NATIONAL MEDIATION BOARD
PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 2746
BURLINGTON NORTHERN RAILROAD COMPANY
-and-
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
CASE NO. 12
AWARD N0. 12
Public Law Board No. 2746 was established pursuant to the
provisions of Section 3, Second (Public Law 89-456) of the Railway
Labor Act and the applicable rules of the National Mediation Board.
The parties, the Burlington Northern Railroad Company
(hereinafter the Carrier) and the Brotherhood of Maintenance of
Way Employes (hereinafter the organization), are duly constituted
carrier.and labor organization representatives as those terms are
defined in Sections 1 and 3 of the Railway Labor Act.
After hearing and upon the record, this Board finds that it
has jurisdiction to resolve the following claim:
"1. The dismissal of Section Laborer Lawrence E.
Cordon August 28, 1979, and removal from
service July 2, 1979, was without just and
sufficient cause and wholly disproportionate
to the alleged offense. (System File T-M-276C).
Section Laborer, Lawrence E. Cordon to be
reinstated with all seniority and privileges
and paid for all time lost on a continuous
basis, including straight time and overtime."
Prior to his dismissal, Claimant Lawrence E. Cordon was
employed as a Section Laborer in the Track Sub-department at
Sioux City, Iowa. By letter dated July 3, 1979, he was directed
P.L. Board No. 2746
Case/Award No.~12
Page Two
to attend an investigation on July 11, 1979, in connection with
his alleged violation of Rule G. The investigation was postponed
until August 15, 1979, and was held on that date. Claimant was
present and was accompanied by a duly designated representative
of the organization. By letter dated August 28, 1979, Claimant
was notified that he was dismissed from service effective that
date, for violation of Rule G.
The record shows that on July 2, 1979, Claimant sustained
injury to his leg about 9:30 a.m. or 10:00 a.m. His Foreman,
who administered first aid, described the injury as "nothing
serious" and testified that Claimant continued to work for about
half an hour after the injury. Claimant stated that the injury
slowed him down, he limped, and that it was painful when he
walked on the leg. At any rate, at about 10:30 a.m. he was
given permission by his Foreman to drive the Foreman's personal
car into Sioux City, about 11 miles from the job site, so he
could pick up his pay check.
There is no dispute that Claimant did not return to work,
and that officials of the Carrier found him that afternoon in a
bar, drinking beer.' The Carrier's position is that Claimant was
in a duty status at the time, and that his actions were in
violation of Rule G. The Organization argues that because of the
injury, Claimant had been given permission by the Foreman to be
off duty, and this is supported by the fact that Claimant was paid
for only half a day, until noon, on July 2, 1979. The Carrier
P.L. Board No. 2746
Case/Award No. 12
Page Three
points out that Claimant was paid for only half a day because
he stopped working, not because he was permitted to be off-duty.
It is this Board's view that the record supports the
Carrier's determination that Claimant did not have permission
to take the rest of the day off when he left the job to get his
paycheck. The Foreman was quite certain on this point. Even
Claimant stated that "It wasn't really too clear whether I was
supposed to return or not." If Claimant was uncertain ozr this
point, he should have clarified matters. As it is, he resolved
the confusion, if confusion there was, in his favor, without the
necessary approval from his Foreman. Accordingly, the claim
must be denied.
The Carrier, however, has offered to reinstate Claimant
conditioned on successful participation in the Carrier's Employee
Assistance Program. Despite the fact that the record shows that
Claimant has declined participation, that remedy will be reoffered
by this Board, providing Claimant makes known to the Carrier his
acceptance of this offer within thirty (30) days of this Award.
AWARD: Claim denied.
F. H. Funk, W. Hodynsky,_
Organization Member Carrier Member
Richard R. Rasher,
Chairman and Neutral Member