HMI-IERI300D OF IG02TIENANCE OF FAY EMIPLOY
EFS
and
ILLINOIS CENTRAL RAILROAD
PUBLIC LAW HOARD No. 4331: CASE No. 14
STATEKEW OF VHE
QAINI
L. Bond was
improperly
dismissed.
OPINION OF THE BOARD
The Claimant, Mr. Lemon Bond, sustained an injury on September 30,
1987. Subsequently, Mr. Bond was dismissed from employment with the
carrier for being accident prone.
The record of this case indicates that during the period November 5,
1974 to September 30, 1987, Mr. Bond sustained fourteen (14) injuries.
During this same time period, a group of 210 track department employ
ees
sustained an average of 2.44 injuries per employee. Notwithstanding
differences in type of work performed, nature of injuries and time lost
from work among the employees, Mr. Bond's accident record is significantly higher then the average.
Mr. Bond attended a remedial safety training class and therefore
knew or should have known
the importance
of safe work practices. There
is substantial evidence from which to conclude that Mr. Bond is accident
prone.
We find no basis in the record to grant leniency in the application
of discipline.
AWARD
Claim denied.
Ronald L. Miller
Cha
irman and Neutral Member
J.S.D. . olomay
carrier member organization Member
2(J ~..-,~ (g gg
Date