NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
THIRD DIVISION Docket Number MW-24186
Edward L. Suntrup, Referee
(Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employee
PARTIES TO DISPUTE :
(Seaboard Coast Line Railroad Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: "Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood that:
(1) The dismissal of Trackman B. R. Holden for alleged violation of
'General Rule 18' was without just and sufficient cause (System File C-4(13)-BRH/1239(sa-23) H)&midd
' (2) The claimant shall be reinstated with seniority and all other
rights unimpaired, his record be cleared and he shall be compensated for all
wage lose suffered."
OPINION OF BOARD: Claimant entered service of the Carrier as a trackman on
August 7, 1978. On January 10, 1980 Claimant received notice
to attend an investigation on January 15, 1980 to determine whether he had
violated a portion of General Rule 18 of the Safety Rules Book for Engineering
and Maintenance of Way Employees. Rule 18 reads, in pertinent part:
" . dishonesty
...
(or)
...
making false statements
...
will subject the offender to dismissal."
Specifically, a routine investigation by Carrier after Claimant had sustained a
back injury while installing croastiea on March
6,
1979 led Carrier to charge
that Claimant made a false statement, as this related to prior back injuries, on
his employment application. On January 25, 1980 Claimant was notified by Carrier
that he had been found guilty as charged and that he was being dismissed from
service.
A review of the hearing transcript and supporting evidence shows that
Claimant did have back injury problems prior to his employment with the Carrier
and that he did, in fact, conceal this on his employment application. There is,
indisputably, sufficient substantial evidence to indicate thatj;he Claimant is
guilty as charged. The Board also notes that irrespective of whether.Claimant
thought this information related to his prior medical history was important to
the Carrier or not, Carrier did have a right to know about Claimant's prior
medical problems in order to both protect itself from potential liability and
(given the nature of the job of trackman) to protect Claimant himself from
potential injury. Indeed, this is the spirit of the following Article which is
found in the parties' National Agreement of October 30, 1978. This Article reads:
"An employee who has been accepted for employment in .-
accordance with Section 1 will not be terminated or
disciplined by the Carrier for furnishing incorrect
information in connection with an application for
Award Number 247.21. Page 2
Docket Number MW-24186
employment or for withholding information therefrom unless
the information involved was of such a nature that the
employee would not have been hired if the carrier had had
timely knowledge of it."
It was observed by Carrier's Director of Labor Relations in response to Organization's
appeal on property that upon review of Claimant's actual medical background
Carrier's Chief Medical Officer advised that he would not have approved Claimant
for employment as a trackman in the first place. 7n this instance, the Board
has no reason to denigrate this professional opinion as Organization suggests
it should be in its ex parts submission.
The National Railroad Adjustment Board has a lengthy tradition whereby
it has held a firm position on the severity of falsifying employment applications
(See First Division Award 21979; Second Division Awards 1931 and 5959 inter alia);
in the present case, the Board sees no imperative to diverge from this tradition
and it will not disturb Carrier's position on this matter.
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Hoard, upon the whole record and
all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Employee involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act,
as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Boaz`d has jurisdiction over the
dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was not violated.
A W A R D -- ' ----
Claim denied.
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of Third Division
Attest: Acting Executive Secretary
National Railroad Adjustm-rr7ent Boa
`By , .~.e-. -,~.c.i .~
Lz~
Rosemarie Branch - Administrative Assistant
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 14th day of January 1983.