PUBLIC LAW BOARD NO. 3514
Case No. 98 Award No. 81
PARTIES Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
to -and
DISPUTE: Consolidated Rail Corporation
STATEMENT OF CLAIM: Appeal by Trackman, Melvin Lett, to have
his discipline of dismissal removed from his record and to be
restored to the service.
FINDINGS: The Claimant had sustained a total of fourteen (14)
recorded injuries during a period of slightly over eight years of
employment. Following the fourteenth injury, which occurred on
March 15, 1982, the Carrier scheduled an investigation to determine
whether the Employee was accident prone.
Subsequent to the investigation, the Carrier, relying upon
the record developed, found that the Claimant's injury record was
significantly higher than other employees doing the same work. The
Carrier concluded that the Claimant was accident prone for the
type of work required of him, and consequently held him to be an
unsafe and unsatisfactory employee who should not continue to be
employed.
The Board is of the opinion that the Carrier has met its
burden with respect to the charge of the Claimant being accident
prone. However, we note that the Claimant's prior record is clear
Page 2 PLB No. 3514 C-98(A-81
of infractions. Moreover, there is no indication that he had been
counseled or put on any type of notice with respect to the possibly
serious consequences that could result from his continued propensity
to injure himself. In this context, and taking into account the
Claimant's length of service, we shall restore him to service
without compensation for time lost while out of service.
AWARD
The claim is sustained to the extent noted above.
/% J. Do alski
"Carrier ember
Eckehard ue~ ssig
Neutral Membe7
J. P. Cassese
Employee Member
Dated: