AWARD N0. 296
Case No. 331
PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 1582
PARTIES) THE ATCHISON, TOPEKA AND SANTA FE RAILWAY COMPANY
TO )
DISPUTE) BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: That the Carrier's decision to suspend Claim
ant a (Old Uklahoma) Division Machine Operator T. L. Mort
from service from December 7, 1984 until February 4, 1985 after
investigation November 29, 1984 was unjust; That the Carrier now
lift the suspension from Claimant's record, reimbursing him for
all wa a lose and expenses incurred as a result of attending the
inves wa ation November 29, 1984 because a review of the investigation
transcript reveals that substantial evidence was not introduced that
indicates Claimant is guilty of violation of rules he was charged
with in the Notice of Investigation.
FINDINGS: This Public Law Board No. 1582 finds that the parties
ere n are Carrier and employee within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act,.as amended,
and that
this Board has jurisdiction.
In this dispute the claimant was notified to attend the Roadmaster's
office in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, November 21, 1984, to determine
the facts
and place
his responsibility in connection with his
possible violation of Rule 16, General Rules for the Guidance of
Employes, Form 2626 Standard, concerning his allegedly falsifying
his first-half October 1984 time sheet. Pursuant to the investigation, the claimant was found guilty and suspended from service
from December 7, 1984 until February 4, 1985.
Chief. Maintenance Clerk 3. B. Ensz testified that he had reviewed
the time sheet in question on November 9, 1984 and there were
eleven days charged for special allowances. He testified that in
the Notes column it reflected that the claimant moved from Guthrie
October 4, 1984 to Oklahoma City October 5, 1984. He noted that
the special allowances to machine operators is a camper allowance,
which is Code 45, which is due when they are working outside the
30-mile limit, and if they return to their home station, they are
allowed 60 calendar days pay. Enaz testified that outside their
limit meant 30 miles from their home station or their residence.
He further testified that there was no movement wire filed by the
claimant. He testified that the claimant was not entitled to any
special allowance from October 4 if he had not moved to Guthrie.
Roadmaster V. D. Davis testified that the claimant was assigned as
a machine operator on backhoe in his territory. He testified that
during the first half of October the claimant was assigned to
Flynn Yard. lie further testified that the claimant did not move
to Guthrie during the first half of October.
PLB No. 1592
Award No. 296
Page 2
Track Supervisor Robert R. Ellison testified that the claimant was
in his territory and the claimant's work location was downtown
Oklahoma City
below the elevation, approximately six miles from
Flynn Yard. He further testified that at no time during the first
half of October did the claimant move to Guthrie.
The claimant admitted that he did not move from Oklahoma City to
Guthrie on October 4 and then back to Oklahoma City on October 5.
The claimant testified that the purpose of making the move on the
time sheet stemmed from a phone conversation he had with Mr.'·J. B.
Ensz. He stated that in May of 1984, he called in to bid off the
machine because his 60-day period was almost up and he was advised
he could only bid off if there was another machine available. He
stated that he referred to the agreement book which states that a
machine operator may exercise seniority rights under this rule
after the 60-day period expires, and since he was not allowed to
bid off the machine and not allowed to displace, the expenses
should have been paid by the Carrier. They were not; in fact, four
days expenses were taken off the time sheet for the first half of
June.
The claimant stated that he did not know what else to do and just
made a mistake. The claimant admitted that the reason he entered
on his time sheet the move from Oklahoma City to Guthrie and then
back to OIcluhoma City wan to continue drawing special allowances.
Under the circumstances, there is no justification for setting; the
discipline aside.
AWARD: Claim denied.
res ton J . oore , Clan
Member
Carrier Member
Dated at Chicago, Illinois
January 14, 1985