Public Law Board No. 3794
PARTIES _ Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes
DISPUTE: and
Seaboard System Railroad
STATEMENT Claim that Trackman F. D. Wakefield be reinstated to
CL IM: service with seniority and all other rights unimpaired
and be paid for all time lost.
FINDINGS: Claimant was- dismissed after he entered a plea of
"Nolo Contendere" in a Florida court to a charge of
possession of marijuana and was sentenced to one year
probation, 100. hours community service and court costs.
As numerous awards have held, the fact that the mis-
conduct occurred while claimant was off duty is not a valid defense
to Carrier's charges. No persuasive ground is perceived for substitut
ing our judgment for that of Carrier in this matter. At this time,
possession of marijuana constitutes a sound basis for dismissal.
In reaching this decision, the Board has found no
merit or evidence to support Carrier's conclusion that claimant was
guilty of "dishonest" and"immoral " activities. The Board's findings
rest on findings of Carrier as to illegality. Claimant's misconduct
reflects on his judgment and responsibility, qualities that are relevant
. 3 )9V-
in the employment relationship.
AWARD: Claim denied.
_ Adopted at Jacksonville, Florida, y~.ld,,.,~,~ 1985.
r
M. West &n, Chairman
er Member Employee em