PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 2444
Award No. 67
Case No. 81
Docket No. MW-81-142
Parties Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
to and
Dispute Southern Pacific Transportation Company
(Texas and Louisiana Lines)
Statement
of Claim: Claim of BMWE Track Laborer C. C. Shelly for 80 hours
at his respective straight time rate of pay and his
record cleared for all charges, allegedly unjustly
suspended from service April 16, 1981 through
April 29, 1981.
Findings: The Board, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence,
finds that the parties herein are Carrier and Employee within the meaning
of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, that this Board is duly constituted
by Agreement dated July 19, 1979, that it has jurisdiction of the parties
and the subject matter, and that the parties were given due notice of
the hearing held.
Maintenance of Way Manager 0. J. Orphan, on June 24, 1981, advised
Claimant as follows:
"On April 15, 1981
you
were dishonest to your
District Manager R. A. Gohmart when you
stated that you never saw or were presented
a letter instructing you to report to your
regular job assignment effective April 15,
1981. Investigation revealed Foreman
Caldwell had presented you this letter
April 14, 1981, but you refused to sign
same. You failed to report for duty at
your regular job assignment at your
regular working hours, without receiving
proper authority, on April 15, 1981.
Being dishonest is in violation of Rule
801 and failure to report to your job
assignment without receiving proper
authority is in violation of Rule M810
of the General Rules and Regulations of
the Southern Pacific Transportation
Company...
PLB - 2444
-2- Award No. 67
For your violation of Rules 810 and 801
you are suspended from service of the
Southern Pacific Transportation Company
without pay from April 16, 1981 through
April 29, 1981..."
Here, the record reflected that Claimant had asked District Manager
Gohmart for authority to work on a different but particular work gang,
i.e., Extra Gang 202, in order to allow Claimant to continue his education
at school. Such permission was granted on the basis that Claimant could
work on said Gang 202 until he finished his education.
The Board finds that the personal arrangement made by these two
individuals was contrary to the applicab le Schedule Agreement and had
been made without participation of the Organization therein. Such
unauthorized arrangement undoubtedly blinded Claimant's common sense.
The procedural error created by the absence of the foreman who was
in attendance but who was permitted to, leave the investigation without
request or agreement or participation by the Organization therein, causes
the Board to modify the discipline to five (5) days suspension.
Award: Claim disposed of as per findings.
Order: Carrier is directed to make this Award effective within
thirty (30) days of date of issuance shown below.
_MT. A. Christie, Employee Member C. B. Goyne, rier Member
Arthur T. Van Wart, Chairman
and Neutral Member
Issued May 11, 1983.