AWARD NO. 414
Case No. 448
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 1582
PARTIES) ATCHISON, TOPEKA AND SANTA FI's RAILWAY COMPANY
1'O )
DISPUTE) BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYEES
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:- _
1. That the Carrier's decision to remove Southern Division
Machine Operator ICI. D. Surovik from service was unjust.
.;. That the Carrier now reinstate Claimant 'urovik with senior
ity, vacation, all benefit rights unimpaired and pay for all wage
loss as a result of investigation held September 21, 1987 contin
uing forward and/or otherwise made whole because the Carrier did
not introduce substantial, creditable evidence that proved that
the claimant violated the rules enumerated in their decision, and
even if claimant violated the rules enumerated in the decision,
permanent removal from service is extreme and harsh discipline
under the circumstances.
FINDINGS: This Public Law Board No. 1582finds that- the parties
herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of the Railway
Labor Act, as amended, and that this Board has jurisdiction.
In this dispute the claimant was notified to attend a formal investigation in Temple, Texas on September 8, 1987 to develop the
facts and place the responsibility, if any, concerning a report
alleging that he failed to properly discharge his responsibilities
regarding property and failure to promptly report an alleged injury
which he claimed caused him to be absent from duty August 17 and
continuing forward; failure to properly secure authority to be
absent from August 17 through August 28, 1987; and failure to respond to telephone instructions of Assistant Division Engineer
G.
16.
Beanie on August 18, 1987 at Alvin, Texas in possible violation of Rules A, B, D, E, 600, 604, 605, 607, 621, 671, 806 and
1040 Rules Maintenance of Way and Structures, Form 1015 Std., and
Rules 13 and 30, Rules for the Guidance of Employees, Form 2626
Std. The investigation was postponed and heard on September 21,
1987.
G. W. Beattie, Assistant Division Engineer, Southern Division
Headquartered at Houston, Texas, testified that he had written a
statement concerning the matter under investigation on August 18,
1987. That statement was read into the record.
In this statement Mr. Beattie said that the claimant had explained
to him and to J. M. Johnson that in early July he felt a pain in
his back while throwing a switch at Hitchcock. Ile further stated
that the claimant advised he reported it to the foreman, and he
_ - ` _ - _ - /~g2
Award No. '414 - -
Page -2
did not wish medical treatment at the time. Mr. Beattie further
stated that they asked the claimant if he wished treatment, and
he responded that he did not and he thourht the reason his back
bothered him was due to tension and nerves. Mr. Beattie also
stated that he believed the claimant was having a lot of problems
at home.
In his statement Mr. Beattiealso said that on Tuesday August 13
he talked to the claimant and advised him there were three options
he knew of, which were as follows-:
1. You hurt your back on duty, possibly while lining a switch
at Hitchcock, which will require a Form 1420 and a visit with a
doctor, or
2. You hurt your back while doing something off the job, in which
.case, we would need a statement accordingly, or
3. There was no incident at all.
Mr. Beattie further stated that at that time lie asked the claimant -
if lie had another idea that could be considered, and the claimant
replied: "No!" lie also stated that the claimant told him that lie -
did not wish to turn in an injury because it would look back on his ..
record, and the claimant further advised that the soreness in his
back was related to the nerves and tension he had told him about
earlier.
Mr. Beattie then stated that he advised the claimant that a decision needed to be made, and the claimant replied that he wanted to
talk to the Union and then he would get back in touch. He stated
that the claimant called back and said he would fill out a 1421
because lie first felt the pain in his back when throwing the switch
at Hitchcock.
Mr. Beattie further stated that he then told the claimant: "Listen .
very carefully; I'm going to give you some instructions to follow.First, you need to fill out a 1421 in Mr. Beard's presence. Second,
you are to go with Mr. Beard to see a doctor."
Mr. Beattie stated that the claimant replied to these instructions:
"I won't go to a doctor with Mr. Beard. lie's not going to be in
there when I see a doctor." Mr. Beattie stated that he then told
the claimant: "I told Mike (claimant), listen to me carefully. I
am giving you instructions which you are to follow. First, you
are to fill out a 1421 form there with-Mr. Beard. -Second, you are
to go with Mr. Beard to the doctor's office."
Mr. Beanie stated that the claimant then said that he wasn't
working, and he didn't have to be there.- Mr. Beattie stated that
he told the claimant he was authorized to be off work, and he was
to follow the instructions. Mr. Beattie stated that the claimant
said: "I don't have to! You can't make me!"
' ' I$82
AWARD N0. 414 -
Page 3
Mr. Beattie testified that the claimant finally filled out the
1421 after he had attended a formal investigation concerning
another absenteeism. Ile further testified that the claimant
remained off duty from August 17 to August 28 without proper
authority. Ile testified that he personally slated to the claimant that he was not authorized to be off on August 18. Mr.
Beattie testified that the claimant was well aware of the proper
procedures for duty-related personal injury incidents since he
had had five previous personal injuries reported.
The claimant chose not to attend the investigation. The Union
contends that the claimant had been terminated from the employment
of the Carrier, and it was not incumbent upon him to attend. This
position is correct. However, in the absence of his testimony,
all of the testimony which was introduced has to be accepted. The
evidence introduced by the Carrier is sufficient to establish that
the Carrier had just cause to terminate the claimant.
AWARD: Claim denied. _
Preston J. Moore, Chairman
~J
,,G~5'~
la"
Union f ember
Carrier Member