PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 3241
In the Matter of ) National Mediation Board
Administrator
BROTHERHOOD OF MAINTENANCE OF )
WAY EMPLOYES, )
Organization, )
and )
UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY ) Case No. 72
(former Western Pacifc Railroad), ) Award No. 72
Carrier. )
/ r
Hearing Date: November 18, 1997
Hearing Location: Sacramento, California
Date of Award: February 5, 1998
MEMBERS OF THE BOARD
EmpIoyes' Member: Rick Webrli
Carrier Member: D. A. Ring
Neutral Member: John B. LaRocco
ORGANIZATIONS STATEMENT OF THE CL"
1. That the Carrier violated the provisions of the current Agreement
when it assessed Mr.1. F. Anaya with a Level 2, Letter of Reprimand.
Said action being excessive, unduly harsh and in abuse of discretion.
2. That the Carrier now reinstate Claimant to his former Caaierposition
with seniority and all other rights restored unimpaired, with pay for
all loss suffered and his record cleared of all charges. (960193)
Public Law Board No. 3241
Case No. 72, Award No. 72
Page 1
OPINION OF THE BOAR
This Board, after hearing upon the whole record and all evidence, finds that the parties herein are
Carrier end Employe within the meaning of the Railway Labor Act as amended; that this Board has
jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter of the dispute herein; that this Board is duly
constituted by an Agreement dated July 23, 1982; and that all patties were given due notice of the
hearing held on this matter.
The Carrier charged Claimant, a Laborer, with negligence which caused him to injure himself
and with failure to timely report the alleged on duty injury. Following the investigation, the Carrier
assessed Claimant a Level 1 Upgrade (Letter of Reprimand) for working in an unsafe manner.
Evidently, the Carrier exonerated Claimant of the
remaining
charges.
-~ Subsequent to the imposition of discipline and Claimant's appeal therefrom, Claimant and the
Carrier entered into a settlement agreement. Pursuant to the terms of this agreement, Claimant
relinquished any and all rights arising out of his employment relationship with the Carrier and he
severed this relationship. As a result, Claimant relinquished all right to appeal the discipline herein.
Therefore, the Board finds that this claim is moot and thus, it must be dismissed.
AWARD AND ORDER
Claim dismissed.
Dated: February 5, 1998
-66
alt.
0. 64"~ - -
D. A. Ring1
Carrier Member