NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
THIRD DIVISION Docket Number SG-25812
Irwin M. Lieberman, Referee
(Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
(Seaboard System Railroad (Clinchfield)
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: "Claims of the General Committee of the Brotherhood of
Railroad Signalmen on the former Clinchfield Railroad:
[Carrier file: 15-1(83-25) G2]
1. Claim that instructions given to Leading SCE Maintainer R. L.
Lyle on or about April 20, 1983 be rescinded and that all radio work be done
by SC&E employees as per agreements of July 1, 1950 and August 1, 1958 and
that Leading SC&E Maintainer C. V. Hensley be paid a minimum call of 2 hours
and 40 minutes at the overtime rate of pay for April 25, 1983, account Electrician Helper C. T. Jenn
and/or radio from Engine 3617 and connected and placed same on Engine 8036 at
Erwin, Tennessee.
2. Claim that Leading SC&E Maintainer R. L. Lyle be paid a minimum
call of 2 hours and 40 minutes at the overtime rate of pay for April 23, 1983,
account radio units were swapped and/or exchanged on the third shift from
Engine 3613 to Engine 3620 by other than SC&E employees at Erwin, Tennessee."
OPINION OF BOARD: As Third Party in interest, the International Brotherhood
of Electrical Workers were advised of the pendency of this
dispute, but chose not to file a Submission with the Division.
The dispute herein was triggered by two related but separate types
of incidents. First, Carrier instructed the Leading SC&E Maintainer to
release the key to the radio padlocks for use by the Mechanical Department
personnel; this took place on April 20, 1983. Second, on April 23 and 25,
1983, an on duty Electrician Helper, upon instructions from Carrier, removed
the radio power Pak from one locomotive and placed it in another locomotive
which was about to be dispatched. These events took place on the third shift
when there were no SC&E personnel on duty. The work in question was simple
and took only several minutes to accomplish.
The Scope Rule provides as follows:
"This agreement covers the rates of pay, hours
of service and working conditions of all persons
engaged in the construction, installation, repair, reconditioning, dismantling, inspecting,
testing and maintenance, either in the shop or
in the field, of the following:
Award Number 26671 Page 2
Docket Number SG-25812
All signals and signaling systems, interlocking
plants and interlocking systems, car retarders
and car retarder systems, train order signals,
centralized traffic control systems, wayside and
office equipment of communication facilities,
highway crossing protective devices, train stop
and train control equipment, spring switch
mechanisms, line of road electrical facilities
but not including work in the Maintenance of
Equipment Department covered by Electrician's
agreement rules, shop repairing of equipment
used in connection with the above named systems
and devices, bonding of track for signal and
interlocking purposes.
Pipe lines and pipe line connections, cranks,
compensators, foundations and supports for
switch and signal apparatus.
Lines, poles and fixtures, conduit systems,
transformers, arresters, wires or cables, pertaining to line of road electrical, signaling,
interlocking and communication facilities.
Interior and spot painting, including the complete painting of all facilities covered by this
agreement on first installation, concrete and
form work of all classes in connection with the
installing, repairing or maintenance of any line
of road electrical, signal, interlocking or communication system, apparatus or device, excluding the
buildings.
Electric and gas switch heaters and slide fences.
All other work generally recognized as line of
road electrical, signal and communication work.
It is understood the following classifications
shall include all persons performing the work
under the heading of 'Scope'. No person other
than those classified herein shall be permitted
to perform any of the work described herein."
The Organization also relies in part on a Memorandum of Agreement
effective August 1, 1958, which dealt with FCC requirements for radio repair
work. FCC regulations prohibit anyone from performing repair work on radios
unless the employee holds an FCC license for such work. The Agreement of 1958
provides for assignments to employees holding such FCC licenses.
Award Number 26671 Page 3
Docket Number SG-25812
Petitioner insists that the work in question is reserved to it by
the terms of the Scope Rule. In addition, for some 25 years the work had been
performed exclusively by SCSE personnel. The Organization also asserts that
Carrier's de minimis position is unsupported since Carrier has never specified
the precise amount of time required to perform the task.
Carrier asserts that the Claims are for a minimum call of 2 hours
and 40 minutes at the overtime rate for a task which takes but a few minutes
to accomplish and takes no special skills or tools. Carrier states that the
activity did not involve a violation of the Agreement since there was no
wiring, aligning or checking of the unit involved. The Mechanical Department
employees check the radios on the diesel units to determine whether they are
working and then either remove or replace them when needed.
The Board must observe that the Notice of April 20, 1983, concerning
the key to the padlocks is neither unreasonable nor in violation of any terms
of the Agreement. With respect to the work itself, there is unrebutted evidence that it had been acc
by SC&E personnel. At the same time the language of the Scope Rule is not
specific in its terminology concerning radios and the work herein; it is
silent with regard to the interchange of power paks.
The Board must conclude that the particular actions complained of
herein did not constitute violations of the Rules. The directive with respect
to the key to the padlocks clearly was not violative of the Agreement. The
work was of a de minimis variety - even if only for a "few minutes" as stipulated by Carrier, and do
overtime call. This conclusion is reached without in any way tampering with
the exclusive jurisdiction of the SC&E employes over all work relating to
radios, as had been the practice for some 25 years. Our conclusion is based
on the nature of the tasks and circumstances involved in this situation only.
(See Second Division Awards 10651 and 7529).
FINDINGS: The Third Division of the Adjustment Board, after giving the
parties to this dispute due notice of hearing thereon, and upon the
whole record and all the evidence, finds and holds:
That the Carrier and the Employes involved in this dispute are
respectively Carrier and Employes within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act,
as approved June 21, 1934;
That this Division of the Adjustment Board has jurisdiction over the
dispute involved herein; and
That the Agreement was not violated.
A W A R D
Claims denied.
Award Number 26671 Page 4
Docket Number SG-25812
NATIONAL RAILROAD ADJUSTMENT BOARD
By Order of Third Division
Attest:
Nancy J r -.Executive Secretary
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 23rd day of November 1987.