Public Law Board No. 2203
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
_TO
DISPUTE: and
Consolidated Rail Corporation
STATEMENT 1. Carrier violated Rules Agreement effective
_OF
CLAIM: April 15, 1944, as
amended, particularly
Rule 5,
when it assessed discipline of dismissal on Track
Foreman Angel Gonzales, December 23, 1977.
2. Claimant Gonzales' record be cleared of the
charge brought against him on November 14, 1977.
3. Claimant Gonzales be restored to service with
seniority and all other rights, unimpaired and be
compensated for wage loss sustained in accordance
with the provisions of Rule 5-a.
FINDINGS: Claimant, an employe with four years service, was
dismissed for absenteeism. The evidence establishes
that he was absent without permission and did not
,;-_2 a 3 1hV 0 . 3 ~'
report off duty on five working days in October 1977 and eight
days during the following month. In the main, this evidence
consists of claimant's own testimony.
In assessing the amount of discipline to be administered, it was not inappropriate for Carrier to consider
claimant's prior record, including the discipline-administered
to him in February 1975, March 1976 and April 1977 for previous
absences without permission.
In the light of this record, we find no persuasive
basis for interfering with the disciplinary action administered
by Carrier. Despite Petitioner's vigorous contentions to the
contrary, we are satisfied that there is evidence to support
Carrier's findings and dismissal decision. We agree with the
Organization's contention that no reference to prior discipline
should be made in the charge served upon claimant. That defect,
however, is not prejudicial in this case since no objection to
the charge was made at the outset of the hearing and claimant
admitted that he had been absent without permission on the dates
in question.
AWARD: Claim denied.
Adopted at Philadelphia, Pa.,
/4~
1979.
-03
-/~wD3 P`
y v~..
4
arold M. Westdn, Chairman
-m
.~,.aa~
Carrier tuber Employe Mem er