Award No. 6
Docket No. 8
ORG File No. WRRG-1902
Carrier File No. 2-MG-1518
Parties Brotherhood of
Ys.intenance of Way Employes
of and
Dispute Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Company
Statement Claim filed on behalf of Western Region Rail Gang Trackman Bryan E.
of Claim: Leach for restoration of his seniority unimpaired and reinbursement
for all time lost at the applicable rate of pay as a result of the
discipline of dismissal administered to Mr. Leach following a hearing
held on Januazy 12, 1976 for conduct unbecoming an employe and for
possession of and use of a hallucinogenic drug while on carp cars
located on Railroad Company property at (rove City, Ohio leading to
his arrest by Grove City Police at about 11:27 p.m. Tuesday, December
23, 1975.
Findings: The Board finds, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence,
that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of
the Railway Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted
by Agreement dated October 27, 7976, that it has jurisdiction of the
parties and the subject matter, and that the parties were given due
notice of the hearings held.
Claimant trackman was one of six (6) off-duty traclsen who were placed
under arrest, and taken from their Carrp Car located on railroad property
by the Grove City, Ohio police for disturbing the peace. A subsequent
search of the roam in which they were arrested produced four (4)
plastic bags containing 52 grams of cannabis sativa, commonly called .
"marijuana", a cigarette and a pipe, broth containing marijuana. The
civil charge originally placed against Claimant and his fellow employees,
was "disturbing the neace". It was later amended by adding "possession
of marijuana." However, such charge was subsequently dropped.
A Carrier conducted investigation on January 12, 1976 resulted in
Claimant receiving the following:
"It has been found that you were at fault for conduct unbecaning an
employee by participating in a disturbance on the camp cars to the
extent that it was necessary for the neighbors to call the Grove City
Police and you are at fault for possession of, and use of, an halluce
nogenicdrug while on camp cars located on railroad property at Grove
- - PL
C3
1
8.5a
-2- Award No. 6
City, Ohio, which led to your arrest at about 11:27 p.m., Tuesday,
Decenber 23, 1975, in violation of Rule 14. The Engineering Depart
ment Rules,
and the discipline administered is dismissal from the
service of the Railroad Company."
The Board finds that Claimant was accorded due process.
The record, including Claimant's self-admissions, provides sufficient
support for Carrier's conclusion of guilt for the charge of conduct
unbecoming an employee. Clain-ant admitted that he was in town drinking
with his fellow traclacpn who were also arrested. He also admitted
hollering at a neighbor. Claimant was apprehended by the police in
the compartment of Canp Car No. 114 free which the blaring noise from
the stereo, as welt as the hollering and swearing, was causing the
neighbors to register complaints with the police of a public nuisance.
The record supports the conclusion that Claimant was a participant
in the making of the noise complained of -by the neighbors and police.
There appears to be doubt as to Claimant's possession and perhaps use
of the confiscated marijuana despite the fact that "pot" had been
smoked and found in the room in which Claimant and his partying fellow
traclY.m°n were gathered. The Board concludes that it is not necessary
that the second charge be proven as either charge standing alone, if
proven, would warrant the imposition of stern discipline.
7n the circumstances, we find that the discipline imposed was not
unreasonable.
The Board is constrained to deny the claim.
Acaard: Claim denied.
A. J. ~ytmingham, ErqLloyee Member L. W. Burks, Carrier r Member
ur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued at Atlanta, Georgia, June 9, 1977.