PUBLIC LAW BOA.°D NO.
15"v2
CASE NO. 185
PARTIES) ATCHISON, TOPEILk & SANTA FE RAILWAY COI:U?ANY
TO ) ~7
~.7~7~q
DISPUTE) BROTHERHOOD OF c:AINTENANCE OF WAY EST-LOYEES
S TATFrMNIT OF CLAIM:
(1) That the Carrier's decision. to assess claimint E. J. F?cDade's
record with ten (10) demerits as result of investigation held Temple,
Texas on July 10, 1981 was improper because the evidence retorted in
the investigation does not sustain the charges and even if the
charges were proven the discipline assessed was excessive.
(2)
That claimant McDade's record be expunged of 10 demerits and
his personal record be expunged of all references thereto.
FINDINGS: This Public Law Board No.
1582
finds that the Dar ties
her"~n are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as amended, and that this Board has jurisdiction.
In this dispute the claimant was charged with being late for work
by approximately one hour. Pursuant to the investigation the Carrier
assessed the claimant ten demerits for being late to work.
The evidence of record indicates that the claimant was aware that
the investigation was going to be held on July 10, 1981 at 9:00 a.m.
Evidence was introduced that the claimant was aware the investigation
was being held and so notified Supervisor A. L. Gardner as late as
July 8, 1981 that he was aware of the time and date of the investigation. At 9:03 a.m. the investigation.was recessed until 9:30 a.m.
to allow the claimant time to appear.
The claimant failed to appear for the investigation, and evidence
was taken which sustained the charge that the claimant was late to
work by approximately one hour. Under ail the facts and circ=stances
existing herein, there is no justification for setting aside the
discipline which
was assessed.
AWARD: Claim denied
Preston J -bore, Chairman
rganzzation clemcer
nnmo
a..nt~mher 30, 1981