NATIONAL RAILROAD AWLETUNT
BOARD
THIRD
DIVISION
Docket Number
NW-238y4
(Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employee
PARTIES TO DISPUTE :
(Rev Orleans Public Belt Psilraad
STATRUN'1' CF Q.Aat: "Claim of the System Cmittee of the Brotherhood that:
(1) The diaissal of Trackman Horace Thornton fair allegedly
being 'amble to perform the assigned duties as Trackman, vas without dust
and sufficient canoe (Carrier's File
013.7).
(2) Trackman Horace Thornton shall be reinstated with seniority
and all other rights unimpaired cad he shall be compensated for all wage
loss suffered."
OPIlfI01A OP' BOARD: tlaimiant had been employed an a trackman on August
27j,
1979.
and was dismissed from the service by the foreman
on November
30, 1979,
for unsatisfactory service sad befog noble to perform
the duties of a trackman. Following
claimant's
dismissal, a hearing was held
on January
3j, 1980,
and on January
17,, 1980p
his dismissal was affirmed*
A copy of the transcript of the hearing held on January
3, 1980,
hoe bees made s part of the retard. We have reviewed the transcript and find
that the hearing was conducted in a fair sad impartial senner. The record
share that claimant was dismissed after approo:isats7y nicety days service.
A review of the transcript of the hearing shah substantial evidence
that
claimant
was cot able to satisfactorily perform the work of a trackman
and that he performed his work in an unsafe censer.
Hosed on the satire record, there is m proper basis for interfering
with Carrier's nation, which we first was not arbitrary, capricious or in bad
faith.
FINDMSs The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole
record
obi
ell the evidences finds ate, holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
Award Number
23526
page
2
Docket Number
W-23894
That the (terrier and the Beoploym involved in thin dispute
are respectively Carrier sad ftplayes within the awning of the Railway
Labor Acts as approved June 21,
1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has Jurisdiction over
the dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement vas not violated.
A W A R D
Claim denied.
I(A3TOSAL RAIESAD ADJI]82='! HQAlD
By Under of Third Division
ATM?:
Itzscutive secretary
Dated at mioagos, nlinoiss this
26th
day of February
1982.
..- -y =
J
. . ~· r ' ` .,,
c:.
~~/~~.`O
C~