PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 3542
Parties
LO
the
Dispute
Pennsylvania Federation Brotherhood of
Maintenance of Way Employes
VS.
Consolidated Rail Corporation
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
(a) That Dale T. Wagner, employed for eight years, Track
Foreman at time of incident, be restored to service
with seniority rights and all other privileges provided
for by either agreement or past practice. That he be
compensated for all lost time until such time he is
returned to the service of the railroad as a Track Foreman.
(b) That Dale T. Wagner's record be cleared of all charges
brought against him.
OPINION OF THE BOARD
Claimant Dale T. Wagner, an MW Track Foreman at East Penn
Branch in Easton, Pennsylvania, was charged with failing to erect
stop signs. This resulted in the collision of WLAL97 and a_backhoe.
A hearing into this charge was held June 25, 1982, at which time
Claimant was found guilty and ordered suspended for 30 days.
In essence, this case centers on the question of responsibility
AIX
/Z
0
Aa
Case No. 7
PLB-3542 -2- Awd. /#11
Case #7
for the accident. Petitioner contends that Claimant's fault has
not been shown by Carrier. This Board has reviewed the transcript
of this hearing and is fully convinced that Claimant, as Carrier's
representative on site, was responsible for the accident, inasmuch
as it was a direct result of his negligence that the accident occurred.
Had Claimant erected the proper safety signs, both train and backhoe
could have been protected.
Track safety is of primary concern to Carrier for obvious
reasons. Claimant's negligence cannot be sidestepped or lessened
by pointing a finger at the backhoe operator (a non-rail employe)
or the train dispatcher. In order to guard itself from loss, Carrier
has every right to expect its employes to follow rules established
to protect not only itself, but the people and products on or around
its line as well. This Board can see no reason to upset the previous
decision.
AWARD
The claim is denied.
E. Dennis, Neutral Member
J. [odd, Employe Member R. 0'N 1, Carrier Member
Date of Adoption