PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 2439
Award No. 78
Case No. 78
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
TO and
DISPUTE Southern Pacific Transportation Company (Western Lines)
STATEMENT "1. That the withholding of Water Service Mechanic (welder)
OF CLAIM Hector Guerrero from his rightfully assigned position on
the premise of his physical inability to safely perform
the duties is in violation of the current agreement.
2. That Claimant Hector Guerrero be allowed compensation
for each work day he is withheld from service beginning
November 22, 1983, until such time as he is allowed a
three-doctor panel examination as provided for in Rule 32
of the agreement."
FINDINGS
Upon the whole record, after hearing, the Board finds that the parties herein
are Carrier and Employees within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as
amended, and that this Board is duly constituted under Public Law 89-456 and
has jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter.
The record indicates that claimant had suffered an injury in 1982 and that there
were certain restrictions placed on his activities by the Carrier's Chief Medical
Officer in July of 1983. There was a dispute with respect to these restrictions
in .which the petitioner requested that a three-doctor panel be convened to make
the final determination. The records indicate that claimant was furloughed
from service because of a reduction in forces on October 14, 1983. Ile was in
furlough status for the remainder of that month, as well as for the months of
November and December, 1983. He was recalled to service on January 3, 198_4,
and worked continuously thereafter through the month of February 1984 and is
still working to date.
The record of this dispute indicates that claimant was either in a furloughed
PLB No. 2439
· ~'- ~' Award No. 78
Case No. 78
status or he was working during the time period in which the petitioning-organization is requesting compensation for time lost. Further, the issue of a
medical panel is moot due to the fact that claimant has been working since
January of 1984 without medical restrictions. For the reasons indicated,
there appears to be no violation of any Carrier rules and the claim must be
denied.
AWARD
Claim denied.
u
M'l~ _v
I. . Lleberman, Neutral-Chairman
L. C. Scherling, Carrie ember C. F. Foose, Employee Member
San Francisco, CA
October _j , 1984