PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 1850
Award No. 8
Docket No. 16
On3. File No. ERRG-1700
Carrier File No. 2-MG-1471
Parties Brotherhood of Ylaintenanoe of Way Employees
to and
Dispute Baltimore & Ohio Rialroad
Statenmt "Claim filed on behalf of 28 neibers of the Eastern Region Rail Gang
of Claim: listed below for three and one-half hours each at their resrective
rates account Supervisor Hogan sending them back to their headquarters
on Septenber 9, (16) 1975 and only allowing them orgy half hour pay for
the day:
Claimant _I:D:Vo. Claimant 'IX:No.
Sirbaugh, C. 1205605 Sweeten, J.G. 1514740
Yjz!Kenzie, R.D. 1514045 Dyche, C.J. 1514971
Miller, R.E. 7.514831 Mayfield, T.W. 1514868
Linger, J.R. 7106786 Iawis, R.L. 1514043
Arthur, L.V., Jr. 1512350 Stalnaker, R.G. 1514623
Zbth, N.J. 1513687 Atkinson, H.D. 1514829
Price, D.F. 1512468 Wilson,M.S. 1513676
Durst, G.L. 1513558 Ross, M.K. 1511972
~brgan, R.T. 1513533 Drell, R.M. 1513622
Jams, C.E. 1512147 Gloyd, D.S. 1500267
Smith, C.H.,Jr. 1513863 Caruthers, R.D. 1512193
Holconb, B.R. 1510401 Walker, S.L. 1513633
Kean, D.H. 1515210 Ryan, F.M. 1509901 . .
Jones, M.L. 1514619 Beclmer, B.C. 1507037"
Findings: The Board finds, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence,
that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of
the Railway Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted
by Agreement dated October 27, 1976, that it has jurisdiction of the
parties and the subject matter, and that the parties were given due
notice of the hearings held.
These 28 Claimants were members of a 44 member Eastern Region Rail Gang,
. - PL
a
18.50
-2- Award No. 8
headquartered in camp cars located at Burnsville, West Virginia. on
September 16, 1975, the Rail Gang members boarded their buses and travelled to their work site some 10 miles away. It was raining upon arrival
there. Supervisor Hogan, believing the inclement weather would not deter
them from work, directed the gang to lay rail. Sixteen (16) members
of the Rail Gang left the bus and went to work. 7taenty-eight (28), the
Claimants herein, said it was raining too hard to work. Ps a result,
these Claimants were driven back to their camp cars and were paid for -
the actual tire on duty, travelling from their headquarters to the work
site, one-half hour pro rata.
Claimants allege they were entitled to four (4) hours pro rata under
Rule 16 (b) which, in pertinent part, provides:
" (b) . ..Trachman and extra gang men required to report at usual starting
tine and place for the days work will be allayed a mimimunn of four (4)
hours when conditions prevent work being performed..."
Paragraph (C) of Rule 16 provides:
"(c) Less than eight (8) hours are worked for the convenience of
employs, only hours actually worked or held on duty will be paid for."
Absent a failure on the Claimant's part to demonstrate that "conditions
prevented work being performed" and the fact that forty (40) percent
of the Rail Gang did follow Supervisor Hogan's direction to lay rail,
the Board is i
mpelled to conclude that Claimant's voluntary choice to
refuse work on September 16, 1975, thereby removed them from the nonetary protection of Bile 16 (b) and placed them under the Provisions of
Axle 16 (c). Consequently, Clainents were properly paid the actual tire .
thereunder.
9he Board, in the circumstances herein, will deny these claims.
Award: Claims
derri.ed.
A. J. G7ingham, Etmp lo
yee Member L. W. Burks, Carrier Yjarber
%.
Arthur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued at Atlanta, Georgia, June 9, 1977.