PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 2960
AWARD N0. 70
CASE N0. 66
PARTIES TO DISPUTE:
Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
and
Chicago & North Western Transportation Company
STATEMENT OF CLAIM:
Claim of the System Committee of the Brotherhood that:
(1) The five (5) day suspension assessed Boom Truck Operator
M. L. McLaughlin was without just and sufficient cause.
(Organization File: 2D-2546; Carrier File D-11-24-86).
(2) The Claimant shall be allowed the remedy prescribed in
Rule 19(d).
OPINION OF THE BOARD:
This Board, upon the whole record and all of the evidence, finds and
holds that the Employe and the Carrier involved in this dispute are
respectively Employe and Carrier within the meaning of the Railway Labor
Act, as amended, and that the Board has jurisdiction over the dispute
involved herein.
The Claimant was directed to attend an investigation to be held on
October 21, 1981. The charge read
as
follows:
"Charge: Your responsibility in connection with accident while
operating White Boom Truck, System #21-3074 at the
Intersection of Easton Boulevard and Delaware, Des Moines,
Iowa on October 12, 1981."
Subsequent to the investigation the Claimant was assessed the discipline
now on appeal before the Board.
Several pertinent facts are undisputed. On the day in question, the
Claimant was operating a Boom Truck when he was stopped at a public
intersection controlled by a four-way stop sign. The Claimant testified
that to make room for a semi-truck which was turning, he backed his truck
up. In the process, he struck the car in back of him.
It is the conclusion of the Board that the Claimant had sufficient
culpability to warrant the issuance of discipline. While the semi caused
the necessity to back up, the Claimant struck the car because he, by his
own admission, misjudged the distance between his truck and the car
behind him. Had he properly judged the distance, the accident with the
car could have been avoided.
With respect to the quantum of a five-day suspension, while
substantial, is not wholly unreasonable so as to be considered arbitrary
and capricious. The Carrier must have the right to take reasonable steps
to assure that its employes operate vehicles safely, especially in public
where unsafe operation can lead to significant liabilities.
AWARD":
PLB No. 2960
Award No. 70
Case No. 66
The Claim is denied.
H.
U.
Harper, LMPIIYe Member
Dated:
- 2
G
Vernon, airman
Bbl ~ ') i 1
l:
1f.
l.'
Craw ford, Carrier Member