NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
THIRD DIVISION Docket Number SG-23873
Carlton R. Sickles, Referee
(Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railroad Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: "Claims of the General Committee of the Brotherhood of
Railroad Signalmen on the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific
Railroad Company:
Claim No. 1
Claim for eight (8) hours' pay for Labor Day, September 3, 1979, for
all maintainers under the jurisdiction of Signal Supervisor A. M. Smith on
August 28, 1979. General Chairman file: AV-G-292. Carrier file: L-13o-643
Claim No. 2
Claim for eight (8) hours' pay for Labor Day, September 3, 1979, for
all employees on Gangs 1-3 and 4, and on Crews 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 on
August 28, 1979. General Chairman file: AV-G-285. Carrier file: L-130-638
Claim No. 3
Claim for eight (8) hours' pay for Labor Day, September 3, 1979, for all
members on Gang No. 9 (Silvis Signal Shop) on August 28, 1979. General Chairman
file: AV-G-286. Carrier file: L-130-641
Claim No. 4
Claim for eight (8) hours' holiday pay for labor Day, September 3,
1979, for all signal maintainers and testmen working on the Missouri-Kansas
Division on August 28, 1979. General Chairman file: AV-G-287. Carrier file:
L-13o-639
Claim No. 5
Claim for eight (8) hours' holiday pay for Labor Day, September
3,
1979,
for all signal maintainers and testmen working on the Southern Division. General
Chairman file: AV-G-288. Carrier file: L-130-640
Claim No. 6
Claim for eight (8) hours' holiday pay for Labor Day, September 3, 1979,
for all signal employees on the Illinois Division on August 28, 1979. General
Chairman file: AV-G-291. Carrier file: L-130-642"
Award Number
24505
Page
2
Docket Number
SG-23$73
OPINION OF BOARD: An initial question has been raised by the Carrier as to
the jurisdiction of this Board to resolve this matter. An
order was handed down by the United States District Court in
1980
in connection
with bankruptcy proceedings at which time the Carrier was ordered to liquidate.
The Carrier alleges that it has not existed as a Carrier since the date of that
order and, therefore, it is no longer under the jurisdiction of the Railway
Labor Act. It further concludes that this Board has no jurisdiction in this
matter. This procedural issue has been raised by the Carrier in previous matters,
and the Board has consistently ruled that the Carrier is subject to the jurisdiction
of this Board. We accept the rationale of the Awards involved and will conclude
that the Board does have jurisdiction to consider this matter and will, therefore,
proceed to evaluate the merits of the issues raised (See Second Division Awards
8970,
9204, 9314)
The Claimants herein seek eight hours' pay for Labor Day, September
3,
1979
pursuant to Rule
16,
Section
3
of the Agreement between the parties. Rule
16
incorporates the National Holiday Agreement of August 1,
1954
as amended. The Ogrrier had not paid the Claimants involved because the Claimants had not satisf
condition of the agreement which required that, under these circumstances, the
employes would have had to have been available for work on the day before and the
day after Labor Day.
The Carrier alleges that these Claimants were not available for employment because immediately u
Carrier then concludes that these Claimants, as furloughed employes, were not
available for work on the days involved. Further, the Carrier has denied these
claims because some of the Claimants were monthly rated and are not entitled to
separate holiday compensation.
The Carrier is aware of many prior Awards of this Board which are
possibly contrary to its position but suggests that in the case at hand new
ground needs to be broken.
We have examined the two Awards cited by the Organization
(20269
and
20427)
as well as the Awards cited on behalf of the Carrier. Both of these
Awards involved vacation pay for birthdays. In each instance, the Claimants'
positions were abolished because of a strike by another Organization. Both
Awards concluded that the provisions in the agreement apply classifying the
employes as "other than regularly-assigned employees".
The specific language in the rules to be interpreted is the provision
which provides "such employee is available for service" and the note which
follows which provided that "available" as used in Subsection (ii) above is
x~,;
interpreted by the parties to mean that "an employe is available unless he laid
off of his own accord or does not e;.Trl and to a call, pursuant to the rules of the
applicable agreement, for service. Emphasis added.)
The Carrier is, in effect, alleging that the provision of this portion
of the Agreement should not be applied to a furloughed employe and that under
these circumstances the employe would not be available because even if he were
not furloughed, he would not report to work because of the time-honored tradition
among the affected labor organizations not to cross a picket line.
Award Number 24505 Page 3
Docket Number SG-23873
The holiday pay for monthly rated employees is computed in separate
sections of the National Holiday Agreement and is not governed by Section 3
which is the claim here. We are inclined to support the two Awards cited by
the labor organization. This Board feels that, in this instance, we are limited
by the terms of the Agreement which has specifically defined what is meant by
the term "available" and since, pursuant to that definition, the
Claimants
herein did not lay off of their own accord nor did they refuse to respond to a
call, then under the terms of the agreement, they are available and the claim
will be sustained.
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, upon the whole record and
all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the parties waived oral hearing;
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act,
as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the
dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreemeit was violated.
A W A R D
Claim sustained.
NATIONAL. RAIhROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of Third Division
ATTEST:
cy J. Dever - Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 30th day of August 1983.