PUBLIC LAW BOARD CIO. 1838
Parties Brotherhood of
Maintenance of
Way Employes
to and
Dispute Norfolk and Western Railway Company
Statement Claim is made that Eugene. Parker Forman rights be restored
of and that he be paid the difference between Extra Force Labor's
Clam
and Extra Gang Force Foreman's pay for all dates he is
required to work at the lesser rate of pay, effective with
October 23, 1979, and that he be paid for the 33 days'
actual suspension which he lost, at his applicable rate of
pay. Citing Rile 33 in support of this claim.
Findings: The Board, after hearing upon the whole record and all
evidence, finds that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within
the meaning of the Railway Labor Pct, as amended, that this Board is
duly constituted by Agreement dated March 1, 1976, that it has
jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter, and that the parties
were given due notice of the hearing held.
On Tuesday, September 4, 1979, Claimant Eugene Parker, then an
acting foreman, was responsible for the supervision and operation of
Bachhce No. 50005 operating at approximately MP 573. During the course
of the assignment, the aforesaid backhoe was struck by a N&W train. As
a result thereof,
under date
of September 5, 1979 Claimant received
notification which., in pertinent part, read:
"...You are hereby released from the service of the Norfolk &
Western Railway Caipany . . . . "
An investigation at the request of Organization was held on
Page 2 Award No.
6(p - 1838
Septanber 25, 1979 and Claimant Parker was assessed thirty-three (33)
days actual suspension and discfualified as extra gang foreman.
nnie transcript of the investigation discloses that Train No. M7P,
a westbound coal train, had struck the backhoe. Claimant Parker was new
to the area that he eras assigned to. On September 4th, at approximately
9:00 AM Hackhoe No. 50005 was operating under the supervision of
Claimant. There was no injury :to the operator; however, there was
several hundred dollars worth of damage done to the Ixckhoe.
Collier, the backhoe operator, testified that he was digging in the
six foot per the instructions of the foreman and that a portion of his
outrigger was approximately too feet from the south rail of the
westbound track, near the edge of the ties while he was digging out the
six foot. There was fog earlier in the morning, but at the time of the
col1i.sion there was only approximately 1,000 foot of visibility, due to
a
right hand curve obstructing the straight ahead vision frcsn the east.
Claimant under examination by Carrier's Officers acknowledged that
he did not have a line--up of traffic in both directions in his
possession. However, he testified that he did check the line-up for at
least one of the directions. Claimant Parker acknowledged to Dennis J.
Ahern, Assistant to the Division Engineer - Maintenance, Portsmouth,
Ohio, that he had not spoken to the dispatcher prior to putting the
backhoe out of the six foot fouling the westbound, that he did not have
a line-up in his possession at the time of the incident, that tee only
thing he had was a line-up of eastbound train movements only.
Claimant was removed fran service for violating a Norfolk & Western
Operating Rile requiring a foreman to get penrassion from a dispatcher
-zssT 's
4ew
'te=ar
AGN
'UOT'eS 4e _
XacpaAr TP.zrOR Pue
':~-XW
Uen
.zar t ' -=r
.-sir -H ·s
'aq.a~
·a -v
·pgTu,ap ·PaTtrap aq
IS=
'uT?To a4 qatq OPnTomD 04 P9TT9dlxT aie am sn aaogaq p=oax OL14
vo
·aATss-cx)xa 30
snototzdeo 'fzexqtqze szeadde q-r azat auTTdzasip go aprse bur a.-4as eqq
-4T=;Bd q.etZq suoseaz paqeTtcolqxe TTam
ar4
=o; sqTnsaz aq,4
owl
t=snrZut
que=em pTcmm 4vq4 pzooaz et;q uztTq'M saou943utn=o
CU
ptrr; trna pseog
aq4 pue quauauzad aq oq pzooax aq4 uo zeaclde qou swop trorqen+rTQnbsW
s '4uLllrE"eT:) ·PaTT'pf tr-aq aneq PTA aq *rOLr4Te ~ `pseM
xoqezado aq4 :TPT:~ue4sqns ubnoq4-Ce 'qeaz5 qetT4 qou se^ aotppeq ar.T4 oq
abemep aq4 panTonuT TTe xo; ATaq=,4x43 -sa=r4an=no
ate
go rare trr
sro-,rotadeo you
734r,
qze za.iatt sees passasse aurTchoszp aqs ·ue=.sag
pa-F3rTanb a
Aq
uo*r4eTote aTrtx a
;0
3at=eO Aq uotsnTnuoo ate qxxklne
oq aouapTAa aTdue strreq= t4orqre
:dzx-,s*ror ate pear s2q P3 acL
wrorss-asrad
qons qsanbax oq xaqoaedstp aq4 oq axods xanau aq qep paqqttape
'quarreT:) 'ss~erq
etr4
tro quamrn&a go aoa-fd due btreqqnd oq
=oud
/-99 -oty Pxetv £ abed