of sick leave pay covering the fifteen work days in the period from January 2,
1980 through January 22, 1980.
Rule 56(a) of the applicable agreement which controls this dispute
states:
"(a) Employes covered by this agreement shall be allowed
sick live with pay during each calendar year as
follows:
,.-,~ ::..1.- Employes oyes who on January lst have been in service
_. one'(l)year and less than ten (10) years, ten (10)
working days.
2. · Employee who on January let have been in service
ten 10 s of (sic) over, fifteen (15) working
. · ~.':='' days. Eaphasis added.)
The Organization contends that under prior awards interpreting Rule 56
on this property, claimant was entitled to sick leave pay for the first fifteen
working days in 1980 even though she never actually performed work during 1980.
See Third Division Awards No. 21478 (Eischen); No. 22914 (rasher). The Carrier
contends the claimant was not an employe$ within the meaning of Rule
56,
during
1980 because she never returned to her assigned. position after September 18, 1979.
Also, the Carrier contends that there is no language in Rule
56
which provides
for disbursement of sick leave pay to the estate of a former employee
Award Number 23486
Docket Number CL-23986
Page 2
During the period from January 2, 1980 through January 22., 1980..
claimant was in the service and an employe of the Carrier. Since she had more
than ten years of service,, she accrued a right to receive sick leave y
beginning on January 2p 1980. Third Division Award No. 22194 (Kasherr. Her
claim for sick pay is not cancelled merely because she never returned to work
during 1980 since she had an absolute right to receive the fifteen days of pay
as of January 22, 1980.
Similarly,* claimant's right to a sick leave allowance did not expire
upon her death. The Carrier has cited agreements on other properties which
specifically provide for payment of accrued but unused sick leave pay to the
estate or beneficiary of a deceased employee While we question the relevance
of these other agreements, we note that the sections cited by the Carrier con.
cern the employer's obligations upon the death of an employee None of the provisions address the iss
employe gained a right to receive payment while still living.
We will., therefore compel the Carrier to pay the claimant's estate
fifteen days of sick leave pay for the period from January 2., 1980 through
January 22, 1980.
FILLINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board.. upon the whole
record and all the evidence., finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Eaployes involved in this dispute
are respectively Carrier and Employee within the meeaing of the Railway
labor Actp as approved June 21,, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over
the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was violated.
A W A R D
Claim sustained.
~CE 0
'JAN 2 5 llgg2
~~c°8o
Office. - S~
NATIONAL
RAILROAD A
aTI15
By Order of Third Division
FScecutive Secretary
Dated at Chicago Illinois this 8th day of January 1982.