PUBLIC LJ?.W BOARD N0. 148
rw
DOCKEi .°:O.
.5.
- KWARD NO. 5 GE:sa "'. RIT=R
OPIATI!w
n11a `:''
EZfcctivc M:mzday, September 14, 1970,
Claimant, Guadalupe
:K3z_i:.az, w~·~ demoted frr= Track Foreman to Tract4 Lager a: a
rec:ai of a formal belt-ing cannucted under the prawtsinns tf :"-ti
cs`
11 of the Agreer^wnt bztween
no
Gal=-astor:
Wharves and the
Sre::.=rh o of Maintenance of Way 3*nployes.
The
Claimant was
found
au-4141y
of indiff a: an ce La the narf orzsan cb of his duties
arising oa; of three specific charger, to-wit:
... That the, track gang Wider
Claimant's sl.tpervision rc
q;;as_-'
1:.
.~ey6
to complete a crossing at an intersection, Which
co:.stf~...,.e.s a:. vnreas:*nable le^.etl: of time,
2. %t)v:t C1_-_;-,.ant was not available to call. at his resi_a.^.ca froa i2 :3u until 4:30 A. M-,
A_za.2st
20, 1970.
ands
sailao
to leave specific instructions as to Wfiera ha could be located.
3. That on August 20, 1970, at
ar:prcx`lsataly
3.0:45 A. M. ,
C._aLmant allowd his track gang to be blocked off from their work
for approximately 40 minutes by an engine crew maXing up a transfer.
The facts disclose that Claimant, at than time of the form-
al hearing, bar:
bean an er;ploye of the Carrier
in
the Track Depart
...r.._
for a par=.D: .'.f
scone
L'°a yea=s airA
than
1,e e
haz tct_f
3e_
TTr-,-.Is
..
...:. s~.i..aia & £2
.." h
pv='--_'',
_`.i3 :. : ~:~..:.. a Di
a y e
ax
I
it ri
'Cl ~ A .yJ .I 1:1 ~ .yl
'r t r 1 IU ,f' I A·1 1'Y 1
I
11 ~tl 11.
.yl VI IJ ·4~ It ,!
r. rll Pt .II
(-
JI Ell
~(
rl
d. ! 1:1 I-I ·ri ' j
l
JI
11~ 11 r;l
IF +V III t .I fl!
IIV t 1'1 ~~ ,: ·r+
1t
III I7 . 1'I 41, , y L, il! It: 9' Ill I I ,i
r1, ·,1
a ~i n.l s1
.tt CI t9
I~
~l·
li
AI
~,
f! 11~
.~.1 [ r4
ul '~ 'Yt rl I! · r, 1' .rl I 1 .'t
I:
Il
,11 !~1 I1 M IJ Cl 1 1I rl 1J ~I I·-I tf .,I I~
ai
r7 1) 1 ;'· I 1
14 .N e) '4, i 111
., ! g
l l I I PIE
I r
il .It ·a L. M U 1~ T3 4
if
,i L~ tl 1 ·rl
..i I 11 tll
~d
fl
,I<.
t~ rcj cl) V III ,u, 1,
.~!
of S+
w .,
N
,n
·r.
v
M
m
I: 1, 1'1 'll 1 ·rl
o tr
,4
Rl
'~ 1" -r·F
.y~ 4.1 F)
~1 Ir
_.I Prl CI ·N 1'1 11
la
I L1 ' LV 41 f,
1· +J
lu t "J F" ·,~ lu ~)
iJ
~~ 11
1'i
ri ED f,)
!'~
I
,l" '4d
K1 Ci
d, "'
'IJ
L71
H
+1 rdl
'!j r,1
tl1
,sl F ti ,I I 4 ,C!
FJ .I R') (' ,k, 41 4i p. 1. f 'rA ,F: )
,1 tU 4i ,) I
. Rj r.
Ill
4-1
·.-1 :1
I rl f I :>
I
.17
II,
r.i
Ill
if
M
4F
41
I
UI
·.l
( l : r
k
t~.I' I 1 ,h~ S
I1 ·r, ><I .. ,I ly » ~I. ., 't i , 1 ,1: ,
r.1 a IJ S. A~ 6A 11 r:f of t:F ,7: fl li C) I-I t!
i ,1: Ili ~fl Id N I7 I d 1.1 f II 11 I7 ' A I
1 , fl · i IIA ~- 0 to ,47 ~'I ·. i 11, ·, I if VA ~" t:
LI. la 11 1 14 f·t rl , L
J "A 41 rC·! ,L: l~ la. "I
II 11 ,I. ICI M to ,P 1: 1·' A! tl L. :'·r
!i!I Ll r t 1lf 'C1 ' I1 0 11 1'i w r' 41,1
44
I) RI
.,4 IA '11 /1 191 fit a in I.I I: l° (I II .,` lil 1J I I.I
rl1 I ,· 1 t,l IA IJ f' 'J, ' 1 4 n, .,l .,t u c (' a If I I. LI
t r. I 1 ! A 1 R 1 t-I t ,1 ; Is, k 1 I A p 1 n It
( ,·1 t,J '1 tl l7' 11 tq 11 CI rll i,~ ,F' ' ill I '1.1
rl ,li S: R1 S" i ).; II to k .~I 91 ;: 1. I I .'rl
i .li Ip .il FR t~ t M AF t't I .. ,I ;l,J ·I ,.I 11 '1 .~ ~ W
I`I IF r. I1 fl I1 r (] 1.1 r1 » ,.l II ,(I At :~ II'~
1 1.1 ii it y AI 1' to 7J sl II rl I
·.~ 'C a -F~ 11 t' FI of 1. rl 1 IJ II 11 1.1
·rl It JF ~' +J (J Iy ·A ·,j 1) ,1: rl
1'.rl ;I ll,I rf~ it
III II 19 IV (1 rd 1.1 IJ 11, 14 +) 'l7 .I, It ~t .F 'll Cl 114 II
·rl li 11 41 "1 111 14 r1 11 11 f~ la r:
'I:'. II rl 1! ,17
tl , /: fl ,I- r- Il I 1: ·rl rJ F7 i: II t' r.i ,-i 11 I'I 1,1 I:I
1! ·,A n '.I A) t.) ,Ll II 'tJ.I f,.1 0
rl ·,
II, 11I ,f. 11 IU !I r~ Il .rI 1· rI · I ~I ·f. ,11 ,·-I
t'1 I 11 ,1: P. .s: nJ Ej +1 ,.I ·,d I: i· ,t l I) tl f'' .Sa ri
I I RJ t r, .FJ 4J CJ M ·rl I,I ...I IIA ; LI I, f 1 I ^I , I I i
11 11 I' .-I In .,4 rf; ,I· Cl ·,+ ·11, ':~ 11 ,. r~ c.l is ·,1
+1 1 : fj ff << .,A FJ f ,A., F; li ,AI 1) 11 ^· .. il .lil f,l ~1
f
1) lJ ..r ,4, fj ·l:~ .,i Ij ,Sd 'If (- t3
-I! ,1' 11.1 " 4-1 ,J' D f11 RJ ::1 11, WI '..' A 1 t'1 11 tl f.l id 11
II Ij <I 1,1 AI fl 'l.l ~i ,~ t· 11 71 l., I' fI
L1 ll ·I ·,I G, ,L:, r (: ,l, '+! Rf 11 ,-V r) .6. r. VI A1
b7
I1·,~ ,41 A ·rl Id :1 'lI [:', to :,- Y.' 11 .R. +I LI 1.1 IJ
I~1 RA 1: rl t
~l N i !fl ,-I ,l I41 1: r([ r: P.. ~' WI". 1.1 G ii
11 IV AA
F: R 'G ·A !: 1 is ,.I IFI IS il ·,~ ·ra .11 ll IJ ·rl
11 d. rl 11 1 ,._ ~1 '1 1:7 AI u· .-y rl 1 I ' I! I -
Ii n1 t ·,1 nJ I~ F: f,i t) ,L! li! ! F.I
1' I'll 01 I:·I Id rrJE l1 nl It !4 I· C 1 R' rd
hi [~ i., I W (J.
A l t'1 II i ,I : w I A Iv (n C. f ~ R:I
i~ 111 11 1; r? 1 ft .: 0 ui I 4,1 JI 1 i ii ,=i~ .f ; i'~ t
1_I 1:1 r5 +1 t' I (. t'FI. .- .r·- ·ri 1. W= '1
L; i.l R:1 I7 , ·1 ;1 t.l r1 ail f~ tl~ -rr f,> ./I r f' I~1
rr tl I' 1, N ,ll,1' rl R: -.F t!rl· 1: ·i AI
'f ;.1 a! t. 1y ~ F' L~ r· r.l f.. !.I
:, (S .tl I ~J ~· 'F _I' : ,'..'.l . .`f f: a: ·+ III
:, FPI 'f: :1 t tJ ~.t t n [- · ? ~. C: 111 +) t1' r, 1= 1,) ii
I
I,
a
IJ
a
'Im
'I ~
Et n1 '%: r m9
Ilm
.it
X
rp
1.
~; ru m;i ~ a, rol
U,-I
x
'.T to
.u
,1
",_; r·;
tr ! a vr
cm
a ^s ,a,
1`°J
,i·I
to
~·L
s
1.1
.t: rC:
Im
tY
n e
u
It
ILI .IJ 'La 't! -·~".9a
"'
14 C
~I
U ~~ k ·ra
?I
IU C, '3
C) ).a
uT~ C)
t
'r .;
47 s~
) 1 -.i ,C
"n +.' Lr 41 " 'o
.r. a
-,~r
~r:! ro
41
C: kl
'nt
r: a: ar
;nr ~a ·.s
1)
N
m to c,, a
>~
a
mh I:.
Ir i'
·rs
.i:1
e u v t 1~ c:~ ~:
a'°
,C; -.·X t' 4.1 Yt 41
' 1 !·I C) ·r1r1
ml
1)' vet 'IC Idl CJ
W,
.Iw b C_y .C:. Q ··'a C'
Q
N t ": 4,1 t71
to
w
a
~~ TJ I~ N tb
~mi
TF
ma
Q. u: r,, ns;.ml s' ·_, ,><I
Au'
t4
mX ~.1 ·^
p' ~r .a
.,, w a. ,r:Cr' .C ~;
.4t; ,. "C
Jt
yi~l
nl U~'
~'
ml
LI
.N'
rilr;Q.
4''
·a·t,. ;,~I ~.'
C.t ~.~
W
:I, ·A, NI
t'a
.Yr'
·n1 Y
, t
A1 14 41 11 41~i '~ 40 fs 1 It
(CI f:' .~' 3y tin
rti ,rC
i7
-rnt i IV ·L
. - jj 71
t: C.E ,^M, - r s: hl I 'Ifu
a7 ... r
f: .~F t w "I I ^CN C.' f.1 W
~T
.X a9
:I
',)t<
-.A
C
mi ,'.
~:
"1'
tA
6t
I'
N
41 ' .N cp 8 0s ,a
''~ > tr 1.1 a' kl N c -r t
r.. ,t l W '1.r r!1 11 , ,t.. 41 it:;r
a
tU 3a lu t;,) 9~ 2 Cr "· "i .t. 4)' A
.i T. .S~
It) It L: C V~ fill rt- .):. C1 L C'1 h' '~a tal M C% t IN
ii L~ c: )X Lt , t s' t; ;. p .·, i f.t. IJ +a r.l
SI ll i. t'1 R' III Ic1 ,5.. ti; ) t 4r 1._ 441, ·'f 3.: k:A ~Y 1w C LI rl
' Ill Sr 4 .;:. A : U (., f'. '.^I ~.: 14 V. )) mE m' ha mt C' CI
t:. ,-· :., ,a' <~ ')I w: r '::', ·CI (IP ml el~a ry t:
rT ...s ~~ C 4> ·t'.,' 41.4 if f: ft f 'tP w) m) -».1 H ·! .f: '.e
al (', ·1 t' u, .ya r1 ,~ I°· w JJ 'a m) 1 .I d.A hr
0t 1.1
·~ ..f ', Ib..I ..! a. ~t.'f n t) '"'~ ,r' r. IV h 0.t .·I
I ^c"I .cf:,; .1 Lr °v c. 'b Irk an t
~ ~ - d CJ n~ :fr n'I A
1" al t: it a. os m -r .ra 1» c~ i! f.)
'I , ~l. "it _.r QI .a: t1 'llj 4.4 4.i 4f pt ·r4 4T .t'i tr tj". rr n^i ~ni YA .G.
::f .i -i ,C; CV f) 10 tj ·et Id ·rr )) 'ii R. .^ "
..1 r '9 to ~A f: ,~4^ tl tC, .8 .-0 'tr m' E1 IY1 17
1. ( t' C)I;I 11~ i:", t) b' .L~ I.r C CI 1.1 rtl
11
]it ... ft ~la
., .1 d -= 1 cr 14 1 1 0 s ·. r I A ~ C,., "1 CJ' 111 0 .C: I:) 1J
(, i c. IA 1) "° .ill 4.A )~ rF ,.n ..~ rta +) :.I ;·
r
_ L.r If y. tf Ir ba " 47 ` u, w ,t. ml f^ h ~: ro
/.i t:. 1: ~r f.' .. Ir "r(t ~r !A t. 'L7 "MI 's' 1..i QJ I_-r X.
:., ') I. C; bl :.r I tl f_> (J ,C~ If. C,.
I .I' :' '· ! ..I i .:I 4'. y ': · , .°·) fi !·r !! f.~n4' ll .f' (.' f 110
·:' i.: n; ~ 41 't. lit 17. tX 11' :I ri rn c t.l nG 1,
..1 r_ t'. "r 'C Iq qtr (Vut 01 (~ tl I N It ···I .·
Xn r., is ' ;) c - t. t ~r t) .1. e;l fi art ,c'I~ e.n t'
t: ~ .r 1 1 rf H l' Ili U .I l A t i~ , t ;t. c9 L i
LI G7 4:· · (,I II r' ~ l-I 'IC' 'ty ,C i;' .Cr .I
LI' ,~' nl t° "tl r, Me b) 1 !Ir11t it r,' [I r". t','I ·.I .1 ^ y. ·1.1 ('; 19 i.I] 44 R1 rf t'~r~ y.r
I . fI
' I7) '3r~ .JI .! LF .l ~',
t" I' '; .t: 1D ·li ·.t 1: (t 111 .r~ il
,C7 () 4"·-1 Xil .Ii C. ''IJ l7 ,i: .;1F I" t^: :· I'iri
'a I; i' 1-I t fl fi 43 61 41 ';: E:'~ t~ i d ;1fl f
+1 1i- ._I ',1 .I : I I: t · IA r'I [:, ., i ~? t 1 r.l
f) Lt 1:1 - X; VI 44 ·I I: 14 ·'!' 17 ~j f'~ I' .r:' IA ...1 ra 5
r1 ;- c ., 'n . r k. I,p .~ l: 1) p4 I;;I ) i u ~n til IG t1 fX~
.1 7 ·: t.l wP r) t: .q; ~'' t'
;~ Ir if s. t m ~'r al c :T r u t1.
(J of F. ·A n, 1 r:. .1 tt. 1: rl
.f' 1, f> ll (1 ~I "7 fl. li.~i R,! 511 R' VA C.I nl la
II, ! ~J C9' ,') 1 T^ III 1.1 n 1:I .: "" ' y (O
"; .)J p ~. !_I SM L; tt .C-r y.t
bl ;U rj ,' a yr rl ;. .,.A ~~ rt el~ IIl f:; R ~J
.. ,.. ;I ..; t` s' I; G!.: r',r Vi f~ J.. !1 CJ 'N :.t ,t.
,C ,; ^~.1 al ~r. JI .l ti t 'J ;it _. I! .4J A3 ~w 11 r'f f!1. r A)
T'
i
I
. . Y
A c.~ c~ ~d .S
>= Claims.^.t could be rsoafrad and if Claimant is
_oLu`.i Q3,x~t~rs3.3=§H
8us?
of Oi!i^al
i^--ntr
r=$'ier
L°
take
SpT~1'rn? $.:.t:.C;i
.JU=
a3GVC=d&aaaCS Wi-raia4SG ;ft~,i'P,iC&i
fi·~ia.
h-.s a0oz= T-a..° that L-
9Y~-=nca n:'*-nay
daeu ,j
w.
~°;lY...
taia s.^_y off ·`e charges,
axes.
in acao'dan-ca
with
Wit! No. 4876
(Rs~z:.°_r, iz is
C1w
firdiLiq oaf this board that the action bf
':r`..'TSOa ?.°~- L.gilt_-a%y "i
carsci'vu5. rit.~Y's~
J ~. ~~
Gs3.i3.~
r3° auEt$1nH4w.
i?"
; vie"m atc:--·tainsd. Claimant shall *x r*3t=ed tc his posi
t :.^.^ s Form an-.3 rei=n--sat '.n t!~,-- a-nest of ttw d"toronaa
betty=en Track Laborer's wage and Track roreaaan's wage-
0. L. 6EJTa=,
ririar ma: ~.~r A~ T.
vmv
nG,' ~a an f
=at i or.
i