PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0.
2366
DOCKET N0. 41
AWARD
NO. 29
CASE N0. 1415
FILE: S1-304-T-80
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
Illinois Central Gulf Railroad
and
Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
"(1) The dismissal of Trackman J. E. Trice was
without just and sufficient cause and was
exceedingly disproportionate to the offense
with which charged.
(2) Trackman J. E. Trice shall be reinstated with
seniority and all other rights unimpaired and
compensated for all wage loss suffered."
OPINION OF BOARD
The Claimant was instructed, on October 15,
1980,
to
attend an investigation concerning an assertion that he
falsified his employment application.
Subsequent to the investigation, the Employee was
dismissed from service.
The evidence of record shows that the Employee was
convicted in
1977
of three counts of obtaining services
with intent to defraud. When the Employee filled out his
employment application with the Carrier in
1979,
he stated
"No" next to (Question No. 10, which asked, "Have
you
ever
been convicted of a crime?" '
The Employee concedes that he marked "No" on the em-.
ployment application, but stated that he did not really
understand the question. We do not find that his lack of
understanding has been fully explained in the record. The
question is rather direct, and should not be confusing to
Awd,. #29, PLB - 2366
an individual who graduated high school and has a significant
number of college credits. The Employee pleaded guilty to
the offense, and his sentence included certain time of incaxrceration in jail. Thus, we feel that the evidence clearly
shows that the Employee knew, or certainly should,have known,
that he had been convicted of a crime.
Certain EEO considerations have been raised, however
they have not been presented to this Board in a manner that
we can issue any definitive rulings therein.
Falsification of an application is grounds for termination of employment, and nothing has been presented in this
case to mitigate the offense. Accordingly, we will deny the
claim.
FINDINGS
The Board, upon consideration of the entire record and
all of the evidence finds:
The parties herein are Carrier and Employee within.the
meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as amended.
This Board has jurisdiction over the dispute involved
herein.
The parties to said dispute were given due and proper
notice of hearing thereon.
AWARD
Claim denied.
~ J seph A. 'ckles
Chair an and N tral Member
~s G c. ' t
J. Sr ib ins Hug HugW,,G. Hai-per 6/
CarAer Member Organization Member
DATE