PUBLIC LAW BOARD - NO. 3514
Case 39 Award 39
PARTIES Consolidated Rail Brotherhood of Maintenance
to Corporation and of Way Employes
DISPUTE:
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: That Track Foreman J. L: Jolliff was unjustly
dismissed from the service, and that he be reinstated to the
service with seniority and other rights unimpaired and compensated
for all time lost while out of the service.
FINDINGS: The general issue here is whether, under the facts of
record and application of principles generally applied by Public
Law Boards in discipline cases, the Carrier had sufficient cause
for dismissing the. Claimant, or whether some,penalty, short of
dismissal, would be appropriate for the offense committed.
The Claimant had pleaded guilty to felony charges arising
from his possession of cannabis (marijuana). He was sentenced to
a term of one year of probation and paid a fine of $500.00.
The Carrier, relying on testimony adduced at a hearing held
on September 29, 1981, concluded that the Claimant was guilty of
possessing a large quantity of marijuana. On the basis on record,
it cannot be said that the Carrier lacked reasonable grounds for
deciding that the Claimant's actions were so serious that they
merited imposition of the dismissal penalty.
PBL No. 3514 C-39 A-39
Page 2
However, while we adhere to the long line of precedent awards
that have upheld the Carrier's right to determine penalties after
it finds guilt to the charge, in this case, we find that the
discipline imposed was excessive. We note that no notoriety or
discredit accrued to the Carrier following the arrest of the
Claimant. Moreover, the Claimant was considered to be a very good
employee by his Supervisor. Accordingly, on the foregoing grounds,
the Claimant's absence is sufficient discipline, and the claim 'is
sustained to the extent that he will be restored to service with
seniority and other rights unimpaired, but without back pay.
AWARD
Sustained as per the finding.
F J. Domza 4ki '' Ecke hard -Niue Ig J. P. Cassese
Wirier 68pber Neutral M er Employee Member