-
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 1925
Award No. 37
Case No. 32
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
to and
Dispute Southern Pacific Transportation Company
-Texas and Louisiana Lines
Statement 1. Carrier violated the effective Agreement when San Antonio Division
of Machine Operator Helper Mr. Ronnie J. Farrar, was dismissed from Carrier's
Claim: service on February 15, 1977, on the charge that he was absent from his
assignment on February 9, 1977, without proper authority, and when questioned
on February 9, 1977, concerning his absence on that date, his attitude
indicated a complete indifference to duty, in violation of Carrier's Rules
M-810, M-811 and Rule 802.
2. Claimant Ronnie J. Farrar shall now be returned to work, with pay
for all time lost and with seniority, vacation and other rights unimpaired.
Findings: The Board finds, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence
that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning of
the Railway Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted by
Agreement dated March 23, 1977, that it has jurisdiction of the parties -
and the subject matter, and that the parties were given due notice of the
hearing held.
Claimant, a Roadway Machine Operator was dismissed,after almost six (6)
years of service, for being absent from his assignment on February 9, 1977
without proper authority and when questioned thereon, Claimant's attitude
indicated an indifference to duty, all of which resulted in violation of
Rule M-802, M-810 and M-811. The investigation held at Claimant's request
on March 3, 1977 gave no cause to change the discipline imposed.
The Rules in question, in pertinent part, provide:
"M-802 - Indifference to duty, or to the performance of duty, will not be
condoned "
- -L-
PLa. IqcZ.J
Award No. 37
"M-810 - Employees must report for duty at the prescribed time and place,
remain at their post of duty, and devote themselves exclusively to their
duties during their tour of duty. They must not absent themselves from
their employment without proper authority. They must not engage in other
business which interferes with their performance of service with the company
unless advance written permission is obtained from the proper officer.
Continued failure by employdes to protect their employment shall be sufficien
cause for dismissal.
Employees must not sleep while on duty. Lying down or assuming a reclining
position, with eyes closed or eyes covered or concealed, will be considered
sleeping."
"M-811 - Employees must not absent themselves from their places, substitute
others or exchange duties without proper authority."
Claimant was accorded due process.
There was sufficient evidence adduced at the investigation to support
Carrier's conclusions. Claimant admitted that he did not report for
duty February 9, 1977, that he did not have authority to be absent and
that he failed to advise his supervisor or foreman that he would be absent
on February 9, 1977. The admission of guilt, albiet tacitly, of the Rule
violations in reality ends the trial.
The discipline imposed, in view of Claimant's record, which includes the
fact that he was previously
suspended July 7, 1976 for violation of
Rules MO801 and M-810, was not unreasonable.
In the circumstances this claim will be denied.
Award: Claim denied.
n
~9
A. J. (C nningham, m loyee Member R. W._.ickman, Carrier Member
FC thur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued at Houston, Texas, May 9, 1978.