PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 1760
Award No. 47
Case No. 47
Docket No. MW-DET-81-4
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
to and
Dispute Norfolk and Western Railway
Company (Former Wabash)
Statement
of Claim: 1. Carrier violated the effective agreement when
laborer Timothy G. Hurt was unjustly dismissed on
October 19, 1981.
2. Claimant Hurt shall now be returned to his
former position with all rights unimpaired and
that he be paid for all time lost as provided in
Rule 20 of the Agreement.
Findings: The Board, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence,
finds that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning
of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted
by Agreement dated February 2, 1976, that it has jurisdiction of the parties
and the subject matter, and that the parties were given due notice of the
hearing held.
Claimant, a Track Laborer with a crossing gang, was dismissed from
service by the Roadmaster for violation of Rule G. A formal investigation
was requested, granted, and held on September 2, 1981. Thereafter, Claimant
was notified that the dismissal was upheld.
On October 16, 1981, a lumber company, adjacent to the tracks,
delivered to Claimant a 12 can pack of beer as a reward for a favor
performed by the track gang the day previous. Claimant was instructed
to put it away and that they would take care of it after quiting time.
Subsequently, Claimant was observed stumbling around and, apparently,
was unable to talk without slurring his words.
PL
Q I'1 (o0
-2- Award No. 47
An on-ground investigation disclosed 12 empty beer cans
behind a pile of ties. Claimant was told to leave the property
or he would be fired. Claimant said to fire him. He was fired.
The record reflects corroboration of these statements.
There was sufficient evidence adduced, including Claimant's
admission that he was drinking, to support Carrier's conclusion
as to Claimant's guilt.
In the circumstances the discipline assessed was found to be
reasonable. This claim will be denied.
Award: Claim denied.
-(~ S 0.
4VAI~
M.
R1
Christie, Employee Member S. C. Lyons, Carr a Member
Arthur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued December 14, 1984.