I'L.HLI(' L AtN' IMARU NO. 58511
BROTHERHOOD OF MAtMTENANCE OF IA"AY LAIPLVYEES
YS.

 PNSP RAILWAY t OMPANN

 Former` ,1 I SF Railw=ay Co.)

pie No _,91s . Award No-_91 - Brcrctom

t'_Trncr i =c _\o, l4-E0-02,09

! )t ~arlization hile \o. F 4(?-I 3A2-I 04_t_ I NI


STATEMENT t>F CLAIM:
Claim of the (0 the Brodict-nood

_. I _1C ( mr"scr lAzed the AYrcement wmrILn"Cm*v Aupdyia .510, tOier2 CL3iTTiam-!:mm)) i', Borm«n i:67 2d`0., ivn=Tsrbincd 'c'z d*c' Inckleril of C_Itldtit t 'tvihccw1i'n14 tt_7C!; fhb i t31trCC_ :!ilO :! lVrbai aIt~:rCattc_3I L4lth si


1LiYt'_icr a` `'=c' I ,!`VC2:T.`, I)CI't3? ;)C= A?Ip1SL `"_ . (il(j
 violation cat 'tlt t tl 1.0 < c rscl;~c.

_'_ .',w a comeqwnce o! the Wdabon referred to i=1 par ? clue: t arrier shall rt·rn«ve t-om t?tc i1mriMs r-mord this discipline and he lie Knotnwc3 ~vi;h ,Caforfv, \acation. Ed! i'~ltk; raWnpaircxi wid "age loss wrimencing wnen f :climai-i withhold Sm sem'ice and continuing l'r`rward and'or cttherW14,C I314~t3C l0at_t.',.


I Ie ( d "Wr j1ped

 F IU
Public ' mw _MMvl °,w 58511 rcpm the whole rtcrWdrd and Q Ow m-iclenw. 1aW, i_IS.tt tCc: j5ft(`nc5 ."Tc'(':-ttl .tr~ C;itr:c.'.r iTd:el Eil"7ph3t't.'t;: "M df'.t_' riwai?it,dE of flit RT.12l14z?~

 t.ahor A,~c. ;t5 ctTnvnd;:J_ that the 1i(;;.tc-d has itu-isdictioT7 ovc:l the dispute lrcr---;rd, and chat arc. parties to a'c-:~ .li,,aidti :·tr-e ~s~::d~ due re>lve of t?:e hc:a>'irTl! xl4' ~.,d pftrciiipr;tt: iaetcutt t "1 21a;rLant. .lisrlclly k. Brer;-t1>rT, had been ctmpi«yeci Q sf:e CIUvM ;±c: 2005, t .)tl

 ALI:~list `^, 2019, the C%1d'i`:k.° cIW,`';_yefs (s;itrlial7t 1C3 mCrtcl an t rnvk"~:i,4a:ior, "for the purpose

 C!t awi.'I'E:.i1=1313,..: tN F_.:E°!°> and 4_t.'.tC.'Trill(Ii::g ih1°s) iL`,,17t7Tt'^:abd17Iy J L.li1%. .f t .'t>Mlt..'Cte(7n Vrith
 '.`;t Aicsued -tit :c{w of nwitii t 1760swaiiilat ":ilen t he3 Cnw(a_i boo a wr'va ahcrcatlon
 ~ittil ~l i`t7-1:atri<; 3 ':? `!;C t ::'' Vi'W.#S F)Cp <it .it apprfi)XITIWICii' 0tltt hodr, colt '1ULu"t ~, NP)
 Oi. WC t.iit'rlC:a SI.r'cS'.'it?I- . T h :~h?"ti1sv u r
 s t~ 1J1C 3171W w;tlr..tiiIEtI2. t>_ `^s~.'·,; t'i_ic'r Eli. ut)ttl. We t arric"i° isAued E ila·T',<?rt .: .cticr `tmiina huI1 gwtty of Kv srW2"_ i:? vKdown i;t \iai^tenal3Cii'iI `,\.q lter_3lti!g Rule t 6, and dit5ir2nsseci him `r(i`.f t'"lf it t':i'r~t,'tlt.

 Rule IA. Wiiiua . pro% ides, in relevant p11rE:












l tie fact:' tit Hi:, t:;°it.- 'ivy !eirgi:i~ f.inciiTutcf9. f 3Ii i:?z~:4a:;t 5, YM ii, ('!"M<ilm all
 \ssista?1_ R tea 11 Fireman "?ii 1n"iiic:ii in an ;aguliie_lt w4h its iperviscir, I_awranct:
 i_tleecia. at the C arrwr`N i .,
 s7., Vvz:6s` Depot, Mr I tli.CI°0 f.rf1::CC1 t`· il.:F,z°*tvt°L>C. .li)5;(:p1? A.
 WiitUV SWLICIL.0 Stipcrv'Lsor at 1_t.l ,t?Int<i. Colorado, mitt Mr. Walters :arno: a') the scene airs: he ItM smiemcc,ts r;f>in the t'm) principals a5 "ell as From i"f> odwr employees " t:c~ had tWC'it tlif=scm. .i,Wan t ii',IF<y=-c. ,t;ld Brian S~'dniir. ~1]1 tow cniffcrvees read their ~ttitt'121ci1I': ti>Lar ihc Anew vxnvCI Ct't twrct .alit aNii testified coricC;ninz: :tie incittt'3tt.

 t ht: MvitM :nduat" Own *.. .`it' ?rtt?rninz'_ :1? intic sir AaNi,'rs c omhwt'Ci ti ttntcrcnec Call with t'`ain-.~iilt~t i;as-It!", irti:tticlil? Mr . I_ cIC'2i;'. ()cUril?l~thi call. Mr Wahcr'; at?parciitl, niei;th'itirj that i·inpliii.ees were not ail,«.cd t E: nri;; in their vtrhiclfe>. 0llItr?,nit achnt)Weetgcai .si tthi i il;C~LILf:vt(t~ that lie had "taken a ht°! nap- tiuirt'a a trip it t'thlt t =_it?iC .':1I t ii':.
rcparmbin Stir thz: d<;% ^~ ',1t;;i;, two -weeks `seto=c, there hail 6ec·It d
 prohieri? with low 1UE J ;)ti , 3O`°ie (it EhL.Lilicfcs. ()n Iiic trernln.> °__ .-41e. U taiinarit canriU
 into tilt,' £>fft~c .:nd t e_iisl ;;! i L3itv., °iK;t :t?L: F . . _ Wb1 hwta°hett; _L'w id1w agMM Mr
 £3i:3c)i3 carve ltv;.~ :iF°ic 4 tisj vril alt'".Ii trait [t-,C t"iitri'" ..k" '..3_i :i !Lit, %lt, i_iiC '(iv
 tt4(i tiw wmWew b7 put s!-! in the Arcs. ~E
`;h-_ i Utori) hasi W£i ,"i ° ,:wt:`. wad- hg t"ti mct4, dnta ... .<td ~_ '~, i' FI>t=ci `-thzat
 Piece E?L s . . . C Wa,mgrit t£)ltl ktr. Amen, t3?at the sitttat?txn presented a sa1`ety issuc which needed to tic addressed, ut?s1 that st?tr;eht?cb, could -yet UlE:d. Et appear, that Mr, I_E<cet`c} instrttcteti t Went= =n pitt an- in the. dPt s all it L~stt~ G Lie l)K~ and they would art rhcrn fixed, and { ts'itt'itli rt't)l10c.i thUt tie: NV(>Lild 1101 ifO it. No -<iteT:3 `tytifictt that tic had Khmme11 TIC Wlters of Me pmi"?c3T' and they %veve not using the .~!tl~'~ so t
1111 r:wh

 During this :a'iltt'r^,;Ftititi. t'1'atitiatlt aim, tontT(aaed .No I tt(t`ero AOw W. Wttlters` to?dicr htstrttctions Win ttatTkg Accortling try N(r IAWt'Ir1 Chimant ttAd (rim that he was a . . Kg ry. Wa, rcczrtzc?g C;laimat?t. Nip ( ucorc) re;Acd An he N%.-ouid c:n%cc all ruics, and Claimant replied that any time 11r_ Luc=uro Jid AnV-thing wn in %1ould tall NIr, i% tdierv

 Nir. Luccro charranertled ( Umilt?t's conduct a5 a liltsb.-p and aSCened tat
 Chiimais had vE>ne -;gin, and on." lie acknowledged that there war; ~t?o physical contact
 during tile: ineiWt. Nit I tee=-c, ;also acknowledged that lie had heard rv;.·i}rds;uch a:; -°t'.
 k_'- "hurls , ~)tcan <>i, =ILL' railroad toad -,l?e;' \,%ere no! ot'('Ct?siv;: ;.r hits?. FILnvever. he
 c'xp!anled. !3;: hat. cv, h,a> s . itt i 9,=~ . .
 r r- w E _°`h 7 `tip directed ?<i him wrth JeTr, ie:rnor. and gym`
 totbnd it

W Lamm ` wed Out t ISLnwa had been eng'agallt! in wmh cxI7dmt 1t}r wilts time, and, ..iw a rca:t of Win incident. lie dill not ile~f t~f)tiifc)t"t~3f?;=' "Pth tlairna1'tt. Id tftremencti by' W; :ybuns amt no kmt;cr wanted tc) work ~ktt3,, 7i=t?3, f!t` stated that it he came to it he *"'oui j leek _9nor(m:' ;oh and would never \"7rlk t:'±i)1 Wmaw agAt?.


N sr. tKhmme. LthE3 _a '~t;)?tP,.)P2~ its '.1 &. 11 Vc.`L:ha.nik on 1"i:,_ _'aY ;iT'?i;` Id2C?tCT?'_. s atett Lit the iaix";t_ ?tacxn ;ka (;t° haw not twerf'tem_I all of We , rt;te, ~


E . .

tat (Unuai amz M:. 1_t,cn, h_Ed af~Lta't: about the ~EIC a>2! the t:aiit r, ca?d Cia ?rnam told ',1r. Luccro that it ncctltai tc) Q Wed. that it could kill sc~nicone t_ ;t hle%t out, arid NA ka.it..t.iL) wph1..d tf`tf'Et it "i7Litd he ME.t.


Vt. Sl'dMji`. "'i0r Va_: 17stbrt~?i? zv. aw 2.i` i.'. t3 hei)7Cr ;flat OJ`_ 1:0111-11-nIcd Lit Tile
 Awt"`,,tigatit?t9 that C 7a±ttmt a"o,onmd 'vfr. I ueCrt) dtf?tELiiiu'·.:fi S'?t~iiICCt ''w1;`. ~iVa£terS
 that Claimant i?.ttt been rapping. HC WC) Lomk?1nd that t taunar21 told Nil. I.tmero that
 tiny t1Piw No- i uC=fro hittke vL !ulc he v'o;.ad call TIr_ \V'alte'>, and ft"_- tC1ail;311tj lie could
 Se L a t . _ . No a . . We am:' 11 ~Llstt C(?ilftt'rt2Cd tkt ChtTr#aTa t tvL$;?tic:Cl ~Kl?1L? at Th.
 f_itccro about ·hc (l at ti-c~ anti ti'~L f tile -f-word' <,_ (evL

    \jr Si jshor ==shti£,j 'cftrtt'` Jell, :1-?~P : tS:iS 1111 E.L9ttc'i c?


r t s
 ,:11d, aiLflOt71-111 t ~r11I'_l:d'a `;'rta<;t' at :ttfc` iflllE;lt.. ha did i1·.=i

 r<s%~rcation, and 1St'. heard Cu?m_ t'·: ;fit' raiistniC. ca'u, dq. ;;,, 2,..,-('
 'ne trailer could pre~-cih -t ,L:3~'t~, t`°0'-!t:'ii" h,.a:titi`t; The ;t"+iiL:t .s~1> ,11
 =1 tht'rt' was t°c' `.t'. NtWARt _(':it i nlpht rkwLZtr
 .Ic'ttt z.. teaP

 prt'SEnt such :l prtffvr, ; fu 'aajett tax ptittn'tL; uir in the tires El~StiC". [le Stdt~di thrit ( f..nazWl "an 'ad;uItaz`ft" about to >wAl m:i;v.

 1 ~aa.`ail torlt`;:7r7t3tkori,

 fnt:!tttT1t as an

`>$<ttt<d thd t a? 11;1111 on :~'t'?i !?rt the h?k'.hmi.i.b


Ek'L . a, kh3e 3'd not

 a .IoE .;rr':Ec:ot:3 `;at'tt*"

 p! 1; viSO, t_ _.w `'·.7°, :')rt
      I WC 5 of

    _ Umblt" j"_nVad .,. ti An :0xt£tth"i tint other the ctiii`U!K`ni'.' K.it. tlutt tniit'IT#11;;


%4 1 ;iccro aAtvKt .he w tvt_ W nC;tI',vN NcC'1 Lil prepwtt tK . hc' Q'4, t1tCt_ t ?ie
                      £'.L t', '!tasks t,ks:`tasks I


-tWfwd he Oc`i?_ q1hW1v _i??t. _c}'.4_I Mot the °1aCci~ C ?cre <2_i,i Oak= VW- '£'
 T<fin ha" , at* L4,~Ilt bxt~lK IItwB,l: _ind ."Icai.at tl'~: ..>attCT Et' N.It. I "bC`c't';s. ; lc' ,tato,! that \lt.
                          :x .tt`L,°t;i3:t


CICCt12 W?HK`3 "! x:t ..> 1t. <l~: I t':" ~' ' and I??Wdtt':e . '-`.IA. t tartteL,i1
 cSt>"I?lctt1 ~ : >W. :ift r
 at.htro"leilgni that lie , p.;.`<:hto W l U ccul had t 'f in, ca"' nu)tl -i!=t"Tlt .°~i' ??`
 t. :! i ..li
 pbc:cv c°:h, C .:s to hal;t~:>`.~3~ 111,7e , wtN ,s pbt?E,leI2i ~~.=ii( the :),ickht·e t~v'o vcejk,
 WCr atld lMl tli)ne whine Sob(t ..- tlatn'1ant also asktio:=, £'Kln'LY Shat he a;kid W.

Iowa) A he had brviuaht Ws "Iittic nap- ti> No. " alters?` awro"n, jnd No, Luccro, told l??i~'t 111,11 .?w !?,.d E3£ 1T~3d.


iUtIixa nla"aamec.

 Cllfa "hat liar; iL£:::fi'TL`..l `.4ftS bi ,,t~.3::Ir"£`FiW I I :SSllt`:'_T?ItILt ;£
:III' We rt'gardine the T!tts i'o "'3t_' t`>4'o

 Eunt:wt tt? whc°' 0?rart imA's.a C!t>`

 1u!.

 .aLt'·. the SSI!::i'1C)?5. ..».-

 Ci`·til1 to ~cr _. VvKqhlC

 ~.t~:K':. 1,l` I '.?i.:..:1 d<I_<~.l.i(
 .;i he had 11_. `h' _ -
n'aih ad-

    t iafn2bbrtt a4t~no.=;cdp:.i that In '_Ira, till xgw;lcra ":d: %.1I' KnK'rc= bait ntwwaAwd


Ount cut:Ing "as tnav'o!wx' .3`l Nith ciids Clalina-'`lt teSLltietl t",-ix `~t l?`,z7~1t?,. c)Cc £firi~wt~

 cvtCY £1.21 Ltn l he i11 i not 1wcl l*ka: .:.fth=:I Ivan had been ina t A l?R..' l l t~ -bated that Ole

 _'tattel inWli`t'ci bi ntyni il s c_13. CrwA"st'i °rF1nh is %vas i3Fraal't the ` ;t?,.

    I he .ail'":w~i pdik= ti5t' vW)t.,. lif`t,RMnMve '"Ca`t£miaI'd ii`, Wl`P rE C?';t)1sks


!0-:JC(-tt, t` .:.':;PTIC:Uicc,:i _?= fIoiiC: . -Aj)pcndIX

 $ t0tl nC.;:[ `:a.`. -tz?:1' >it`;F spenoor _.9. 1 tnay he oxT' #
 ~_ `2 [`:a.` _' - . s ..2,~':=~i.~b ',t>l .. .tlIy to ii3`e"·_' ....'Ct Nit,'.
 Lf'dCt`iiF44 hi`lf.;taM Aw Pl'PA `n''iKi~`= Can ` ~ " Can :: i ? _
      _ } ;=;3 . .;i:CC=I_£_ ~-c°I!<'f.t~: tis~,.. C91! :e'ktlt2lT .2 zf5-

V;tWOV1'1,:"1 p,,,:-iod 'zt .. ~',!NcC°t ,k... elnpbt)%'CC to .di',tnts"aI,

      .Ati11w. E j.«- ·i',:_ .iv" >._ Aw1',·, j. t(i- > ,J

      t$,!'S(E~C~K1Tti _1' . ..'t~ ·i'- x :h"t1C'!~ V77'· a[[:ii;41


` , Q _. .CO'.-Pi An _oh .. , ,. f >iasc; ,. `t. _f·tYj <i ...- Wit': , :t . CS . ·4}_
 :d`x

 ,.ii:~2 `_i.`.F"st,·f2·,t"a. ~vrh a Kit;,. t, ,_. .,.'C._°*1 pCMt£L km1C<; f r

 ..1 cstabhA: al?d dtw'u?Iwn, - }i!~3iF :131It, .')Rl 'iuihi~f' t; ":t) .tf .

    ! he E wncr try A "w" ttb,lt (- :;fttn3nt received ;3 Sir old !mparlbil invoaQadon.


In P,"t'tbculai. CAC-' l`'arHi_`S` qltt'~ tile hnulgiittk" titiCe 1N3, ~,uat iwav mW rmlded

 Wnixd and t'.:5. re"pvv _,?t:`s`n, "A, wvnQa "trt ?tR`=hMWt: C: W.. C? ? `s_"_ tl?z_' .`ill£'et:i

 `t ithii?atn fe'= r'~r. :°C' $ il~"',>t >_`7:

 l lsv eaF£teil ?1222t 't,~"S't w.2~. It() rhl'`=I£:?Il
Acted _ht2; I'.V bohE:1.~C'fi LET'_~ I .: c'I'e} ltblv 141:iF'?~' tt)

>;>.I1d! ilx=" ;`C We LEA vtSC FCte .:';ItC:. v comniv there "jN *1Kttt; , IK tti'c":. 1lt' <fKrlitll'tit .':Wa .._. M?' hc _;??wcl hi,


,. , tt='t"~F':i. , _:, 4_ziti'si Thai he l)t> ,_-, _ . t?l;!~i'7a Fl'tf t22;tt(i;'.

 Too 2v 2nk~ A

 t )(1 bCi;-,. ~3'2?~. ".'.'c . ;3?'s.__ :4'~a'3-i, Art 'llb, _M_ f'· .=cai z..t- ·IIW.tti'c.f_ S.

 Lt':StTtt'£l `t7 '"Wk `-.t[iI ^:i,7?. i

 WIC£' tl1C: t AuiC. P7t2FM t3I.?F,

 Ctvw.t;#bCd tli:S't

 iIW .t, Iwo ,.1;1 v;"rWn1 .27"tl , ;t2_;p tsw.:<t>aT) E l_,_t7l*!I7` .xm! NI?' . tit_ ,. sltfsl ;?tlT)t?t'Isiiljl`·.
 , t_ 37`rW a Mato,. 0 v~ __. ;L ":c:)a<_, J ?t=w,_ l;c 4L. r,cd ._,f- fit; >_ . ?t: W c}C;ttii>If of 'r?i
 t_:1ubr 5amduct role, It is "vif established. Liw Carrier states,, that s:7CIf ,ttl admission

;Nullteient ttt SatiSt' the ('Zifr;ef ' > harden of proot, and ` 'Ii' ~:e.tt?11l:3Ii~r` _1'It?ctic C c=)ncfiiwivelv c,;abhQWS ( ir23nnmt~ _..1t tIc'ar:_S', the l 'i`-rtcr c one?;.:its, Claimant W7itlteQ Rite f .t)


Willi respect d' the penalty' asst ;sc. I. Me (Itrric'r mites that ihc PEPA provides that t"c) serbus. Level S otiitses WON a Polclnth tevbn% peri«d call sultlc:t an employee to disn£issaL C`laf-nans',~ record, the C'nirrier pwnt~, out. ~hote-~ tvln discipline events widyin its t?-snontla rep: ice, I,tr;cid. hlcNding clue Wr air incidatt sintidr tc> the onr: at issue. Ile Carrier concludes that this floard has no basis upon which =o overturn (eLiirnant's disrai~sai arid ;cqiicsI_, that the t'Iailn i,e denied.


Hrc 0r~aniza:iohi rows tmwedwal anti sastamh'e ci:ullvctead; to the di~c:t>t;ric .'ssessid at2a:n5I ~Th=Pxy_ Fun. TV ChPaNzati: n .t>aerts th'a t :,,,_.ii~t °%Gns c':zaicd c`7 1-~Ifr and tf7:[Jw'tlell hCxIt3E. F'SC' tJyt-t..;,.3`tif<lstLSFI notes that the 1911C',tl:a~ilisr3 'iwktC ched no rule Ci£imtaht had alc;gcdy %, icdtltcd_ hit the (Iearins, t`£ffcc:r alltiuch vii:: :.~ vie entered into evidence. Moreover tte Organization points out that. a%c:I :::~ .*iijeC.tion, crnployt~e ~tatcrncnti ,verc allowed tlttc) evidence tit the iI1vc~t£Latlrlri z: `t ell iit:3:.I7 (1e cnnplc~'C'cs Everc !)resent tuiil av:Sifai"f: lor questionaig.


C)n the iaerit& Be t-hganizatiori asserts that the record evidence leads to the
 iciniical conclusion that C ialnlunt was persecuted for reporting a sathq condition and
 Ilehdaag to hN belief th=at :I posed ;.t sknitictl£tt risk to ('anier employms and the puNW.
 `hilt At;ankaticin poirith to 1W I uc:e;o 4 tcstiniooiy that 'heir super-,iwtir, 11r. tN/ultc:rs, had
 W>t\ti i4 )t' mc) liC."lit .1!'itr~it ,-,rohlenis irlth the tires on the i1'uckhoC ~ir1(1 traifQr, ^·i12
 m4hincg had been ;done `(r correct i!°C situation. 1IoreoxtuC, the Orgaaiifat;orl riciWs. We
 JYCn' t`alpiotcu tc ;titic'_i 0;aT CUM= k.«,'d that fflc' `iilu~lt;ct-?i ;-,?'~._,Ti'lit="if ,. Af ,his'
 siltetv,' i,wUC "

    The t42ainzatlttn saws that the fanLat t,ii:1tT12Ir;C used on AN twi:L3:itot? ;.`3 <2t the


      ;i

mw! used :12s"~m and the titlEc'r C_Tlhk cTt°q tit? the failii` took I?C) c·:W .'tIr15'Ml to Il;c laIir'.t:.wC i )r nine tip- usod c,? expicsS Ids rnwacrc>ti utih inac:arevicut'y 'allure 'tr addrcs- the sa~ct=< isstic. i W d Win= in; Token tai. the Agatidatioil mg= , the hal W cmild have t: used :3 t?iC~'·'s'tlt~t, rcoutttntl ?it injury tar a%en death- t. iim:3nt's d?.`nrtSSah <<It Aganbadon uram allu)u its to b0TdCffhlc". haraSSrucr£ for his r e(ltirntlt.: tilts .Safety issue. Ile Qgar'7utiC?n ri=quc'~i-s that ;17": 'Lihn ht sustaineCL


We W°;: LaMi-ta3V reVteavc-d tile r `etord in its e nttriumFrst, we hind no e4derice 4aany prcwe;Wnii v-7cliaition ct° ii-rtc,2ularitv which denied t ;a:·rtwlttt hip right to a htir ;:lid inipat'-Ilaf t;lvev£i`Jaat!oI?. # t.e if"t:. ·(iL'~tI!Fttl ,totic ' in W ciw p"'t`, jdul`.

                                      'aTt;31t' Llc't;tl1 w3*iow C:aitflant t^'1 tindc~"-t:!??d t", :;tu'{uatltlr?S ap.unst !,rill of>li t'::.' rCYC·twti~<t to wSpt'tild_


    On lit, illw=it~. ,'=iero :s; ;cry We ;Iisc)ane Aout vkhat _ctuti'-=I" occurirtl Atla>ugtilt: mtt t trirlC:!pafs thwl?3Car?!tv it uitc Jticrt'e'itl~'. %'ir. i..~,~rtt ,'=ercC %ed C IairiwY.

Air?^2'.'s :i.'^ ii d;trcsC)ctttu=, tnrcsitC;n: ; vW? . =,tt";e Chum ma chars, tt.rized C as .
                    `rt:tt wrack, wrack, Cl. .lItt%i ?


                                  i''; ., '.t7. i .i~C W s s=1'1

am (& me nu!t 0qn CnxRM IM)Tt%a'.C" t)L' "'IC I la.;ertt" ?'?~Ifurc to a:',i3'.'`~·, °ra_trtv cotlc::rt1" -c ". t: pla tt'kA'* rAwd

    VlArr<uH Not selMe matt wttliFILh; for frustration ~_.:_

    %'?: =%_,y)?_': t (t7 ?f(c condition


r
 .,k me chicle itF':`:, aa1s: t tTlplt)\'at`, j;7tl'·13it1y tlt=i'`nktflrt)i of va`' 1'°t.' :'OM teE a c t`C?x41t1

 maim"f x>_ OWN, _it:n `rt' P'ttr.t

l fte toC` of PIiAnitis i ; ! ii

t i i (t1(71 CC +llld =2 LSpt'C% L,t'r

ills itt'rnih tip llw tviAplacc


:'C ~.df~t`it 7wwtSW FI'C 3$: ~'d3-t:c'~-+ _· YtftlI: the ?Ilc._tJ'aCt

 Si;?;'<,Ctl W or Ow 1'tllf;`t);3tj. and m`? i \ n's '?T_tStle'Sl! I7Ck11'Ct:FT itll an C11 (71Aki·'.ii; i?T'P2Fl'tc:T'lt`_; Call hL' c.zltt;.,t.'?t_`1I/S.'d it:S t'(o9aLltl(_'

 4'Itlc .:f<' N7F-ctpfL` argtintt;nIs. «T`.c? `I;: (:'?z° ftC_:\'CC21 the tatct

 things car `)C ai L7`w"t:',; .'f tf7k_ !n t>E`Sr..,.'(?Lit~rFR :I~ E`it'_i1:t'.1.'I? Ow I'..£% , aT`TSk3l''SF1=_:i in Ole

 ,:?-L_tl£I1s;Tl1 ~,lt:l'4 :titrlt:W:1`> do two tttt: C.`%t't7',1: 1t-;.`1 ?it A>:9G _ .n::~?~'v;ti<1T:"~_ :.rA ,T7e1:n2 be
 _a·`·C:SC.Ccf on We ~F~c't._?=: ...~ . (, r..:lc'Y`,ll:.., ttM .,T dC ll( ?:i` AC Si.1'"s '.flf t>i2.

    MLnt ~.~.~_,..t .~ .!~_~.. T.. ·;W::3litv ,:iCF. ;TT As s.,.^o ,-_ kind tl" Tcxit>'1 i_t

t3tCWl;'T; the ltc,2h%w t0 car E 'M*`v:c7ll 'IiI:I Clr_IIitIlidiT C" ,:.1q.,. .. ,1 (.0(1117C.` .eCf`;i ,.t=t~rdpLc~tcit~t~° , ~:~. (,~rFi?4:7~ 'tai. ;:c;pcrtmr% ,;3 the rr--se-ice , , r 'tf-~r arTTpfovt<t;s. and that _flla x=sc°s tat `!'v Et_"_. ,i' an z=·t~'Wi`Itiil LtI[ft1T1 the T)It~:si1131.~ c>fi ?l'. . lCN ;Vti Llc'xL' !f,+ .
 CiiFtr£'t;itL::La>tT ,1n . T:1w ` .1i tf3c° f'x't'Cm:3=.1'5 proper Cxe?'irk ·L' of hi, ihiC1ph211F2tL'

 Cl'7tet`,`a!hllI>tcai '.11:<'?, .LT ,'=I:, aIS;+ :tfi UL CI' ~t1~C11' C ~:~2tTi23Ii` a=w ~`w~+t",Clb' f?tSrsLFCd t!-'o
 rTt=~,ti9at'.i12 alter N5. Luc:c:rt= z1n;aw:! hti2t the Salem pri?_3lyl"S~; he i~ ksf CtilsC£j talPUld
 jet;
 siilfC`Sld. and fk't'3cd the ;a'!011'103( to Lcf7.iT ;ipptFiTS to f1:31.`C" tlcC"i itiC ;3iliTiixl'~ I?-!o"=111', k<Jr
 W. ,c?'f7a1 =c:L t=,rtti.fi v',.s1 %Al t"t:V: Ctrf t r'i2 of : .. 1:`rl:`t i y tm Tic job Tic It
 x.`4?Tltltsi.'(1i711 W.jdh ;11:'s. (Ialtll:m1 c21(lr.'cS hi; ft73'ft2lili't a `"k-_-iilL; "m- wl;.:. (?t' :7i1;711C;1ktt?tl. Otl

 I is a! May ,.r.:! c'I.Y,IT):TW _°;r},ii'fit l°iv could ,. _ ._, ,-

 bully 17r'.c"'t t^t i . .SP:,: indeed

 .xal was the .'C;'.,=. Now V i`rRt 3_;r1itCC~:liic',It that day f; ;< ?h.. .`1 't)i= ilk f s?d111351':_ h"7
 `tttitt't'~a.'., ._ ifru~nt12:` 11i':2 _i;t°E. _It:, F I_i;:li3t??i at him tams kp*x .wii t; `·i"iri,L' "Ong ifl('F1S x..

 <`i.Iiii:.>_"ak. 1iEC A;._e . .,E ,i:S., , ,w« :ii i#". I tit'ert? .? _ v? ...car AM ..g1ci.xSC ;id = xe

 s"ilation, O'Rii :2 +<it 'slit it' . WE. 3"rfi L 1.:;"t;,i7TL'S l3c)wEl=.:Ti Lci Ni3- Li;cv. t
                                it rC't_ld'I.L ti3` actions


as ;3 :L!('sCCt i'ittl %·1' -,..,.rs'ktxt-t: ia7T?i`:'sidt' that tl1C C:fr1't_~t l s. , . r 'v htitilc`T5 ApTtW icT`4

 t, I:FtIT:M5 Lat" in 'UMMOY 1% Malec

    W;;h ?`c'*I(?c'C:I to ;i't" pcIT:if?' ,:>Ma,t`;i C ,E9lS22:1SIC .,a`- :1 b'ILt?i_wrCi1 c.al~'r(tWCC. with

                                      r u


trlti' ,?tnifai t3lo?''ts* ?_r:.Ic.It on #3i, t'_'L(?1'_k" MiICi another Q v& S
                                · v . t)·IS C;6tL', t_dIt'I#L'T'.

I `R=~ P1TTt1"Cs PFl}:'L pte,rTT`yII`: [t"i"TT''ti,it',t'etl (c)r il n ::'t.:6lllck f.4tc.°: I on"oc.'. aid :1C c:ai?33FE)_ ',.iE
 Ono ill:' choke A()C'T,d L hem C t'f'F'C'Sx.'?;"s an iIIlfL1·C, ikT`f?tirt?ri,` 4tr ~i3t~tC;d'S?RIO31t>t1: i?iv`i`t"?sC t)j
 .,rt C,IY'7`1tiT's t3: . "c.'T3cTT? [_ ili'It."'R?Ittit' `N`t1;tiCW ,

 Mf8:'i.af2T :aft t5t-:1 W . s.,.,

 -rar +h o ! .f_Ctct` .~c~' , z . . r

 + %I t' tt .., cY`5

 _ 't'!:'?et§x7i? ?tt

 K V40 OWN"-",
      WC 6 A

Sj,kNIAVH4A K.3~C:F~ ~`s
 Carrier Member

 Dated this: ' day of

 AWARD
Claim denied.

 D.6. Ifi~:t~ENeutral .Nljmbcr
      t


I lA t' l l) ' 1 `A 'v N Ie:R
 tlraait iza tio i i M enil) er

 c No -)91~