Public Law.Board No. 2363 -
PARTIES- Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes -
DISPUTE: and
Seaboard System Railroad (former L&N Railroad)
STATEMENT 1. The dismissal of Track Repairman J. A. Haynes
CLAIM: was without just and sufficient cause and ex
cessive.
2. 'Claimant shall be restored to service with
all rights unimpaired and compensated for all
' wage loss.
FINDINGS: Claimant was dismissed for acting in a vicious
and uncivil manner and leaving his job without
permission or notice. '
The record shows that during his tour of duty,,
claimant started an argument with a fellow employee who was busy
pulling ties and then proceeded, without provocation, to call him
obscene names, physically threaten him and brush against him in
an attempt to provoke a fight.
When on the following day claimant was asked
to sign the receipt for a letter notifying him of an investigation
of that incident, he refused to sign the receipt although it was
explained to him that signing would not indicate any admission
a3~3 - A
WO ?D
2
against interest. He remained adamant and abruptly proceeded to
leave his work assignment and Carrier's property.
There is no basis in this record for setting
aside or modifying the decision to dismiss claimant. Carrier's
findings are supported by substantial evidence and there is no
prejudicial procedural error on it.s part. Claimant's refusal to
sign a receipt for the notice of investigation is not a basis for
discipline and has not been given any weight in this Board's decision.
AWARD: Claim denied.
Adopted at Jacksonville, Florida,D.(C( 1985.
Harolc~hI:--iVi~ston, Chairman
Carrier Member Employee Member