PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 2774
Award No. 52
Case No. 61
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees
_TO and
DISPUTE The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway Company
STATEMENT "1. That the dismissal of Plains Division miscellaneous machine
OF CLAIM operator Walter T. Taylor, after a formal investigation May
19, 1981, was unjust.
"2. That claimant Taylor be reinstated to service with seniority,
vacation, all benefit rights unimpaired, paid for wage loss
and/or otherwise made whole."
FINDINGS
Upon the whole record, after hearing, the Board finds that the parties herein are
Carrier and Employees within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, and
that this Board is duly constituted under Public Law 89-456 and has jurisdiction of
the parties and the subject matter.
Mr. Taylor was hired by Carrier on April 21, 1980, as a track man. Following an
investigation held on May 19, 1981, Mr. Taylor was di s charged for falsification of
his employment application.
Section b)of Article %I of the October 30, 1978 National Agreement provides as
follows:
"Omission or falsification of information. An employee who has
been accepted for employment in accordance with Section (a) will
not be terminated or disciplined by the Carrier for furnishing
incorrect information in connection with an application for
em
ployment or for withholding information therefrom, unless the information involved was of such a nature that the employee would
not have been hired if the Carrier had had timely knowledge of
it.
The employment application contains a statement by the individual filling out the
application that it was true to the best of his knowledge and that he understood
- 2 - PLB - 2774
Award No. 52
any misrepresentation would be sufficient cause for discharge. In that employment
application, the claimant indicated that he had not been convicted of a crime.
The testimony at the investigation indicates that in 1973 claimant had been arrested for shoplifting and assault. The shoplifting charge was dropped but Mr.
Taylor was fined court costs plus $97.50 for the assault charge at that time. The
charge was simple assault. The employment application also omitted employment with
one company in which he had been discharged and had incorrect information as to the
basis for his leaving at least one other employer. In that instance he had been
fired and he had indicated on his application that he had been laid off. There was
testimony at the investigative hearing that the Carrier Officer responsible for
employment would not have hired Mr. Taylor had he been aware of his previous employment record, as well as his previous criminal charge and conviction.
The Petitioner contends that Carrier abused its discretion in its decision to discharge Mr. Taylor. This is urged by the organization due to the lengthy period of
time between the employment and the ultimate decision to dismiss the claimant. The
Carrier argues that it is clear that claimant had furnished false and misleading
information on his application for employment and, furthermore, he would not have
been hired if Carrier had been aware of his past record.
The Board notes that there is no restriction on the length of time which must elapse
between an employee's initial employment with the Carrier and the time that false
information was discovered on his original application. Thus, although it is regrettable that it took eighteen months from the time of employment until Carrier
discovered the information to be incorrect on the employment application, that
does not in itself prevent Carrier from taking appropriate action. With respect
to the decision to terminate claimant, Carrier was well within its rights in accordance with the agreement to decide that claimant was guilty and should be terminated.
There is no doubt but that he had falsified his employment application and would
not, according to the testimony, have been hired by Carrier had that information
been known at the time of his original employment. Thus, the claim must be denied.
4
PLB - 2774
Award No. 52
AWARD
Claim denied.
I. M. Lieberman,`Neutral-Chairman
d.
G7M.-G
armon, C rier Member S. E. Fleming, Employee ber
April
R9l
1983
Chicago? Illinois