p' H 11 ~ i0 n 4L·1-. r7 CA. f. np ,1 1·.4 :: li 4·li ~r·1A
 rL· ··t Y·P.r·f^R0.ft N V W
 ti ·3hwt:4_;, L.rr·wp a~;: b G · .aa p~t~l I
 p .- 4'.7 1 a !1 t' w N n w R W O. w f. S ti a 0, I G L w [l Y ttV11 j tl
 N n Y' tf Y r l: ;·1 W fl 1 1'· ;l W h'. CA r V ri ti w tj w n t: f1 O p 7J V H
 t^ Ct ti R J Ir 4. w H C1 · · 7i G ti P r· 41 tl H w ;f ·U it v f 1 w w H b -. C. t 1
 4t 1' 17 a P. :S w l·· w w Ma w :J S ,7 p t1 1 · w p by Iv w r· :1 : Iy 0.t; 1- 1·.1% 1- t l 1 .
 :t'tf w w 11 w r·a V r,u·vi a (Y Ot3 a i'· li 1, --``'.J< w O ,
 ft ft n b r l 1(t. 11 w tl 1 R Y A It N 1 t · 1:. .: : C: a u' u w ~. t ) ·:.' ·'
 r O 1_w u G 1·· r~wo wrt fj 4 V n Y tL ft ·t· 111·: [~ .0
 PP rl F:71 wfo o f~ffY^ \i: OJ'fJ 1:1 p rt .. y1F·tl''i
 Y·H 1 4 1·. t t. F f-14 ft 1. w w I7 H· C7 1r 1''
In r r t · r$1 - i-ip ayp:1 ft 1°It ti i.lv pn1".43 a t·· a.Y~-O li ·) c ·~
 n.b n 1-· n n w R W ti r L:Ii1 (1 4'.1' t· 1111 r :1 :1 W 4- R 11 C1
 111 O rt M OP~G 0· to VR ·S 1, t: 1'· PA ft ft It t- ~.· If 'U ti t1·-i~ f4 J
 ?tt I~o~nwrii~ an(rta's 42 do 11 w
P1 1' :3 G to :3, It 0 -0 C, ~rw BI-w p u · rl3~u`Iry ii N
 n 41
 N h·.: n w n t :: rs a; is p ~i OW :1 Gt .l H s: - rt :: y. 'd
 ·.; a ban f1 7F 0. is b :~-- V R G W 0 0 It ph4 (` w' Mr· w i· ·'
 f7G rbp¢'Y.w o1 lo flow WV.i~p tip b y~l- f . a: :Vt1., 0 H LY.
 b V a th '-; at Y· w .7 S O n F··H t~o~ PC ti lp_O r·· to 11 t- t~
 H GE) fib Et abfYG6i' wttrtQt ;lOR Hr 4.r. S'4tLp.-7!1
 rf R w'J elM· MA J M w b i tv n w R p O w r ·1 r·· 1^AN p 0 in (:
 -a' n I ·r t P F·1·-6' tlo ti.0.H · O i1' (1. to ~ t ~h p Mr" w V U:j p H.n h7
 A w p r r· it 4 IL n 41 M P. ·O ft tr' tt J "J J W n r- tN W· £I 9 4 nl
 H R 1 am ·J a b O O k ft ~1 p r· ML 4.v y of. t'- S.7 Ls ~v
 :S w K W'o r· n n it' 0 M 73 1·- V a 0 17 :1 I- .t n r U Yn f w r] rt :.:
 M it r U PC :J wG 4 p a. u n :3 "l O n III C, W ~L M ·f· w p ~u 1* Y t·t

 · 1 w p. p rn 7Rt· ~ 3< u h o n '· H u L e O O . r· r· H ~.1 w
 r'tr r. r~ W. s W c p .-,a _w r n. t, o
 r 4 ~'· PI 16'ts n n it M n P 1~pl ra 76t t." h·W ft w as 0 O V Iti N H :C.) .:
 n N ft " 41,4 n :·'~C :1 p t-:?· Rn
 r F· :i' n O Y N b N 0 I~ i: r1 `4 R C I~ H G w ~t
 r `S p w 'J G O \· li ·J w r W r W p :T N·'h'1 w i[ W R C' t-i
 w Y. p, w ·0 n w P H t% n V 7 n f: f1 p' M n o 00c ;1 n :r t'
 0r~ tt MOM b4 · Oltt'· wl;H Hp W.h'· H~aOWP H a: O
 Hh i:prwnw :1 CC p wpw F'·~ r M pwr~ Vt t5 ,>
 by PC np oa' yH rY`C w pp.:.;; o td Ow nHnJn4M :; K
 R ww1'·VPOG · .0 ~4n 1 r rtes o w plat- 1-"b w
 p pr I:t~h·%~ H w pN0 a: `C Or pn.v 0.IIL(.:l' wr· .·-. n r
 R :f ": 4 p w tl to ts,0 w ;1 p. .1 Vt- PA-Q4 n a :7 .-1 U W
 t·· It.l: P: ft. P. (] to n · b N ·1 N· w w VI 4.11 Y· ·J p 11 v y,
 < b W (* . Lt . O ft 11 n. t7 - r p r_ 0" w n ro W n
O' G R O 1 W r7 tt t6 r7tt N' P :1 0' r W. f 1 p n p a O ' t i
 1^ w tl b 0 w H u. G o 0 IJ p ,D w M p cX :t':1 :r v : w ,`~
 ow 1·M ~':nn K y ~p$7·~l w u· ~If pP.rnb H
 L.7 w n- no (/' P n :7G H Q"·f~ N 4.~n' NfOHi;~
 w r a· W P· 1( h'· CL U G W O O
 n P R, w r.r n cr R b nhl M W w a p w'J'O ft
 RO .~· HP~ '6lnp· :3 ~ N eg w r· p ~~I~G0H·u
 'Lrf 1 OAPi~E70~ H·h·n la, M w ILI%R cartv6.w ~liii·N· nY
 w G 92 :7 I%PI ·M.tt. O n p rt rr'J g p C p p !·· n P^c n w ti tt p ;.
 Itw r· W ··P O 71.W M H w n(1 n' ..f h'·t`Gw? w~
 w ROG~t"nC nR Ow %"b R 00 to o- 40gor
 r w
 p r :.f at P IA :7 M 'J' tr rt I7 ·J n w R It J a r· w YLG W w r'- 'J
 y w w r· :7 , w b wIT b p W O ~7·O r` .t - u p ' _

 P. V. a`n~Orxw ~lpbp P·hf H4po RCfr OPM Oft ~p~pT~ u0

 R O w R w M O at' w 4 w 1- ILI R l·· · (t. 4 h' · 1·· R 1. n il a rn
 0p ~r·Gt, b ~rpu wr~o r7 r`4 rr p c7' o t·>
 w ~·o~w fro ~ti.m4 Hod r·r·p ~. rrw w~fpwr~ rt^.
 nw CUP, t7 t'i.wg wwilC: p,7 [Y~I Ww r w'Jt~p
 b H IT w J n w F·· b n w - ·d · ,t v7 ar p
 n Hi r· It 1·· It n V. ff 11 1·· 0 M 4 W H r
 :rlf `· IL w ~· n N-o o r
 w n r '1
 '4 r
                                  Patio 2


claimant :gad received additional training through attendance at ruins c=aces, sazacy car preoentations and audio-·ri3ual showings. The Carrier :Ltad Award iio. 1 of Public Law Board ao. 1606 in support o£ cieLr position, as well as Award coo. 2d3 of public Law Board .;o. 913.

 The tranraripc of record contains 133 panes of testimony. There are also nuaarous exhibits by the Carr.'= to supyorc ch=ir pass=ion. The tastiaoir, of ail witnesses has been carefuLly studied.

 T'aa avidenca establishes that the claimant sustained a :minor Lnjur;r to c!ia ring fi:agar of his right hand when he threw a switch at 3Lding 53 Southern Scatei Cooperative, which is an industrial side track facatad within the Roanoke Terminal. The Ql41MIMt sustained the injury when he threw a switch into ravarse position and his pin;er scrucs a shut box which was located close to the switch :1111310.

 'the avi4enee of record irdiaatts that chit shunt box was located toe ^1oaa to cka switch handle. Sea the testimony of conductor
 .zu~titt woo testified that there was close clearance bac-ason t:ze terminal box or shunt box, and the handle of the switch when it was thrown into the red position. He slao testified that when the switch was tarawn, it would not clear your fingers.

 The evidence furtsar establishes chat the shunt box or terminal bo:c had bean .:avad pursuant to this injury. Conductor Proffitt tastiliad that he ehacked the switch. and the box had boon moved over toward the track. and it -.has now out o£ the ors).

 The Organization furtaar points to the face chat the parties have an agras=snc chat as amnloyee's personal sartics record will not be iactu4sd in, or rafarrod to, in the hearing or in the tranacri;2t of the procaedinIs of the hearing, and that the agreement was violated haraln.

 Under this agreement the Carrier may, when the employee is ohargad with bsin3 accident prone, introduce the record as it pertains to previous accidents or Lnjuriss. but only this portion of the clai::ant's personal service record may, bo inel:cdtd In, or rafarred to, is to hearing or in the tranacrioc of the procesdimgs o_° hearing. sio·,~aver, suc_s record stay be attsched and submitted cc the officer reaching the decision as to the amount of discip line to 5a asaeasad. Such should not be censidarud rsgardinv die guilt of the claimant as to tits -hhar;a :cads for t!%4 investigation.

 Tn the instant case there is no evidancs of na31iCanca an the part oc the claimant herein. There is further no svidance of any ruLa vioLatton ay tits claimant. The evidence further is clearly insufficient cc establish chat the claimant was accident prone. Also the evidence does not establish the claimant persists in unsafe practices.

 3 its-34
                                  Award Na. 3~ Page 3


The only act perforated by thy clainant herein was co:apliancs with instructions to throw a switch. V:iara is no evtdanca as to any na&tiganas or unsafe usthod by ·ahic:a the clai;rant threw Cho awitcz involved. On the other hand Cho evidanca establishes that Cho shu.-tc box xaa too eloss to the switch far t:%a switch to be thrown in a safe manner.

 On :Sa fotagoing banis the Board finds that the claitt is valid. 1as Carrier is diractsd to rainstats the olaimanc with seniority and all ochsr rights unimpaired and with pay for cims lost. IE to parties era unable to ascertain the amount due to the claimant, t'co Board -.,till reserve jurisdiction to dstermina t:%a amount.

 A:-;a,T : C1aLH sustained.

 0=Rt inn Carrier is directau to comply witi this award within .rcy days fsc;a t.'^.a data of this avar3.

                        ssto.~ ?". ore. chairman


                        G1 I Akjlie~- 410

                      rg _c .Loa smasr

        r


                                    _r~

                          a_ runner


3 r
 js 34