Public Law Board No. 3514
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
TO
DISPUTE: and
Consolidated Rail Corporation
STATEMENT Appeal by Melvin Bryner from Carrier's decision
-- _
CLAIM: of July 2, 1983 to dismiss him for unauthorized
"possession, removal or disposal" of railroad
ties.
FINDINGS: There is substantial evidence in the record that
claimant and two other men were observed loading
railroad ties into two pickup trucks and remov
ing ties from the railroad bed. One truck con
tained 30 ties while the other had 19 ties in
it. The men had not obtained the required
authorization for railroad ties removal.
Claimant testified that he had been asked by
John Pahls, a foreman's brother, to help load the ties; Pahls told
claimant that he had permission to take them.
Removal of ties without proper authorization
is a serious offense. However, in the light of claimant's eight
years of unblemished service and his forthright attitude, we will
Award No. 27
Case No. 34
direct Carrier to reinstate him, but without back pay.
AWARD:
Claimant reinstated with seniority rights unimpaired but without back pay. To be effective
within 15 days.
Adopted at Philadelphia, Pa., October 4, 1984.
^v
' t
Haro d~ . Weston, Chairman
rrier M er
Employee Member