PUBLIC LAW BOARD N0. 3765
· CONSOLIDATED RAIL SYSTEM FEDERATION BROTHERHOOD OF ' Award No.
Parties MAINTENANCE OF WAY EMPLOYES
to the Case No.
Dispute
Vs. . .
GRAND TRUNK WESTERN RAILROAD COMPANY .
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
(a) The dismissal of Trackman T. Girgen was without just
and sufficient cause, and was arbitrary and capricious, based on unsupported and improper charges.
(b) Claimant Girgen shall be reinstated without loss of
compensation, seniority, vacation rights, and all
the benefits and privileges he enjoyed prior to his
dismissal.
OPINION OF THE BOARD
Claimant T. Girgen was at the time of the incident involved in
this case employed as a Trackman temporarily operating a machine on
Tie Gang 81 out of Valparaiso, Indiana. He had two years of seniority. On June 8, 1979, Claimant was charged as follows:
Y ~ p
37~s
r -2-
You are herby notified to attend a formal hearing to be
held on Friday, June 15, 1979, at 1000 hours, in the Office
of the Division Engineer's, 25 E. Dickman Road, Battle Creek,
Michigan to determine your responsibility, if any, for alleged
violation of the following rules:
Grand Trunk General Rule #2: Safety is of utmost importance.
Working around railroad equipment and property can be dangerous if the safe course is not followed. Employees must follow
all safety regulations and signs and exercise care to avoid
injury to themselves and others.
Grand Trunk General Rule #3: Employees use or possession of
intoxicants or narcotics while on duty or while on company
property is prohibited. (b) Employees shall not report for,
nor be on duty, at any time, under the influence of intoxicants
or any other substance whatsoever (including those prescribed
for them for medical reasons) that will in any way adversely
affect their alertness, coordination, reaction, response or
ability to work properly or safely.
Grand Trunk Safety Rule #3210: Unless engine or motor of power
operated equipment, machinery or tool is shut off and engine
or motor, and all parts of the equipment, machinery or tool
are stopped, do not perform any of the following operations
unless the design permits it to be done safely: (b) Applying
or removing chain, belt or other attachment or device. (b)
Touch chain, belt conveyor or other moving part.
You are also charged with allegedly violating General Rule
#13 on and or June 7, 1979.
General Rule #13: Employees must not act in any way, while
on duty or while representing themselves as a company employee,
that would bring disrespect upon the company.
The above alleged violations allegedly caused you to injure
yourself at approximately 0600 hours, CST on June 7, 1979, at
Valparaiso, Indiana. You have the right to be accompanied at
this hearing, without expense to the Carrier by a representative of your own choosing, and to present witnesses of your
own choosing and to present witnesses in your own behalf. You
will be given the opportunity to present testimony and to
question others who may testify at the hearing.
f
37 ~S- a
-3-
A hearing into the matter was held on June 22, 1979. As a result
of that hearing Claimant was found guilty as charged and dismissed
from Carrier's service. A record of that hearing has been made a
part of the record before this Board. The Board has reviewed that
record and must conclude that Claimant's dismissal was appropriate.
Claimant reported to work under the influence of alcohol and was
careless in the manner in which he handled machinery. Carrier cannot
tolerate such actions in an employe. He violated two major rules
in this instance. His continued employment could be a risk to his
own well being and a liability to Carrier.
AWARD
The claim is denied.
R. Dennis, Neutral Member
W. E. Larue, Employe Member ien, Carrier Member
02
Date oVAdopti n