PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO.
2774
Award No. 162
Case No. 162
PARTIES _ Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
TO _ and
DISPUTE-' The Atchison, Topeka and Santa re Railway Company
TATEMENT "1. That the Carrier violated the provisions of
Or CLAIM the current Agreement on November 18, 1985,
when Superintendent. G. H. Gill, dismissed
Trackman, N. E. West, from the service of the
Carrier on the basis of unproven and falla
cious charges, said acts to be capricious and _ _
in abuse of discretion.
2. The Carrier will now be required to rein
state Claimant to his former position with
Seniority and all other rights restored, un
impaired, with compensation for all wage
loss suffered."
FINDINGS
Upon the whole record, after hearing, the Board finds that the
parties herein are Carrier and Employees within the meaning of
the Railway Labor Act, as amended, and that this Board is duly
constituted under Public Law 89-456 and has ,jurisdiction of the
parties and the subject matter.
Claimant, who was working as a Trackman, was injured on September
14,
1985, and marked off on Monday September 16th for doctor's
treatment and was scheduled to return to work on September 23,
1985.
While off duty, Claimant was arrested by the local sheriff and,
i i I I 'i I I i
C N C L L N 0l E ® ~ b N N
a!'
O .G O
al
N
'a
N O C
la
N
H
N
10
.u
.L -O i' 3 .. L
NL
N of L Ol
L
L C
ra
4- ALL'O.C L
L
al
L 0
1J
v- L to c N
L !Y
.io
>a
L -G C 'D N
-H H
al
L
In
rt
0 U C GC N 0 C > U C
'0
3 0
E CD N C N L 0
at
N
al
'O .-1 C N C
al
3
3 U N E
C.1 O~ L
al rp
-H
-Ei
.1 r
Lfi 3 4-
= E
i .-o C
t-
11 ~j .,
L E +'
..~
0
1'
0
.H
.H v- 'O !G U
N N .u .u u
-V 3 0 0 r6
L
..i -.I C
+r
al
C -a
4-
p +r L
,w
11 C -0 0 rG
L
to
-4
C 0 N
N U
ra
L
·H
N E '0 2
rt
.--i .0 -p V
L t h N
+' al
.C .i ·.i >· 3
p 0 ~ f
o,
11 4'
3
u
C ~ a
H
'0
·H, .- C E' G v
·HI
al
U C to
·H
al
ra al al
·.1 ~ H
m -o
ar
-N
'a
fu
>· >
-i t
C
N
fa
'OCT N
.H
al
L
Of
+P
O
al
~N 0
ra al > > a
0
.a L U 2 .-i '·
> al
0 '0
N N >
C C N
a
3 U
al'
C ,O
al
~ rdfor-,O
-i
0 N oil
C >·
a
H
.H
to
L
(a
3H
a
.. L
a1
O
.u
C ?r -H
a E
E ~. +t
.14
L U
H UUH V
a 0
ai a1
C
'p
L L
-i
LIP 0 +j N N L L c a
al
0 UI +J +' -N
L O 9 L C +' C
al
4- ..H 2
C 3
a c
id -5
al
L ra
.V
rb
·H
is
N
~! ·H
H
m
L, L
.H 1J :1
u
L
L
>. w a a
rG
0
a7
0 y 1.l
L 0
4- U! +J .C
.H
L
H L
E +>
> U L FU 0 `t- .0
al
+! L
+l
u
al la al
of
'O
ra
0 O L -V
al
N
+J
L
L N C 0 U N N
(G to al
O. C ·a N
d.i H
.u al - L 0 0
p, .u 0
.,J
L .. 0
.;1 1j
;n
3 +'
L ..i
E
.u O Vl
rt
N
core
a
ra
.C a N N
'O L C U
a
O t 'p
-H 3
u l E 0 .C E
C 0
H H .N
L
H
0 0
-i
.-
.N
.,
o a v ui 'o
m .v
H
ul a el = .- a m
Ola C'J
rt
3 .H
N i 3
>. 10 C
L 'O
·H O, - C
al
+1
"J 0 -0 U
.up .,H y, !G
t N
1J --A
C u C
al
N C N L
41
C L L
1J .IV
u L
-i re
a
to @ x m
1 p m
ai m
+J
a
al
0
~qin
E 2 0 > .o
D
-J 06
a
R, `-
N
.J JO L
O
L
N
al
C
rt
a al r W 0
al al '
· aJ
N L
·H
L c4jwLm ,O
N
fG
O' O
al -'^'
E ,L u
C -P J! :~ +J
L
S- J C
.-i 0
al
h? 0 C
H `~-
^' u
0
al
N
.:P
C-i -~' N A N O
r6
.C +'
0 L U
4-
':
a u n c at m
H
L
u
a:
OL p C > .H
3 4j ~ p
L
LO L 'o 0 p,
v- _H
0
ar
.. H
a
H
41
C -P
L
0 3 3
a ~ `~- -0
al
u
H
IV
al
-P
rl
ul
al
N .C
a7
E D E r 0 3 > E u fG L ~: 1. .a .P U3
Dal
al 1= u O.J
L
.H ~ N Jl O C
L C
.V L +1 ., .- 0 > f- -N
a1
a
al 0 al
L
.N
a .u a m al ..~ H ~- L
:a .v :n m a in
!n 4J
C 10 L 0 .O C al
> i6 0 -H D a: -R 2
H
' O7 Itl 3 :' ~1 ~ H N W E u 'C T L ~6 3 3
. a-7-7q-~6,~-
-3_
AWARD
Claim denied.
,
I. M. Lieberman, Neutral-Chairman
V. I'I.
Garmon. C. F/ -oose,
Carrier Member Employee Member
Chicago, Illinois
March
3',
1988